《律师本色》前情提要 Previously on The Practice
怎么了 What?
包里有个人头 There is a had in the bag.
是我昨晚在酒吧认识的那个女人 It's a woman I met a bar last night.
你带着她的头干嘛 What are you doing with her head?
有人把它放进去的 Somebody put it there.
George Vogleman George Vogleman
现在以涉嫌谋杀Susan Robin的罪名逮捕你 you are under arrest for the murder of Susan Robin.
杀你女朋友的人不是George Vogleman The guy who killed your girlfriend is not George Vogleman.
检方指控的依据之一是 Part of their case is the notion
Susan不可能会去找一夜情 that Susan could never have gone off on some one nighter.
你能想到任何她会这么做的原因吗 Can you think of anything that could explain why she would?
我跟Susan 我劈腿了 I had been a little unfaithful to Susan.
正如我跟你父亲所说的 As I said to your dad
我相信他们抓错人了 I am convinced that they got the wrong guy.
也就是说整件事要么是 That means that this thing
为了陷害George Vogleman was either mission to frame George Vogleman
要么就是冲你姐姐来的 or somebody was after your sister.
有没有可能 Is it possible that your sister
你姐姐的生活中有着不为人知的一面 could have kept some part of her life secret?
她的确有点沉迷于网络 She did spend a lot time on the internet.
你当事人是最后和她在一起的人 Your guy was last seen with her.
他还带着她的头 He had her head.
如果George Vogleman没有杀她 If George Vogelman didn't do it
那么对真正的凶手而言 he certainly represents reasonable doubt
他肯定就构成了合理怀疑 for whoever did.
你什么意思 What are you saying?
他们不会重新展开调查 They are not gonna reopen the investigation.
我不能命令警方 I don't give orders to the police
指导他们怎样调查案件 on how to investigate their cases.
你只要你命令他们进行调查就行 I am asking you to order them
没说怎样调查 to investigate period!
要是他们相信已经抓到了凶手 Well I can't order them to keep looking
我没法命令他们继续追查 if they are convinced they have the killer.
如果他们认为他就是嫌疑犯 If they are thinking he is a suspect
我们有一套机制来处理 we have a device to deal with that,
我们把它叫做"审判" we call it the trial.
Jay 我真的很感谢你愿意作证 Jay, I really appreciate your willingness to testify.
我不一定帮得上忙 Frutt女士 I'm not gonna be that much help, Ms. Frutt.
我不确定你的当事人是无辜的 I can't say I think your client is innocent.
我明白 但是或许只有你能够解释 I know, but you are the only one who can supply
为什么你女朋友会和George Vogelman a possible reason why your girlfriend would have gone to a motel
一同去旅馆开房 with George Vogelman.
我不想帮那个杀害了我姐姐的家伙 I'm not crazy about helping the guy who killed my sister.
我们只是想请你说出关于上网的事情 All we're asking is that you talk about the internet thing.
不行 I can't.
Roberts医生 Dr. Roberts,
你比任何人都要了解George Vogelman you know George Vogelman better than anybody.
但我不敢说我真的了解他 But I wouldn't be able to say that I truly know him.
我只在工作时间见到他 我.... I see him at work, I...
你看 他因为这场命案被逮捕 look, his being arrested for this crime
我们整个医院都受到影响 It's hurt the whole office.
我真的不想坐到证人席上 I really don't want to step into a witness chair
连累我们医院的声誉 and associate our medical corporation
他在你的婚礼上当过迎宾员 He was an usher at your wedding.
我也不相信他们对他的指控都是事实 And I couldn't imagine him doing what they're accusing him of.
可我同样不敢相信 But nor could I imagine
他会那么迷恋色情片 his taste for pornography
还有他会和酒吧认识的陌生人回家过夜 or his going home from bars with strangers.
要我做证的话 我最多只能说 At best, all I could testify to is that
我以为我了解他 I thought I knew him.
连他的朋友都不帮他 Even his friends have pulled away.
你现在掌握了些什么 What have you got?
没有暴力伤人的经历 为人诚实 No history of violence. Reputation for honesty.
主动向警方报案 Came forward on his own volition.
-孤僻 -在报纸上登交友广告 - Loner. - Advertises in the personals.
-喜欢色情片 -喜欢独处 - Likes porno. - Keeps to himself.
够了 All right.
你问了多少个朋友或同事 How many friends or associates you talk to?
12个 可能还不止 A dozen, maybe more.
有没有人说是真正了解他的 Anybody say they really knew the guy,
我的意思是完全了解 i mean completely?
没有 No.
好极了 Great.
我觉得事情的经过是这样的 Ok, this is what I think.
他们一起去的汽车旅馆 They go to the motel,
这个女人不识时务地拒绝了他 then this woman rejected him at the wrong time.
也许他觉得在性方面受到了侮辱什么的 Maybe he felt sexually humiliated or whatever.
这是对他来说最严重的嘲讽 This is the ultimate ridicule,
于是他抓狂了 and then he snapped.
然后就砍下她的头? Chopped off her head?
接着 他该怎么做 Now, what's he gonna do?
他不可能逃得掉谋杀罪 He's got no chance of getting away with it.
如果伪装成被陷害 他脱罪的机会更大些 He's got a better shot at making it look like he was framed.
于是他把死者的头装进自己的医疗包 So he sticks her head in his medical bag
好戏就这样开场了 and the big show begins.
孤僻 Loner.
-足科医生 -是他杀的 - Foot doctor. - He did it.
他很生气 后果很严重 Got mad. Lost his head.
孤僻 The loner.
是吗 还有别的吗 Is that it? Anything else?
马萨诸塞州没有死刑 对吧 There's no death penalty in Massachusetts, right?
本字幕由豆瓣KW组翻译制作
免责声明:本作品之片源来自互联网，版权归原电视公司所有。字幕由豆瓣KW组制作，仅供个人影视制作学习交流之用，任何组织和个人不得公开传播或用于任何商业盈利用途，否则一切后果由该组织或个人承担！本站和制作者不承担任何法律及连带责任!
欢迎访问 www.douban.com/group/kelliwilliams
字幕交流QQ群：128462677
听写： Melly Razorback
翻译： 林紫秋
校对： 美溪客
时间轴 后期： 林紫秋
《律师本色》第三季 第六集 "One Of Those Days"
你要一直抬着头 George You keep your head up, George.
不要摇头说 "不 不 不" Don't be shaking it "No, no, no."
始终把头抬起来 Just keep your head up.
他们有他们的说法 They're gonna tell their story,
我们有我们的说法 and then we're gonna get to tell ours.
明白 Ok.
洗手间 有谁要去吗 Bathroom? Anybody need to go?
都准备好了 All set.
我去过了 I went.
行 Ok.
他是最后和死者在一起的人 Last seen with her.
她的头颅就在他的包里 Her severed head was in his possession.
他的车上有她的血迹 Her blood was in his car.
我们的证据会显示 没有任何一个... As our case will show, there is not one piece...
没有一件物证或一个人证 not one piece of physical or testimonial evidence
指向其他任何人 that points to anybody
它们全都指向George Vogelman other than George Vogelman.
这是因为George Vogelman丧心病狂地 That's because George Vogelman gruesomely,
残忍地谋杀了Susan Robin hideously murdered Susan Robin.
事实再清楚不过 It's not even a question.
有时候 事实并非像表面看起来那样 Sometimes how things look are not how they are.
所以我们才会有繁琐的审判程序 And there's a reason we bother with the trial.
我们只要求你们保持客观 All we ask is that you be objective
并且仔细倾听庭上的每一句话 and you pay close attention to everything you hear.
Tisbury先生 Mr. Tisbury.
控方传唤Helen Gamble出庭作证 The Commonwealth calls Helen Gamble to the stand.
他的律师打电话给我 His attorneys called
让我去他们的办公室 and asked me to come down to their offices.
为什么他们会打给你 Gamble女士 Why did they call you, ms. Gamble?
他们其中一个是我的室友 One of the attorneys there is my roommate,
另外一个是我的前男友 another one I've dated.
所以他们觉得 So they figured in you
你是一个好说话的检察官 they'd get a sympathetic district attorney.
我不认为他们是想要特殊照顾 I don't think they were expecting special treatment.
他们想让当事人主动配合警方 They wanted to surrender a client
希望我能够帮助他们保持案件低调 and hoped I could help them do it quietly.
他们有没有告诉你案子的详情 Did they tell you any details about the case?
没有 他们只是让我去办公室 No. They simply asked me to come to the offices.
他们说很严重 They said is was serious.
所以你去了 So you went.
是的 Yes.
到那里之后发生了什么 And what happened after you got there?
他们带我进了一间办公室 They took me into a room
告诉我他们当事人的 and informed me that their client
医疗包里有个人头 had a human head in his medical bag.
你是什么反应 How did you respond?
我以为他们在恶作剧 I thought they were joking.
然后他们指给我看那个包 Then they pointed to the bag.
是这个包吗 Is this the bag?
没错 Yes.
请求标记并记录 法官阁下 Mark and identify, your honor.
记录在案 证据一 Marked, exhibit one.
然后呢 Gamble女士 And what happened next, Ms. Gamble?
他们叫我看那个包里面 They asked me to look in the bag.
你看了吗 And did you?
看了 Yes.
你看见什么 And what did you see?
一颗人头 A human head.
现在 Gamble女士 允许我... Now, ms. Gamble, if I could...
你开什么玩笑 You gotta be kidding me.
反对 Objection!
律师 Counsel...
冰柜里的东西 是我想的那个吗 is what's in that cooler what I think it is?
-证明证据的连贯性 法官阁下 -我反对 - Chain of custody, your honor. -I object to that!
去我的办公室 律师 In chambers, counsel.
陪审团 休庭10分钟 Members of the jury,10 minutes.
走吧 Let's go.
单是把那东西带到庭上 Just bringing that thing in
就足以导致无效审判了 is grounds for a mistrial.
你希望刚举示第一个证据 You want a mistrial
就宣布无效审判吗 Ellenor on the first witness, Ellenor?
这是为激怒陪审团耍的花招 That's a stunt to inflame the jury.
都听我几句说行吗 Would it be all right if I talk?
你最好解释清楚 It better be good.
法官阁下 Your honor
这个案件本身的怪异程度 the fact that this is so grotesque,
与案件是有关联的 it's relevant.
怎么有关 How?
他把人头放在自己的包里 He had it in his bag.
任何人带着这样的东西到处逛 Anybody who could carry something like that around,
都可以证明他的精神状态 it's evidence of the kind of psychotic mind
这种精神状态跟本案罪行相对应 that goes with the very crime
第一 他不知道人头在他包里 First of all, he didn't know it was in his bag.
就算如你所说 他没杀人 Even under your theory he didn't do it,
他在知道人头在他包里之后 he knowingly had it in his bag
至少又过了三个小时 他才报警... for more than 3 hours before he called...
因为他吓坏了 because he panicked.
我坚持我的说法 你可以在庭上反驳 You make your arguments, I'll make mine.
法官阁下 Your honor,
他们会说他是无辜的 they'll be saying he behaved like an innocent man.
当他发现的时候 他立即就报警了 As soon as he saw it, he called the police.
但他其实没有这么做 Well, that's not what he did.
他把它带到车上 He carried it back to his car,
开到律师办公室 drove to his lawyer's office,
拿着它乘电梯 carried it up the elevator
你不必把人头带过来 You can introduce all that
也可以在庭上把这些都说清楚 without bringing the head into court.
他想要吓唬陪审团 He wants to horrify the jury,
法官阁下 这招太... your honor. That's...
我坚持认为这是与案件有关联的 And I maintain that's relevant.
正常人应该会被吓到 A reasonable person would be horrified.
正常人会觉得反感 A reasonable person would repulse
甚至都不敢靠近那个包 and not even approach the bag again,
更不要说把它装好 带上车 much less pack it up, go to the car
律师 Counsel
有理由让陪审团 It's legitimate for the jury
体验一下那种恐怖的感觉 to experience some of the horror
这样他们才能判定在那种情况下 so they can assess what's a reasonable reaction
什么样的反应才是合理的 under the circumstances.
人头不准呈堂 The head is inadmissible.
我希望你在庭上训诫他 法官阁下 I want him sanctioned in open court, your honor.
光是拿冰柜... The cooler alone...
你为什么就不能乖乖 Why don't you just be satisfied with my ruling
听从我的裁定呢 and leave it there?
冰块化了而已 That's just ice settling.
然后他给了我 他和被害人 He then gave me the address of the motel
去的汽车旅馆地址 that he and the victim had gone to.
你去了? And did you go there?
是的 Yes.
和McKrew警长 Frutt律师一起 Along with detective McKrew and attorney Frutt.
我们到了那里 发现了尸体 We went there and discovered the body.
Vogelman先生整个过程中 Mr. Vogelman cooperated
一直很配合 是不是 at all times, did he not?
没错 Yes, he did.
事实上 正是因为 In fact, the only reason you or the police
Vogelman先生主动跟警方联系 know a crime had even been committed
你和警方才知道发生了凶杀案 is because Mr. Vogelman came forward.
是这样 That's true.
他车厢地板上的血迹 And blood scrapings from the floor boards of his car.
基因测试结果与受害人完全吻合 Exact genetic match with the victim.
他们在酒吧里聊得很融洽 They seemed friendly at the bar,
但没觉得他们之间有暧昧 but there was nothing sexual going on.
他们是一起离开你的酒吧的吗 先生 Did they leave your bar together, sir?
不是 他先走 No. He left,
过了10到15分钟之后 女的才走 and then she left about 10 or 15minutes later.
我女儿不是个随便的人 My daughter was not a promiscuous woman.
就算她去了酒吧 Well, even if she would go to a bar,
我估计她的确去了 which I guess she did,
我也无法想象她会和一个 I couldn't ever see her going back to a motel
酒吧认识的陌生人去开房 而且... with some guy she just met. Plus
而且什么 Plus what?
无意冒犯 但是... Sorry, but...
他老了点 长得也不怎么样 he's kind of old and not very good-looking.
房间里采集到的样本 The only samples in the room
全部来自被害人和被告 belonged to the victim or the defendant.
所以如果真有其他人进去过 So if somebody else did go in there
那这个人一定是会轻功 It had to be immaculate.
以前也有过吧 It's happened,
凶手离开后没留下任何物证 murderers leaving behind no physical evidence whatsoever?
有过这样的案例? It has happened?
没错 但可能性... Yes, but the odds are...
有没有这样的案例 有还是没有 警官 It's happened? Yes or no, detective.
有 Yes.
还有 警官 And, detective,
你知不知道一个叫"诗人杀手"的连环杀手 you're familiar with a serial killer known as the poet?
我不认为... We don't believe that...
我问的是 The question is,
你知不知道一个叫"诗人杀手"的连环杀手 are you familiar with a serial killer known as the poet?
知道 Yes.
接下来 还是回答"是"或"不是" Again, yes or no
这个杀手会把受害者砍头 this person decapitates his victims?
是或不是 Yes or no.
是 Yes.
但你把他排除了 But you ruled him out.
"诗人杀手"会把手也砍下来 The poet severs the hands as well
而且会把头留在现场 and leaves the head behind.
他不会带走 He doesn't take it with him.
跟我们预期的一样好 It's gone as well as can be expected.
这也叫好? This is going well?
连我自己都开始觉得我有罪了 Even I'm beginning to think I'm guilty.
他们在庭上举示的 Look, everything they put in,
我们都有所准备 we were ready for.
并没有出现让我们措手不及的证人 It's not like they put up some surprise witness
作证说你猥亵猫或什么的 that you've done some strange things to cats or something.
George 你明白我的意思 George, you know what I mean.
所有的证词都在我们预料之中 We've expected all of this testimony.
虽然的确对我们不利 It's not that it's not damaging,
但至少没有让我们措手不及 but there haven't been any surprises.
那现在怎么办 So what now?
我们或许可以结束举证 We might want to rest.
-结束举证? -什么 - Rest? - What?
好好想想 Well, think about it.
他们一共只证明了两件事 All they've proven is 2 things:
他曾跟她在一起 他带着她的头 He was with her. He had her head.
要我说 这已经很充分了 Pretty good proof, ask me.
没有凶器 没有目击证人 No weapon. No eyewitness.
他们只证明他跟尸体有关联 They've tied him to a corpse,
-没证明跟谋杀有关联 -即便如此 Eugene not a crime. - Still, Eugene
你不能在这个时候结束举证 You can't rest on that.
我不是说非得这么做不可 Look, I'm not sayin' it's the thing to do,
但必须承认 but let's face it
我们有什么 what do we have?
说他是个好人? Nice guy?
也许我们可以跟陪审团说 Maybe we should just say to the jury,
嘿 我们已经准备好了辩护的证据 hey, we were ready to put on a defense,
但因为他们没有完成举证责任 but since they didn't make their burden,
-我们就不用出示了 -那太冒险了 - we don't need to. - That is such a risk.
我们已经提出了"诗人杀手"的可能性 We already sprinkled on the idea of the poet.
网友 或者跟踪狂? Internet. Maybe a stalker?
你不能结束举证 You can't rest.
太缺乏说服力 Pretty lame.
Eugene 看起来完全就是他干的 Eugene, he looks completely guilty.
你不能站起来说他们没完成举证责任 You can't just get up and say they didn't make their burden.
这样太愚蠢了 That's stupid.
或许我们可以说 Maybe we could say he involuntarily
他是无意识地砍了五次头 cut her head off 5 times.
-哦 真好笑 -你说我蠢? - Oh, that's real funny. - Are you calling me stupid?
-好了 -我没说你蠢 - All right. - I didn't call you stupid.
我是说结束举证的做法很蠢 I said it would be stupid to rest.
够了 Ellenor All right. Ellenor...
你怎么说 what do you think?
我明白Eugene的意思 Well, I see Eugene's point,
但我不认为陪审团会 but I don't think a jury is gonna let him go
仅仅因为举证责任放过他 on a burden of proof thing.
我觉得最好的辩护理由就是George本人 I think our best defense is George.
他诚实 他要表现出诚实 He's honest, and he plays honest.
如果不是George杀的 那是谁 If George didn't do it, then who?
这不是我们需要回答的问题 It's not our job to answer that question.
我明白 I realize this,
但我一直在想这个问题 but it's the question I keep asking,
陪审团在审议的时候 and the jury's gonna be asking it
一定也会想这个问题 back in that room.
等等 等等 Hold on. Hold on.
我明白你怎么想的 Ellenor If I understand your thinking on this, Ellenor,
警方停止了调查 the police basically stopped looking.
这就是我们的切入点 That should be our defense.
我们不知道除了George之外 The only reason we don't know
还可能是谁干的 who else if not George is
是因为警方从未想过这个问题 because the police never asked that question.
这就是你们辩护的关键 That's what you have to key on.
可是人头就在George的包里 But the guy had her head in his bag.
莫非我们要把审判的对象变成警方 We're gonna put the police on trial
追问他们为什么不去调查其他嫌疑人? for not asking who else could have done it?
-我们不能这么做 -你们在玩火 - We're not putting the police on trial. - You guys are playing games.
归根结底 他毕竟带着她的头 At the end of the day, he had her head.
这跟调查不充分完全没有关系 That's got nothing to do with any faulty investigation.
人头在他手上 He had her head.
那你告诉我们怎么做 爱因斯坦 So tell us what to do, Einstein.
你知道吗 Lindsay You know something, Lindsay?
你最近有点犯贱 You've been bitchy a lot lately
争吵解决不了问题 This isn't helping anything.
我同意Jimmy的话 I agree with Jimmy.
我犯贱? I'm a bitch?
他的辩护策略 On his defense theory.
你必须为George辩护 You have to defend George.
而不是去攻击警方 You can't be attacking the police.
这两件事都要做 We gotta do both.
我们得让George出庭作证 We gotta put George up,
让大家相信他的为人 let him be as convincing as he can be,
同时我们要指出凶手另有其人 and we gotta open the door to other possibilities.
等等 嘿 Excuse me. Hello.
男朋友一个人住 Boyfriend lives alone.
弟弟住在大房子里 Brother, big house.
所以呢 So?
所以 案发时间在凌晨1点到3点 So, the murder took place between 1:00 and 3 A.M.
没人怀疑过他们吗 Why weren't they considered?
他们被排除了 They were checked out.
他们都是好孩子 They're both choirboys.
话是这么说 但是 Yeah, but still,
要是大家都睡着了 就没有不在场证明 no official alibi if everyone's asleep.
为什么不对他们用B计划 Why not plan B them?
反正他们都要上庭作证的 They're going to testify anyway.
什么是B计划 What's plan B?
也许值得一试 It might be worth a try.
给他们温和的B计划 Give them a soft plan B.
B计划是什么 What's plan B?
有点冒险 Talk about a risk
你有更好的主意吗 Have you got any better ideas?
好吧 但一定要先确保不会弄巧成拙 All right. But first we have to be sure it won't backfire.
仔细审查案卷 Comb every report.
确保这个办法可行 Make sure it's really available.
他们都做过笔录 They both gave statements.
逐字逐句地看几遍 Dissect them.
你负责男朋友那边 弟弟我来 You take the boyfriend. I got the brother.
B计划到底是什么东东 What the hell is plan B?
简单地说 就是我们把矛头指向其他人 Basically it means we point the finger at other people.
这很危险 因为通常 It's very dangerous, because normally,
当辩方对案件事实提出自己的说法 when the defense starts hatching theories of their own,
陪审团可能会把举证责任换到我们这边 the jury can shift the burden back to us,
这是我们最不想看到的 which we definitely do not want.
你说"温和"是指... And when you say soft
意思就是说没那么强硬 Our soft plan B is we do it more gently.
我们不去直接指控谁 Instead of accusing,
而是提出"假使...怎样" it's more like "What if-ing".
这样疏离陪审团的可能性要小些 It's less likely to alienate the jury...
但这种策略仍然风险很高 but it's a risky strategy.
那干嘛还这么做 Well, then why do it?
因为我们实在没什么其他的选择 Because we don't have much else to go with.
怎么了 What?
我看了报纸上对我的报道 The things that I've been reading about myself in the papers.
我不喜欢诬赖别人 I'm not a big fan of accusing people falsely.
George 我们打的是谋杀案 George, this is a murder trial here.
而你是嫌疑犯 You're the defendant.
首先 我要感谢你出庭作证 Jay First, I want to thank you for testifying, Jay.
其次 对你的遭遇我表示遗憾 And second, I want to convey my sympathy.
你是Susan Robin的男友 是吗 You were Susan Robin's boyfriend?
是的 Yes.
你爱她吗 And you loved her?
是 I did.
Jay 我们听了很多人的证词 Jay, we've heard a lot of testimony to the effect that
都说Susan不可能 it was uncharacteristic for Susan
一个人去泡酒吧 to have gone to a bar alone and especially to a motel
更不会跟一个刚认识的人去旅馆开房 with a man she had just met.
你认同他们的说法吗 Would you agree with that testimony?
认同 Yes.
接下来的问题可能会让你为难 I know this is a difficult question,
我想先谢谢你的诚实 and I thank you in advance for your honesty.
你的确知道她那天晚上 But you do know of a reason
行为不寻常的原因 why she may have behaved uncharacteristically that night,
是吗 don't you?
可能是那个原因吧 A possible reason.
你能告诉我们吗 Could you share that with us?
Susan在她死的那一天 Susan had discovered me with another woman
发现我跟另外一个女人在一起 the day of her death.
所以说有可能 她去酒吧 So it could have been she went to a bar
又跟另一个男人去旅馆 and then to a motel with another man
是因为她很伤心 out of hurt?
想要报复你? As a way of lashing back?
我觉得她不会这么做 I don't think she would do that.
我真的觉得不会 I really don't.
但我也不能排除这种可能性 But I can't exclude the possibility? No.
Jay 对于Susan的死 你知道什么内情吗 Jay, do you have any information on Susan's death?
不知道 No.
案发时你在家是吗 在睡觉? You were home when this happened, asleep?
对不起 法官阁下 Excuse me, your honor.
我可以跟我的同事讨论一下吗 Could I confer with counsel one second?
快点 Make it fast.
Jimmy问了其中一个警察 Jimmy interviewed one of the cops.
据说他当时在跟另外那个女人聊电话 This guy supposedly was on the phone with the other woman
一直聊到凌晨两点 till 2:00in the morning.
报告上怎么没写 Why wasn't that in the report?
不知道 但你不能对他用B计划 I don't know, but you can't plan B him.
会把我们自己钉死 We'll get clipped.
那弟弟呢 What about the brother?
还可以试试 Still a shot there.
但愿 I hope.
好了 Jay 我问完了 Ok, Jay. That's all I have.
怎么回事 What happened?
他有不在场证明 He had an alibi.
但我们还算比较顺利 Look, it still went ok.
对于可能是你绑架她的说法 Any idea that you maybe abducted her,
我们提出了有力的质疑 we put a dent in that.
看起来只是个微不足道的胜利 These are very small victories, it seems.
弟弟那有任何新的发现吗 Anything new on the brother, at all?
没有 No.
我觉得应该强硬 I'd go hard.
怎么 不怕陪审团厌恶我们吗 What, and look like a monster
我会在结案陈词的时候再软化一点 I will soften it on close.
你要强硬 Go for him.
网上聊天什么的 Something about somebody on a chat line.
她只说了这么多 That's all she said.
她在和某人网恋? Somebody she was having a relationship with on the internet?
她没细说 She didn't really give details.
我姐姐跟我最近不怎么来往 My sister and I weren't too close lately.
为什么 Why was that?
自从我父亲病了 Well, since my father had become ill,
关系就变得很紧张 there was a lot of tension.
我因为生意失败搬回家住 I had a business that failed and had moved back home.
她觉得这样加重了父亲的负担 She didn't think that was helping my dad's stress level.
家庭琐事而已 It was just family stuff.
我的意思是 我们不太分享隐私 The point is, we didn't share a lot of intimate secrets.
Steve 你所说的琐事 do you think this stuff
父亲生病 你生意上的麻烦 your dad's illness, your business problems
有没有可能增加了你姐姐的心理负担 could they have added to your sister's stress level?
当然了 I'm sure they did.
也许导致她去酒吧 Maybe caused her to go to a bar
喝上几杯 跟人搭讪? just to have a drink, talk to somebody?
这我就不清楚了 That I don't know.
你不知道她去了酒吧? You didn't know she'd gone to a bar?
我? 不知道 Me? No.
也不知道她跟Vogelman去了旅馆? Or to a motel with Mr. Vogelman?
是的 我怎么可能知道 No. How would I have known that?
你跟踪她的话不就知道了 Well, you'd know if you'd followed her.
什么 What?
那晚你有没有跟踪你姐姐 Did you follow your sister that night?
-你说什么 -反对 - Excuse me? - Objection.
请准许将证人视为敌意证人 法官阁下 Permission to treat this witness as hostile, your honor.
法官阁下 Your honor
证人是受害者的弟弟 This witness is the brother of the victim.
请求将他视为敌意证人 Permission to treat him as hostile.
准许 Go ahead.
你的生意失败之后 This business failure yours
你有没有负债 did you incur any debt
-这是怎么回事 -有没有证据... - What's going on? -Is there offer of proof.
坐下 Tisbury先生 Sit down down, Mr. Tisbury.
你亏了多少钱 Steve How much money did you lose, Steve?
大概30万 About $300,000.
你欠了这么多债? You owed this amount to people?
我是找的别人投资 没错 I had investors, yes.
你父亲患了肝癌 是不是 Your father, he has liver cancer, isn't that right?
是的 Yes.
医生诊断他只剩下8个月? He was diagnosed with about 8 months to live?
是的 Yes.
据你所知 依照他的遗嘱 According to his will, if you know,
谁会继承遗产 who inherits his estate?
应该是我 I guess me.
应该是你? You guess you.
你是唯一的继承人? You're the sole beneficiary.
没错 Yes.
不过要是你姐姐还活着的话 But if your sister were still alive,
就有两个继承人了 不是吗 there'd be 2 beneficiaries, wouldn't there?
你什么意思 What are you saying?
我的意思是 你姐姐死在你父亲前面 I'm saying that it works out well for you
对你来说佷有利 having your sister die before your dad.
-什么 -反对 - What?! - Objection!
要是她没有死 If she'd outlived him,
她可以分一部分遗产 或许跟你平分 the estate goes sideways, maybe splits.
反对 Objection!
好了 Young先生? All right. Mr. Young?
证人作证说和他姐姐 This witness has testified as to
关系疏离 his estrangement with his sister.
也承认他有负债 He has testified to his debt.
而且只有他说他姐姐沉迷网络 He is also the only one to serve up
试图转移视线 the internet red herring,
也许他企图利用这一点 perhaps to use as a safety net
来洗脱自己的嫌疑 in case suspicion ever fell to him.
请求全部不予记录 Move to strike all of that.
我有权盘问证人 I am entitled to question this witness.
继续 Go ahead.
你姐姐被杀那晚 Anybody with you
有人和你在一起吗 Steve the night of your sister's murder, Steve?
我在家 I was home.
我父亲也在 My father was home.
你到家时 你父亲已经睡下了吗 Were you home before you father went to bed?
是的 No.
你几点到家的 When did you get home?
大概午夜前后 Probably around midnight.
他知道你回来吗 Did he see you come in?
他10点就睡了 He goes to bed at 10:00.
Steve 你有没有在服用抗抑郁的药 Ever take any medication for depression, Steve?
反对 Objection.
反对无效 Overruled.
Steve 你有没有服用任何精神方面的药物 You ever take any medication for a mental condition, Steve?
碳酸锂片 I take lithium.
治疗抑郁? For depression.
是的 Yes.
你是否谋杀了你姐姐 Did you murder your sister
然后嫁祸给George Vogelman and frame George Vogelman?
-什么 -反对 - What?! - Objection!
你是否跟踪她去酒吧 Did you follow her to the bar,
然后又去了旅馆 then go to the motel?
-你疯了吗 -反对 - Are you crazy? - Objection!
反对无效 Overruled.
正是完美的时机 不是吗 It was a perfect opportunity, wasn't it?
你可以通过George Vogelman的车牌号 You could get George Vogelman's address
查找到他的住址 by running down his plates.
等他离开旅馆 After he leaves the motel,
你就进去把你姐姐杀了 you go inside and make yourself the sole beneficiary
然后你准备把人头放到George的车里 and then go to plant the head in George's car.
当你看到那个包 就想 You see the bag and think,
"哈 放在包里更好" "Ah, even better."
债务危机和遗产之争 Wipe out a debt and sibling rivalry
一夜之间全部搞定 all in a night's work.
太荒唐了 That's sick!
警方有没有怀疑过 Did the police ever question you
你和你姐姐的死有关 in connection with your sister's death?
当然没有 Of course they didn't.
他们从没找你去警局接受调查? They never even brought you down for questioning?
是的 没有 No, they did not.
也许你真是干了一桩完美的谋杀案 Steve Maybe you pulled off the perfect crime, Steve.
反对 Objection!
-反对有效 -也许你真那么聪明 - Sustained! - Maybe you're that good.
反对 Objection!
-Young先生 -我收回 - Mr. Young! - Withdrawn.
他们没调查你真是失职 It's a shame they never checked you out.
陪审团要么非常讨厌我们 Well, the jury either really hates us...
要么我们创造了一些合理怀疑 Or we created some doubt.
我觉得你做得很好 I think you did great.
Ellenor 这个孩子的姐姐死了 Ellenor, the kid lost his sister.
我刚指控是他杀的 I just accused him of killing her.
而且 他父亲也快要死了 Meanwhile, his dad is dying.
不要试图安慰我 Do not try to make me feel good.
有没有可能就是他干的 Is it possible he could have done it?
这不重要 That's not important.
重要的是 接下来是你作证 What is, is you're up next.
明白 Ok.
George 你必须发自内心地 George, you've got to just speak the truth,
说实话 from your heart.
如果陪审团能了解真正的你 If the jury can see you for who you really are,
对于你是否有可能杀人 they will have to question
他们就会心存疑问 whether you could have one this.
另外记住 And remember...
一定 记住 remember, remember,
绝对不能扯到你的品性上去 you cannot say anything that goes to your character.
绝对不能开这个头 We cannot open that door.
绝对不能让他们 We cannot give them any chance
有举示那些色情电影的机会 to introduce those porno videos.
知道了 Ok.
不要害怕跟陪审团对视 And don't be afraid to look at the jury.
你没什么要遮掩的 You've got nothing to hide.
明白 Right.
很好 Ok.
午饭后见 See you after lunch.
现在全指望他了 It's in his hands now.
他能行的 He'll be fine.
你让我们要相信你 You asked us to trust you.
是你劝他要说出真相 My boy got up because you convinced him
我儿子才会出庭 to honor the truth.
Robin先生 Mr. Robin,
我的当事人将要为他没有做过的事 I got an innocent man about to go down for a crime
受到惩罚 he didn't commit.
Eugene Eugene?
你毁了我儿子的清白 You just stole my son's innocence.
你个混蛋 You're garbage.
最后一针 Last one.
我可以再打点麻药 I can freeze it some more.
不用 It's ok.
闲人免进 Excuse me.
我是Lucy Hatcher I'm Lucy Hatcher.
我给他带了新衣服过来 I have new clothes for him.
他得回去开庭 He's due back in court.
你可不可以在外面等一会 Well, can you wait outside?
好的 Sure.
哇 Wow.
就因为你说他儿子杀了人 He just bashed your head in
他把你头给爆了? for calling his son the killer?
差不多 Something like that.
记得提醒他擦维生素E Make sure you tell him to rub vitamin e on.
能帮助去疤 It'll help with the scar.
多谢提醒 Thank you.
真的 你可以在外面等 You know, you really could wait outside.
好的 Sure.
Ellenor说一小时后 George作证 Ellenor says it's a half hour till George.
当我打开我的包 就看到了 And when I opened my bag, there it was.
她的头? Her head?
是的 Yes.
然后呢 And what did you do next?
我先是吓到了 First I went into a little shock.
接着我就来找你了 你是我的律师 I came to you, my lawyer..
然后我们一起去了警察局 and together we went to the police.
你知不知道有什么人 Do you know of anybody who would
会以这种方式陷害你 want to incriminate you like this?
不知道 No.
George George...
你要知道事情看起来对你很不利 you have to know how this looks.
你有什么要辩解的吗 Can't you tell us anything?
我只想说 All I can tell you is,
我没有杀过这个女人 I didn't kill this woman.
我们上了床 We made love.
然后我就走了 I left.
她当时还活着 And she was alive.
为什么你不带她去你家 Why didn't you go back to your place?
为什么去旅馆 Why a motel?
我家乱糟糟的不方便 My place wasn't very impressive or neat.
你和一个刚认识的女人半夜从酒吧出来 You leave a bar after midnight with a woman you just met.
你还会担心干不干净? You're worried about neatness?
没错 Yes.
于是你说 我们去旅馆吧 So you said, let's go to a motel,
她就同意了 and she said yes.
一个23岁的漂亮女人 A 23-year-old beautiful woman,
她竟然说"好" she said, "Sure."
事实就是这样 That's what happened.
你们上床之后 And after you made love,
你为什么又走了 why'd you leave?
为什么不留下过夜 Why not spend the night?
我一早还要上班 I had a very early morning at work.
有人看见你离开旅馆吗 Anybody see you leave the motel?
据我所知没有 Not that I know of.
有没有人能证明 Anybody you know of who could testify
以你的人品是不会杀人的? that it's against your character to kill a person?
-反对 -反对 - Objection. - Objection.
反对有效 Sustained.
Vogelman先生 Mr. Vogelman,
基本上 用来证明你无罪的 basically, all you have to suggest your innocence
只有你自己的陈述 is your word.
你有没有任何物证或人证 Do you have any evidence or witnesses
来证明你所说的属实吗 to corroborate your word is worth anything.
反对 请求上前商议 Objection. Sidebar.
上来 Step Up
他想要逼我们进行人格证明 He's trying to force us into character testimony
这样他就好用录像带来反驳他 so he can back door the videos on impeachment.
当任何一个证人站上证人席 Any witness who takes the stand
他的诚实与否就成了审查的内容 puts his truthfulness in issue.
我有权盘问他 I'm entitled to cross.
如果你愿意 可以攻击他的诚实 Attack him on truthfulness if you want,
但你不能问他有没有 but don't be asking what witnesses
证人或物证 or evidence he has.
下去 Step back.
Vogleman先生 你结婚了吗 Mr. Vogelman, are you married?
没有 No.
有女朋友吗 Girlfriend?
没有 No.
你交过女朋友吗 Have you ever had a girlfriend?
没有 No.
没有谈过恋爱? Ever been in any relationship?
我跟人约会过 I've dated.
跟人约会过? You've dated?
你多大了 先生 How old are you, sir?
43岁 43.
43岁了 你从没谈过恋爱 43 years old, and you've never had a relationship.
重复提问 Asked and answered.
反对有效 Sustained.
你有没有通过交友广告认识女性 Do you meet women through the personals?
有时候 Sometimes I do.
有时候你会去酒吧认识女性? You sometimes go to bars, meet women there?
是的 Yes.
有没有在网上认识女性 Ever meet a woman on the internet?
有没有在网上认识女性 Vogleman先生 Ever meet a woman on the internet, Mr. Vogelman?
有 Yes.
你和Susan Robin是在网上认识的吗 Are you the man Susan Robin met on the internet?
不是 No.
她去酒吧是不是 Did she go to that bar to meet you,
去见你这个网友的? the man on the internet?
不是 我跟她是在酒吧认识的 No. I met her at the bar.
我从未跟她在网上聊过天 I never communicated with her on the internet.
最后一个假设问题 Just one last hypothetical,
我就问完了 Vogleman先生 Mr. Vogelman, and then I'll be done.
假设受害者在网上认识了一个男人 Say this woman meets a man on the internet.
他可能过度吹嘘了自己一点 He maybe oversells himself just a little.
她同意和他见面 She agrees to meet him.
结果她很失望 拒绝了他 She's disappointed. Rejects him.
而这个男人 And this man,
这个被拒绝了无数次的男人 who's been rejected so many times,
终于忍无可忍 has finally had enough.
反对 Objection.
这是论证 不是提问 This is an argument, not a question.
忍无可忍无须再忍 是不是 George Enough is enough, right, George?
-反对 -反对有效 - Objection! - Sustained.
你还有其他问题吗 Tisbury先生 Do you have any more questions, Mr. Tisbury?
没有了 法官阁下 No, your honor,
我问完了 I don't believe I do.
辩方律师? Counsel?
Frutt女士? Ms. Frutt?
没有 法官阁下 Nothing, you honor.
证人可以退下了 The witness may step down.
有什么想法 Any ideas?
我们不能这样结束举证 I hate to rest on that
我们要继续盘问吗 Shall we redirect?
我觉得不行 只会让情况更糟糕 I don't think so. It could get worse.
也许我们... Maybe we...
怎么了 What?
我有办法了 I have an idea.
辩方再次传唤Helen Gamble The defense recalls Helen Gamble.
她就坐在下面 She's right back there.
Gamble女士 请上前来 Ms. Gamble, step up, please.
你想干什么 What are you doing?
Gamble女士 请就席 Ms. Gamble, please take the stand.
你作证说 那天我们给你打电话 You testified the reason we called you that day
是因为你和我们很熟 is because of your relationship with our office.
我觉得你们是因为这个原因 I assumed that was the reason
给我打电话的 you called me.
我们事务所跟你之间相互比较信任? Well, does our office enjoy a certain trust with you?
我想是吧 I would think so.
而且坦诚? And a candor?
没错 Yes.
正是基于这种坦诚 And in the spirit of that candor,
上个星期 你和我就这个案子有过一次交谈? did you and I have a conversation about this case last week?
反对 Objection.
反对无效 Overruled.
我们有没有谈过这个案子 Did we talk about this case?
Gamble女士 Ms. Gamble,
你跟我有没有讨论过这个案子 did you and I discuss this case?
简短地 Briefly...
大略地说过 and generally.
你有没有告诉我 警方和检方 And did you tell me that the police and the D.A.'S office both
都想要快速了结此案... just wanted to check "Solved" In the little box...
反对 Objection!
反对无效 Overruled.
我直接问吧 Let me speed things up.
你有没有说过 Did you basically tell me
由于公众的压力 that given the publicity,
必须有人被定罪 a conviction is desperately needed here,
如果指控的是其他人 that if anybody else were charged with this crime,
你们检方不可能得到定罪判决 your office would never get that conviction,
因为是George Vogleman since George Vogelman,
在他的医疗包里带着死者的人头 having the head in his medical bag,
对于其他任何嫌疑人 would guarantee reasonable doubt
这必然构成了合理怀疑 to whoever else was charged?
正因如此 And because of that,
警方和检方 the police and the D.A.'S office,
至少在潜意识里 on at least an unconscious level,
都愿意相信George Vogleman might want to believe that George Vogelman
就是杀手 is the killer and therefore
并且不愿去调查其它可能性 not bother to look for anybody else?
你是不是这么跟我说的 Did you share all that with me?
第一 我并不直接了解这个案子的案情 First, I have no direct information on this case.
-第二... -请正面回答... - Second... - Please just respond...
我是在回答你 I am responding.
你的问题很长 律师 It was a long question, counsel.
法官阁下? Your honor?
继续 She can answer.
我从来没有明说 甚至也没有暗示 I never suggested or even hinted that
George Vogleman不是真凶 somebody else besides George Vogelman committed this crime.
我没有问你是怎么想的 I didn't ask what you thought.
我也从来没有说过地检署 And I never suggested that the D.A.'S office
并不确信你的当事人是有罪的 wasn't convinced of your client's guilt.
你有没有说过 他们可能不愿再去调查 Did you say they might not want to look further,
因为在舆论压力之下 that it's easier to believe
相信你们已经抓到真凶 that you've got the right guy
来得更容易? when there's pressure to get a conviction?
我说过有时候会有这样的情况 I said sometimes it's been known to happen.
但我不是指这个案子 I didn't say it happened here.
没错 但你是在讨论这个案子时 Yes, but you said it's been know to happen
说有过这样的情况 是不是 in a conversation about this case, didn't you?
再说一次 我没有理由认为 Again, I have no reason to believe
针对本案的调查 that this particular investigation
并非恰当而全面的 has been anything but proper and thorough.
谢谢 Thank you.
你可真会打官腔 That was a good answer for the team.
你是不是暗示这个调查有猫腻 Are you suggesting the investigation's tainted?
你认为警方 Do you think there was collusion
和检方有相互勾结吗 between the police and the D.A.'S office?
我现在无可奉告 I've got nothing to say right now.
抱歉 I'm sorry.
有嫌疑人吗 Any suspects?
出去 Get out!
你搞什么飞机 Ellenor What the hell was that, Ellenor?
Helen 对不起 Helen, I'm sorry.
你这是拿刀子捅我 You just cut my legs out!
对不起? Sorry?
我好心私下告诉你 I tell you something in confidence
你却在法庭上出卖我? and you ambush me in open court?
我别无选择 我必须对当事人尽责 I had to make a choice. I had a duty to my client
扯淡 No good!
你以后休想再找我帮忙 You screwed me in this office for the last time!
-我在那种处境下... -去你的 - I was backed into a... - That's crap!
她说的没错 She's right.
那我该怎么做 告诉George What was I gonna do, tell George,
"嘿 我本来可以救你 但是..." "Hey, I could've saved you, but..."
George不是我们唯一的当事人 George isn't the only client in this firm.
当然 Pearson才是 No. Pearson is.
她说得对 Ellenor She's right, Ellenor.
我们需要良好的信誉 We need our credibility with every case,
案子不是只有这一个 not just this one.
我不是有意这么做的 It's not something I planned to do.
但你还是做了 But you did it!
我们还有很多事需要依靠地检署 We have to rely on relationships with D.A's a lot.
有时候正是这些私下交流 Sometimes those off-the-cuff conversations
起到关键作用 make the difference.
你觉得现在还有哪个检察官 Do you think any D.A. Down there
愿意跟我们讲话吗 is gonna want to talk to us again?
所以我就应该把George送进去 So I should let George go down
好保证我们仍然受邀去圣诞聚会? so we can preserve our invites to the Christmas parties?
没错 Yes!
我们跟他们保持联络 Our dialogue with that office is more important
比任何案子都重要 than any one case.
我下周跟他们谈量刑 I gotta deal with them on sentencing next week.
我相信他们现在一定... I'm sure they'll be in great moods to...
哦 忘了你的教授吧 Lindsay Oh, get over your professor, Lindsay.
你跟他做过什么 上床? What did you do, sleep with the guy?
Ellenor Ellenor!
我最喜欢看女生打架了 I love it when girls fight.
比曲棍球还精彩 It's better than hockey.
闭嘴 Lucy Quiet, Lucy!
退后 Ellenor Back up, Ellenor.
退后 Back up!
你也是 You too.
我不管案件有什么风险 I don't care what the stakes are.
任何检察官跟我们的 If the D.A. Has an off-the-record conversation
私下交谈 with any of us,
必须保持私密 it stays off the record.
否则 正如Lindsay所说 Otherwise, it's like Lindsay says.
我们再无信用可言 We lose our credibility in every case.
这话你跟当事人去说 Well, tell that to the drowning man,
你更关心的是事务所 that you're more concerned about the boat.
我不是在跟他讲话 Ellenor I am not talking to a drowning man, Ellenor.
我是在跟你说 I am talking to you.
大家都冷静一点 Let's everybody settle down a little.
很多人都会面临很多危险 There's a lot of stakes for a lot of people.
互相攻击解决不了任何问题 Tearing each other new armpits isn't going to help anybody.
他们当然只能逮捕George Vogelman Of course they had to arrest George Vogelman.
被害人的人头在他的包里 The victim's head was in his possession.
我不责怪警方认为他是凶手 I don't blame the police for thinking he did it.
他们怎么会不这么认为呢 How could they not?
你们不会吗 How could you not?
但是为什么没有人看见他犯案呢 But there's a reason nobody saw him commit the crime.
为什么找不到跟他相关的凶器呢 There's a reason there was no weapon connected to him.
原因就是他不是凶手 He didn't do it.
凶手是谁 Who did?
我不知道 I don't know.
你们都看到我的同事 You heard my co-counsel
把Susan Robin的弟弟 grill Susan Robin's brother
当做嫌疑犯询问 as a possible suspect.
跟你们说实话 Well, let me admit a truth.
我们并没有直接证据 We don't have any direct evidence
证明他就是凶手 to conclude the brother did it.
不然的话 我们肯定会提出来的 If so, we certainly would have offered it.
但他的确有动机 But he did have a motive.
他俩关系疏远 He was estranged from her.
他的债务 遗嘱 His debt. The will.
他在案发时的行踪 His whereabouts at the time
也无法确定 can't really be accounted for.
人可能就是他杀的 He could have done it.
我们之所以不能确定 The reason we can't know
是因为警方 is because the police never really
从来没有调查过他 bothered to check that out.
Steve Robin自己承认 Steve Robin said himself
他们问都没问过 that they never even questioned him.
想象一下 Imagine.
他有动机 He has motive,
有作案时机 opportunity,
无不在场证明 no alibi,
而他们甚至没有把他作为嫌疑犯加以考虑 and they didn't even investigate him as a possibility.
为什么 Why?
就因为人头是放在 Because the head was found
George Vogelman的医药包里 in George Vogelman's medical bag.
还有Jay Hickman And Jay Hickman,
Susan的男朋友 Susan's boyfriend?
我没法断言他就是凶手 I have no reason to believe that he killed her,
但他的行踪同样不能确定 but his whereabouts can't be accounted for either.
动机? Motive?
她跟其他男人去旅馆开房 Well, she was with another man in a motel.
有这么多未解之谜摆在那儿 There are a lot of questions left unanswered here
因为警方从未好好调查过 because the police never really looked.
你们听到检察官Helen Gamble承认 You heard district attorney Helen Gamble admit
有可能他们急需得到判决 it's possible they didn't want to find anybody else
所以他们根本不想调查其他嫌疑人 because they needed to get a conviction on this.
而由于人头是在George Vogelman的包里 And the head being in George Vogelman's bag,
他是唯一有可能被定罪的人 he was the only one they could possibly convict.
与其搞得更复杂 不如抓着他不放 Easier to stay with him and not complicate it.
有证据显示 Any evidence offered
George Vogelman存在杀人动机吗 as to George Vogelman's motive?
没有 为什么呢 No. And why,
要是他真的想要脱罪的话 if he is supposedly trying to get away with a crime,
他还会把人头放在包里 does he put the victim's head in a bag
带着去警局吗 and go to the police with it?
这说得通吗 Does that make sense?
别忘了还有个"诗人杀手" And let's not forget about the poet.
著名的连环杀手 A known serial killer out there,
徘徊在波士顿地区 in the Boston area,
他的作案手法也是分尸 that has an M.O. For decapitating victims.
有人调查过这个线索吗 Has anybody accounted for him?
有那么多疑点需要排除 There are a lot of questions that need answering.
可是从来没人质疑或探究过 Questions that were never asked or explored
就因为看起来很简单 because this just seemed so simple.
头在他包里 The head was in his bag.
人一定是他杀的 He must have done it.
但事实上 并非如此 Well, he didn't.
我毫不怀疑检方希望尽快定罪 I have no doubt the prosecution needs that conviction.
他们当然这么想 They surely do.
但他们告错人了 But they are prosecuting the wrong man.
没有证据 No evidence,
哪怕是最细微的证据 not even microscopic,
显示有其他人进过那个房间 of anybody else being in that room
只有George Vogelman except George Vogelman.
辩方律师很会表演 是不是 Defense counsel gave us quite a show, didn't they?
是她弟弟杀的 The brother did it.
不对 可能是她男朋友杀的 No, maybe it was the boyfriend.
说不定是连环杀手 How about that serial killer?
鉴证人员对房间进行了仔细的清理 Forensics ombed that room.
收集到了唾液样本 There were saliva samples.
衣物纤维 Fibers from clothing.
精液 Semen.
毛发 Hair strands.
指纹 Fingerprints.
这些都不属于连环杀手 They didn't go to a serial killer
不属于Susan Robin的弟弟 or Susan Robin's brother
也不属于她的男朋友 or her boyfriend.
它们全都属于George Vogelman They all belonged to George Vogelman.
他说他一个人回家了 The man who says he went home alone.
可是却没有不在场证明 The man who sits there with no alibi.
没错 Yes,
不难断定他就是凶手 it was easy to conclude he did it.
在所有不可推翻的现场证据之外 And on top of all the insurmountable evidence at the scene,
他还有人头在手 he had the victim's head.
老天 他砍掉了死者的头 My god, he decapitated a woman,
而他的律师却只是 and his lawyers have offered you nothing
编造一个嫌疑人 but spin as a defense.
他们有给出任何 Did they put in one piece of
物证或者人证 physical or testimonial evidence,
来证明无罪吗 anything at all exculpatory?
没有 只有编造 No. Just spin.
他干的 不 他干的 He did it. No, he did it.
看这里 看那里 Look there. Over here.
不要忘了警方和检方的勾结 Don't forget that police conspiracy,
同流合污 collusion with the D.A.
他们竟然指望你们判他无罪? And they expect you to let him go?
这不仅是在侮辱你们的智商 They're not insulting your intelligence,
女士们先生们 ladies and gentlemen.
他们以为你们压根就没有智商 They're assuming you just don't have any.
你觉得会怎么判 Got any predictions?
无罪 有罪 或者无法做出结论 Innocent, guilty, or hung.
-要多久 -不知道 - How long before... - There's no telling.
Eugene Eugene.
你能让我们单独谈会儿么 Could you excuse us a second?
当然 Sure.
举证都结束了 是吗 All the evidence is closed, right?
是的 Yeah.
有件事我必须告诉你 Then I'm going to tell you something.
你我都清楚 无论如何 We both know I've always had some motive
我必须说我是无辜的 to tell you I'm innocent.
这样你才能让我出庭作证 It allowed you to let me testify.
这样你才能... It allowed you to...
怎么说 更卖力 I don't know, try harder.
但现在 所有举证都结束了 But now, the evidence being closed,
无论我说什么都没有关系了 it doesn't matter what I tell you.
我没有杀人 I didn't do it.
几个月前 你看着我说 When you looked at me a few months ago,
你说你相信我 you said you believed in me,
但是你不能完全相信 but you couldn't fully trust yourself
自己的判断是正确的 to believe in what you believe.
你可以相信自己的判断 Ellenor You can trust yourself, Ellenor.
你的判断一直都是对的 You've been right all along.
我没有杀人 I didn't do it.
温馨提示 要是今后 You know, in the future,
你想用书砸人的话 if you're going to hurl a book at someone,
不要选个子比你大的 it should be at somebody your own size.
她能把你拍扁了 She was about to flatten you.
我会记住的 I'll try to remember that.
还有 我看人很准的 And also, i'm a pretty good judge of character.
Ellenor Ellenor...
我相信大多时候她是和善的 I think normally she's peaceful.
一旦被激怒了 But when riled,
可是很恐怖的 she looks dangerous.
嗯 你可以当面告诉她 Well, maybe you should tell her that.
你以为我傻啊 You think I'm crazy?
我早知道你在我后面 I knew you were there.
我很抱歉我说的有关Pearson的话 I'm sorry what I said about Pearson.
我知道 我也很抱歉 I know. I'm sorry...
不该用书砸你 about the book.
DYDF律师事务所 Donnell, Young, Dole & Frutt.
我很抱歉我竟然想对你动手 And I'm sorry about my intent to flatten.
我知道对不起 I know saying sorry
不足以表达我对Helen的歉意 isn't gonna cut it for Helen.
我会跟她说的 I'll work on her.
各位 You guys
判决出来了 verdict.
被告请起立 Will the defendant please rise.
首席陪审员先生 Mr. Foreman,
陪审团是否做出了一致的判决 the jury has reached a unanimous verdict?
是的 We have.
请宣布判决 What say you?
马萨诸塞州诉George Vogelman Commonwealth vs. George Vogelman,
关于一级谋杀的指控 on the count of murder in the first degree,
我们判决被告George Vogelman we find the defendant George Vogelman
无罪 not guilty.
我以为我死定了 I thought I'd never hear that.
被告当庭开释 The defendant is free to go.
你能否说两句 Can you give us a statement?
你觉得是什么改变了陪审团的看法 What do you think changed the jury for you?
今后你有什么打算 What are your plans after this?
真的结束了么 Is it really over?
是啊 Yeah.
谢谢你 Thank you .
我不知道 真的 该说什么 I don't know, really, what to say.
这么久以来... For so long...
-=豆瓣KW组荣誉出品=-