黑水
帕克斯堡·西弗吉尼亚州
你要不要我托你一把啊 I'll give you a boost if you want.
我才不用你帮我 I don't need your help.
卧槽 她哪里需要你帮忙啊 Ooh. Hell, she got you, buddy.
-把啤酒丢过来 -接好了 - Toss them beers. - Here you go.
-你拿到了是吧 -好的 那我们走吧 - You got it? - Okay, let's go!
我们来啦 来啦 All right. All right.
等会儿 啤酒给我 Hold up, hold up! The beer.
拿去拿去 快点 Take this. Take this. Come on.
该死的鞋子真难脱 These damn shoes!
-喔噢 快下来吧 这水贼暖和 -快点下来嘛 - Whoo! Come on in, it's warm! - Come on, buddy!
你看 还能洗头发呢 Look, you can even wash your hair!
我上个月洗过了 I washed mine last month.
劳拉 凯斯 过来 瞧我发现了什么 Laura, Keith, come here! Look what I found.
-卧槽 -这是个啥 - Holy shit. - What the hell's that?
-这是啥 -你们他妈干什么啊 - What is it? - The hell you doing?
快给我滚出去 Get out of here, now!
-妈的 -快点 - Geez! - Come on!
一群小兔崽子 Goddamn kids.
关灯啊 蠢货 Turn off the beam, fool!
辛辛那提·俄亥俄州
根据 纽约时报杂志文章改编 《这个律师 成了杜邦公司的噩梦》 作者 纳撒尼尔·瑞奇
陶氏化工的史蒂夫 联合碳化物公司的泰德 Steve from Dow, Ted from Union Carbide...
埃克森美孚公司的杰瑞 还有联合化学公司公司的安迪 Jerry from Exxon and Andy from Allied.
欢迎来到塔夫托律师事务所,各位 Welcome to Taft Law, gentlemen.
在开始之前 我们先来处理一点家务事吧 Before we get started, a little housekeeping.
这个年轻人你们都认识吧 Um, all of you know this young man
他是我们事务所的好员工 as the dedicated Taft associate
在过去八年里 who for the past eight years has
埋头钻研超级基金法案 buried himself in the Superfund law.
清理他埋泥里的头可不归我买账 I'm not paying for that cleanup
可我依旧很荣幸能向大家宣布 Still it is my pleasure to share with you
就在上周 罗伯·比洛特加入了我们 that just last week, Rob Bilott was welcomed as a partner
成为了塔夫脱律师事务所的合伙人 here at Taft, Stettinius & Hollister.
早上好 这里是塔夫脱律师事务所 请稍等 转接中 Good morning. Taft Law. One moment. I'll connect you.
早上好 这里是塔夫脱律师事务所 Good morning. Taft Law.
请稍等 One moment, please.
州长办公室那边来电 It's the Governor's office calling for uh,
找伯克先生 calling for Mr. Burke.
有什么能帮您的吗 May I help you?
我是威尔伯·特侬 要找罗伯·比洛特 Wilbur Tennant calling on Robbie Bilott.
环保局让您的委托人承担所有的开销 EPA has saddled them with the whole bill
并且鉴于委托人在当地的情况 and given your client's history at that site,
这个费用可能无法避免了 that's a real possibility.
-我会反馈给他们的 -好 12号 米德尔顿 - I'll take it back to them. - Good. Tab 12, Middletown...
我明白 实在抱歉 I know. I'm sorry.
-但他们不走 -他们是谁 - But they won't leave. - Who's they?
不知道 他们说认识你 I don't know. They say they know you.
额 -你是罗伯特·比洛特 - Um... - Robert Bilott?
额 是的 Um, yes.
他们说这个是垃圾填埋场 其实就是个垃圾堆 They call it a landfill. A dump's what it is.
还告诉我们兄弟俩 说没有化学物质 只是垃圾而已 They told my brother and me no chemicals, just trash.
可我们不是傻子 But we ain't stupid.
我自己录了像 里面有你需要的所有证据 I made them videotapes myself. All the proof you need.
他们污染了河水 害死了我的牲口 They're poisonin' the creek, killing my animals.
-我在开会呢 -我想请个律师 - I'm in the middle of a meeting. - So, I want a lawyer.
帕克斯堡的那帮人都不敢接手这案子 Every damn one in Parkersburg's too yella to take my case.
罗伯 他叫你回去开会 Rob. He wants you back in there.
那帮窝囊废都怕杜邦公司 They all scared shitless at DuPont.
我可谁都不怕 Well, I ain't scared of nobody.
好吧 凯瑟琳是我的助理 Okay. Kathleen is my paralegal.
她会给你拿本律师黄页的 She's gonna give you a directory of lawyers.
所以我才打电话给你外婆 That's why I called your grandma.
-什么 -我的邻居告诉我的 - What? - My neighbor who tells me,
让我打电话给阿尔玛·怀特 call Alma White.
说她孙子在辛辛那提是很厉害的律师什么的 Her grandson's some fancy environment lawyer down in Cincinnati.
先生 我是一位企业辩护律师 Sir, I am a corporate defense attorney.
-然后呢 -我专门为化工公司辩护 - So? - I defend chemical companies.
-那你现在可以为我辩护 -罗伯 - Well, now you can defend me. - Rob!
-汤姆 再等我30秒 Uh, 30 seconds, Tom.
-很对不起 您叫 -特侬 - Uh, I'm sorry, Mr... - Tennant.
我可以给您推荐别的律师 I can offer you a referral.
我就是不知道我能怎么帮您 But I just don't see how I can be of any help to you.
你可以先看这些录像带 You can start by watching them tapes for one thing.
噢 我们走吧 厄尔 Oh, let's go, Earl.
我很抱歉 我 我希望你一切顺利 I'm sorry. I... I wish you all the luck.
你小子 去他妈的一切顺利 I don't need your damn luck, boy!
-我要的是你的帮助 -罗伯 - I need your help! - Rob!
走吧 Come on.
我争辩的不是总体分析这部分 I'm not arguing with the overall analysis.
我的观点就是 不管咱们根据 My only point is that whatever we decide upon...
谢谢各位了 Thank you, gentlemen.
你知道我们要去哪吃吗 Do you know where we're going?
在街角有家饭店 There's a place right around the corner.
-嗯 - 刚才到底是怎么回事 - Yeah? - What the hell was that all about?
-他认识我外婆 -是吗 - He knows my grandmother. - Really?
我妈妈是西弗吉尼亚州的人 Well, my mom's from West Virginia.
她家乡叫帕克斯堡 Uh, from a town, Parkersburg.
我和我爸不是那里的 我爸之前在空军 Not us. My... my father was Air Force.
我们 我们经常搬家 We... We moved around a lot,
但是我们夏天会去帕克斯堡 but we spent the summers there.
-走啊 特普 你请客呢 -没问题 - Come on, Terp. You're buying. - Of course I am.
罗伯 你来自西弗吉尼亚州的话就直说 You can be from West Virginia, Rob.
西弗吉尼亚州以大老粗红脖子闻名 男主之前在尽力撇清关系
我不会告诉别人的 I won't tell anyone.
好了 先生们 午饭就吃莫尔顿牛排吧 All right, gentlemen. Morton's it is.
要屈尊和我们这些下级员工吃饭吗 Still deigned to eat with us lowly associates?
美国车怎么开得上路啊 You can't drive an American car.
塔夫脱-哈特莱法案损害了工会权力 Taft-Hartley, union busting?
塔夫脱-哈特莱法案于1947年颁布 是限制工会权力的联邦法律
的确是我们搞出来的 We practically invented it.
我们 "We?"
对了 我认识一位很受人尊敬的合伙人 Besides, I know a highly esteemed partner
他还在开美国车 who still drives American.
-还会开一些特别旧的车 -好吧 - Some real clunkers too. - Okay,
话是这么说 但他那是收藏 yeah, but he collects them.
这还是有区别的 就像 That's different. Like his
他上的不知名的大学和法学院 no-name college and law school.
-无意冒犯-你在听吗 - No offense. - Are you listening to this?
嘿 你们可以先去吗 Hey, you guys go ahead, all right?
-那个 我刚才这话没别的意思 -知道知道 我就是去打个电话 - Look, I didn't mean anything by it. - No. I gotta make a call.
没什么事 我们到那见 It's all right. I'll see you there.
好的 我们会给你留片炸鳕鱼 Okay, we'll save you a fish log.
-你有时候真是讨人厌 -卡拉 我刚才是在开玩笑 - You can be such an asshole. - Karla, it was a joke.
-是吗 -我们在一起经常开玩笑啊 - Yeah. - We always joke.
可不嘛 你们真是爱开玩笑 Oh, yeah. You guys are a couple of jokesters.
这里是阿尔玛·怀特家 You've reached the residence of Alma White.
我现在无法接电话 I can't come to the phone right now...
他挺好的 并且他今天回家还挺早的 He's good. He's home early tonight actually.
代我跟他说声"你好啊 合伙人" Tell him I said, howdy, partner.
她说 "你好啊 合伙人" She says, "Howdy, partner."
这个周天他还会来吗 Are we ever gonna see him again on Sundays?
会啊 妈 这个星期天他还会来吃晚饭 Yes, he can still come to Sunday dinners, Mom.
他是合伙人 又不是美国总统 He's a partner, not the President of the United States.
我想要做点 我那个做圆环蛋糕的煎锅在你那儿吗 I wanna make... Do you have my Bundt pan?
已经还你了 Returned it.
在哪儿 我在厨房台子下面没看到 Where? I looked under the counter.
在右手边的那个橱柜里 装在那个塑料盒子里呢 对 It's the right hand cupboard, in the plastic. Yeah.
好 嗯 我们刚坐下准备吃饭 Okay, well, we just sat down.
好吧 亲爱的 All right, dear.
我得先挂了 So, I gotta go.
代我向罗伯和泰迪问好 Love to Rob and Teddy.
好 周日见啦代我向爸爸问好 All right, see you Sunday. Love to Dad.
嗯 等会儿再和你聊 Talk to you later.
你到时候能对蛋糕装出惊喜的样子吗 Can you pretend to be surprised about the cake?
她想搞得特别点 She wants it to be very special.
哦对了 花岗岩瓷砖样本已经送过来了 Oh, and the granite samples came in.
你明天回家的时候能顺路带回来吗 Can you pick them up on your way home tomorrow?
-嗯 -罗伯 - Mmm. - Rob?
嗯 呃 当然 Hmm? Uh, sure.
你还好吗 You okay?
当然了 Yes.
天主降福我等 Bless us, our Lord and thy gifts
暨所将受于主普施之恩惠 which we are about to receive from thy bounty
为我等之主基督 阿门 through Christ our Lord. Amen.
感谢你 主感谢你佑护我们的家庭 Thank you, God. Thank you for our family.
谢谢 Thank you.
-嗨 奶奶 - 天呐 - Hi, Grammers. - What on earth!
我试着给你打过电话 但你没接 I tried to call, but you weren't picking up.
哎呀 那个 你又不是不知道 我膝盖不太行 Oh, well, you know me. My two fake knees.
你在这儿干什么呢 What are you doing here?
有个农场主跑来见我 A farmer came to see me.
威尔伯·特侬 Wilbur Tennant?
看来你还真认识他啊 You do know him.
不知道你说认识是什么意思 我和他不怎么来往 I don't socialize with him, if that's what you mean.
他临近的农场是伊内斯·格雷厄姆家的 Inez Graham owned the farm next to his.
你们小时候 我曾带你和贝斯去过那里 I used to take you and Beth over there when you were little.
那个地方啊 That's the place?
嗯 Hmm.
你骑过那匹小马啊 - You rode that pony
我小时候好喜欢那个地方 I loved that place.
第一次看见奶牛 Saw a cow for the first time.
学会挤奶 Learned to milk it.
我记得你一坐几个小时 I remember you sittin' there for hours
一滴奶也不放过 making sure you got every last drop.
真是你的性子 Just like you.
这个 There.
嗯. Hmm.
所以你打算帮他 So you gonna help him?
什么 Huh?
从山谷往上去 垃圾堆就在山上 You come up the holler, dump's up the hill.
我开始就那条河投诉之后 Since I started complaining about my creek,
他们就用围栏给围起来了 什么也看不到 fence goes up. All blocked off.
嗨 我是罗伯 Hi, I'm Rob.
我是桑德拉 Sandra.
我联系了政府还有本地的兽医 The State, any veterinarian I've called in Parkersburg,
都没人回我电话 they will not return my phone calls.
就像我动了他们的奶酪一样 Like I bite the hand that feeds.
-不用了 我已经吃 -这个是胆囊 - No, it's all right. I've already... - This here's a gall.
你看看这尺寸 前所未见 Look at the size of it. Ain't never seen
怎么会有这么大的胆囊 比心脏还大 no gall that big. Bigger than the heart.
这个是你家奶牛的 That your cows'?
你看他们的牙齿 Look at them teeth.
乌七八黑的 你看 Black as night. Here.
这只蹄子 天生向内弯曲 Hoof, all turned in on itself.
我一半的小牛生来就有这种蹄子 Half my calves born with hooves like that.
这肿瘤是我从一头小母牛背上割下来的 Tumor, I done cut off the back a heifer.
把这玩意儿放你桌上感觉怎样 How'd ya like that on your table?
我该看些什么 What am I looking for?
你瞎吗 小子 You blind, boy?
石头啊 和我头发一样白了 Stones as white as the hairs on my head.
告诉你 都是被化学物质漂白的 Bleached! That's chemicals, I'm telling ya.
我的牛喝这里的水 在水里乘凉 My animals drink this water. Cool off in 'er.
这水让它们长出血淋淋的肿块 然后两眼无神 Get them bloody welts, them dead eyes.
有的还疯一样地冲向我 Charge at me, crazy-like.
都是我亲手喂大的牛啊 Animals that used to eat out of my own hand.
其它的牛在哪里 Where are the rest of them?
跟我来吧 Come on.
我一开始是把它们一头一头都埋了 它们是一家子 Beginnin', I'd bury 'em. Each one. They're family.
但后来越来越多 我就堆起来一把火 It got to be so many, pile 'em up, set fire to...
你失去了多少头 How many did you lose?
190头 190
190头奶牛 190 cows?
别告诉我没啥不对劲的 You tell me nothing's wrong here.
这个填埋场以前不在这里吗 And this landfill wasn't always here?
不在的 我兄弟吉姆以前给杜邦工厂挖沟 No. My brother Jim used to dig ditches over at the DuPont plant.
后来生病了 再也干不动了 Got sick, couldn't do it no more.
有一天杜邦的人找到他 想要买他山谷那儿的地 One day they come to him, offering to buy his land right up that holler.
他们当时承诺不会有任何化学污染 They promised no chemicals.
容我假设你和杜邦联系过 And I assume you reached out to DuPont?
杜邦公司 国家 联邦政府 DuPont, the State, the Feds.
能联系的我都联系了无数遍 I called everybody there is dozens of times.
-环保局的人最后来了这里 -是吗 - EPA finally comes out here. - Oh, they did.
-就为了搞出一份调查报告 -报告说了什么 - All for some report. - What did it say?
你觉得他们会给我看吗 You think they're gonna show me?
好啦 Okay.
他都这样一整天了 好啦你来 He's been like this all day. Okay. Go on.
你一到爸爸手上就成了天使了 Of course, you're a perfect angel for Daddy.
-瓷砖小样取了吗 -呃 抱歉 没有 - Did you get the tile? - Um, I'm sorry. No.
拜托 罗伯 Rob.
我今天没开车进城 抱歉 I didn't drive into town today. I'm sorry.
你说你今天没开车进城是什么意思 What do you mean you didn't drive into town?
我得去帕克斯堡 I had to go to Parkersburg.
帕克斯堡 为什么你要去帕克斯堡 Parkersburg? Why'd you have to go to Parkersburg?
那里可能有我的一位客户 I may have a client there.
西弗吉尼亚州的客户 什么样的案子啊 In West Virginia? What kind of a case would you have?
他是个农民 认识我外婆 虽然不怎么熟 但是 He's a farmer. He knows my Grammer. Not well, but...
那你见到她了吗 你妈妈在那里吗 So, you saw her? Was your mother there?
拜托 莎拉 我又不是偷偷溜去见我妈的 Oh, come on, Sarah. I didn't sneak off to see my mother.
-那你偷偷溜去是干啥的 -我才没有偷偷溜去 - So, why did you sneak off? - I didn't.
我们今晚的演讲者对塔夫托家族来说并不陌生 Our speaker tonight's no Stranger to the Taft family.
菲利普·唐纳利 Phillip Donnelly, Phil to us,
菲利普是杜邦公司内部法律顾问 serves as in-house Corporate Counsel at DuPont.
杜邦不仅仅是美国最受尊敬的化学公司之一, Not only one of America's most revered chemical companies,
还是这个产业为数不多 but one of the few giants of the industry
-还没有成为塔夫托客户巨头-只是暂时没有哦 - that Taft doesn't represent. - Not yet anyway!
要的就是这种精神 詹姆斯 That's the spirit, James.
我们今晚请菲利普来到这里 不仅是为了向他展示他错过了什么 We asked Phil here tonight, not just to show him what he's missing,
也为了听听我们这个产业的著名领袖 but to hear how a renowned leader of our industry
是如何经久不衰的 有请菲利普·唐纳利 stays that way. Please welcome Phil Donnelly.
-祝我好运-去吧 菲利普 - Wish me luck. - Go get 'em, Phil!
谢谢 Thank you.
在杜邦 我们不是为了生产化学制品而生产化学制品 At DuPont, we're not producing chemicals for chemical's sake.
我们是为了民众去生产的 We're producing them for people's sake.
是为了让人们活得更轻松 To make folks' lives easier.
更高兴 更长寿 Happier, longer.
所以"化学改善生活" That's why better living through chemistry
不仅仅是杜邦公司的口号 is not just a slogan at DuPont.
而是公司的基因 It's our DNA.
-嘿 罗伯 -你好 菲利普 - Hey, Rob. - Hello, Phil.
-汤姆告诉我的都是真的吗 -是的 - Is it true what Tom tells me? - Yeah, it's true.
-他们能拥有你真是太幸运了-谢了 菲利普 - Well, good on them. They're lucky to have you. - Thanks, Phil.
就像我经常给年轻同事们说的那样 Like I always tell my younger associates,
只要埋头苦干就好了 just keep your head down and do the work.
谢了那个 菲利普 我可以问你个比较奇怪的问题吗 Thanks. Uh, Phil, can I ask you sort of an odd question?
问吧 Shoot.
威尔伯·特侬这个名字你听起来耳熟吗 Does the name Wilbur Tennant ring a bell?
-你说的是特侬吗 -特侬 - Tennet, did you say? - Tennant.
我想不起来了 No. Not that I recall.
特侬先生是西弗吉尼亚的农民 Mr. Tennant's a farmer from West Virginia.
他的房屋紧挨着你们的垃圾填埋场之一: 演练 His property abuts one of your landfills, Dry Run.
他的牛得病了 And his cows have been getting sick.
他认为很可能是因为有什么东西从垃圾填埋场泄漏到了他的小溪里 He thinks possibly because of the runoff from the landfill into his creek.
不会吧 你是怎么知道的 You're kidding me. How did this come to you?
-嘿 菲利普 -他是个农民 他 - Hey, Phil! - He's a farmer. He's...
我的祖母来自帕克思堡 My grandmother's from Parkersburg.
真的吗 华盛顿工厂是很棒的工厂 Really? Washington Works. Great plant.
-对的 她认识特侬一家人-所以你奶奶支持你 - Right. She knows the Tennants. - So Grandma's on your back?
差不多是这样 不管怎样 那个 Something like that. Anyway, uh...
那个农民说环保局来过 他们四处看了看 我想知道 . The farmer said the EPA came out, took a look around. I wondered...
-垃圾填埋场叫什么名字来着 -演练. - The name of the landfill again? - Dry Run.
演练 空 Dry Run. Dry...
你这么一说 确实听起来很耳熟 You know, that does ring a bell, now that you mention it.
我们可能还派人去过 We may have even sent some folks out there.
如果我没记错 当时是协助美国环保局调查 If I remember correctly, help EPA check it out.
那就肯定是了 所以我想和特侬先生分享下调查结果 That's gotta be it. So, I'd love to share whatever came of that
让他冷静一下 with Mr. Tennant. Help settle his nerves.
当然 我回到威明顿市就马上去看看 Absolutely. Soon as I'm back in Wilmington, I'll take a look.
-谢谢菲利普 我真的很感谢 -乐意效劳 - Thanks, Phil. I really appreciate it. - Happy to do it.
现在让我们去喝一杯 为我的朋友 你 干一杯 Now, let's get a drink and toast you, my friend. You.
好的 Okay.
特侬先生 Mr. Tennant!
特侬先生 我拿到报告了 Mr. Tennant, I have the report.
狗娘养的 他们以为他们是谁 Sons of bitches! Who the hell they think they are?
-谁给了他们权力 -这是评估结果 - Who gives them the right? - It's an evaluation.
评估 这是诽谤 Evalu, Hatchet job's what it is.
我经营了一辈子农场 一辈子 I been farming my entire life. Entire life!
你来读读 看能不能认出是我的农场 You read that. You tell me you recognize my farm.
-特侬先生 -你给我读 - Mr. Tennant... - Read it!
牛群健康调查显示 "The herd health investigation revealed
牛群管理存在缺陷 "deficiency in herd management.
包括营养不良 "Including poor nutrition,
缺乏兽医护理和蝇类治理 "inadequate veterinary care and lack of fly control."
你在这里看见苍蝇了吗 You see any flies here?
正在下雪呢 It's snowing.
你能不能不要一直给他们找借口 Can't stop making excuses for 'em, can you?
可能是害虫 他们咨询过兽医了 It could be pests. They consulted a vet.
谁的兽医 杜邦的 Whose vet? DuPont?
看看你自己 不管他们说什么你都相信 Look at yourself. Swallowin' whole, whatever they been feeding ya.
分辨不出真假 Can't tell truth from lie.
我给你的录像带你看了吗 You even watch them tapes I gave you?
-先生 我是在想办法帮你 -安静 - Sir, I am trying to help! - Quiet.
-真的想帮忙 -别动 - Trying to help. - Stop movin'.
现在放松点 放松 Easy, now. Easy.
进去 慢点 Get in. Slow.
原谅我 姑娘 Forgive me, girl.
我的天 Jesus.
想要即刻的温暖 Need something to warm you up right about now?
那么这个可以吗 Well, how about this?
宛如天堂 西弗吉尼亚 Almost heaven, West Virginia
背景音乐John Denver - Take Me Home, Country Roads
蓝岭山脉 仙纳度河 Blue Ridge Mountains, Shenandoah River
杜邦社区活动中心
生命在那 比树古老 Life is old there, older than the trees
比山年轻 如风生长 Younger than the mountains Blowing like the breeze
故乡的路 带我回家 Country roads, take me home
去向那 To the place...
我归属的地方 I belong
西弗吉尼亚 West Virginia...
山峦妈妈 mountain mama
带我回家 Take me home...
这头牛双眼浑浊 他们说这个是红眼病 ...this cow's eyes are cloudy with pink eyes is what they'll call it.
总之 她的眼睛向内凹陷进脑袋里 Anyway, her eyes are sunk way back in her head.
像三声夜鹰那样可怜 She's poor as a whippoorwill.
我现在把她切开看看她到底怎么死的 And I'm gonna cut her open and find out what caused her to die.
我给的饲料很足 Because I was feeding her enough feed...
按理说她应该长肉而不是掉肉的 that she should've gained weight instead of losin' weight.
她的牙齿是这个样子 This is what her teeth looks like.
这排是上面的牙齿 That's the upper one.
我一辈子没见过这样的牙齿 But this one here, I've never seen anything like it in my lifetime.
甚至兽医也说 Even the veterinarian, he admitted...
他之前从没见过这样的状况 he never saw anything like this before in his life either.
所以 你打算让我们怎么做 So, what are you proposing we do?
提出索赔 公示相关资料并找出那个垃圾填埋场里有什么 File a claim, trigger discovery and find out what's in that landfill.
-你想起诉杜邦吗 -是的 - You wanna sue DuPont? - Targeted.
-财产纠纷 例行公事 -这根本不是例行公事 连边都没挨上 - Property dispute. Routine stuff. - Not routine. Not around here.
我知道 汤姆 但如果你亲眼见到过的话 I know, but, Tom, if you'd actually seen it.
他的农场就像个坟场 肯定是出问题了 His farm is like a graveyard. There's something very wrong.
所以 他应该找一个当地律师 So, he should hire a local lawyer.
没有人愿意做 他们都非常害怕杜邦公司 None of them will do it. They're all terrified of DuPont.
-所以呢 -我们了解杜邦公司 - Well, what does that tell you? - We know DuPont.
如果在他们在当地的负责人捅娄子的话 They're gonna wanna hear
杜邦肯定很愿意知道的 if some of their local guys are screwing something up.
所以他们还要感谢我们的起诉咯 Oh, so they're gonna thank us for suing.
总比被环保局起诉要好 Better us than the EPA.
新的合伙人应该带来业务对吧 I mean, new partners are supposed to bring in business, right?
所以你的农民能支付每小时275的咨询费吗 So, your farmer can swing 275 an hour?
到时候可以用用胜诉补偿支付酬金 It'd be on contingency.
天呐 我们是在收集购物券吗 Jesus. What are we, coupon chasers now?
只是家里世交的一点小事情 官司打完就行了 It's a small matter for a family friend. I'll get in and I'll get out.
-帮助需要帮忙的人 -谁需要帮助 那个农民还是你自己 - Help a guy that needs it. - Who? The farmer or you?
小心行事 听到了吗 Surgical. You hear me?
完全没问题 谢谢 Absolutely. Thank you.
要不要啊 罗伯 我怎么可能不接你电话 Come on, Rob. Of course, I'm gonna take your call.
虽然我 得承认 我有点惊讶 Even though, I was, I admit, a little surprised.
就是被塔夫托律师事务所起诉这种事 I mean, getting sued by Taft Law.
不是天天都能碰到的 或者说实话 从没想过会碰到 It's not every day. Or any day, frankly.
我知道 很抱歉 I know. I'm sorry.
我们是朋友 这只是一个小问题 Look, you and I are friends. This is a minor issue.
没必要闹太大 No reason it should get messy.
谢谢 我完全同意 我现在开免提 Thank you. I totally agree. Yeah, I'm putting you on speaker phone.
所以 你想了解我们是否违反了许可 So, you wanna know if we violated our permits.
对 差不多 Pretty much, yeah.
好的 我会让我们的员工 Okay, then. I'll have our guys send over anything...
把演练填埋场危险废料的相关材料发给你们 related to hazardous wastes at Dry Run.
这次我会告诉他们快一点 怎么样 And I'll tell them to hurry it up this time. How's that?
-谢谢 挺好的 -还有别紧张 我不怪你 - Thank you. That sounds great. - And don't stress. I forgive you.
谢谢 菲利普 Thanks, Phil.
特侬案开始一年后
你带宝宝去办公室了 You took your baby into the office?
-我需要一个更大的卡车 -为什么 - I needed a bigger trunk. - Why?
对特侬案子的资料证据今天到了 Discovery for the Tennant case came in today.
你怎么就先开吃了呀 吃得真快呢 Oh. Oh, you started before me. You're so fast! Whoa.
好小子 Good boy.
真可惜罗伯错过了这么一个美好的日子 Rob's missing such a lovely day.
妈 法律就是个易妒的情人 这样的事在所难免 Law's a jealous mistress, Mom. Means it comes with the territory.
来我们去那边 Let's go over here!
真棒 谢谢 我说的就是这个 Nice! Thank you! That's what I'm talking about right there.
55加倫鋼桶
好 来吧 再来一个 再来一个 好的 All right. Let's go. One more. One more. All right.
"聚 " Poly...
这不会是 Is that...
你是否想搜索 POA授权书
不对 No.
没有任何关于“P-F-O-A”的搜索结果
-我最喜欢原告律师怎么样 -来 帮帮我好吗 - How's my favorite plaintiff's attorney? - Hey, help me out, will ya?
如果你运营一个垃圾填埋场 全是垃圾的那种 You're a run of a mill dump, nothing but trash.
你的语气听起来像我的初恋女友 You sound like my first girlfriend.
为什么要使用55加仑的容器 Why a requisition order for 55-gallon containers?
有鬼 这是标准大小的化学剂桶 Conspiracy. Standard size drums.
灰烬 灰烬副产品 玻璃桶 塑料 废纸这些只是废弃物 Ash, ash-byproduct, glass tubing, plastic, paper waste. It's just trash.
这些都是直接扔卡车里送走的 不需要用桶打包啊 You pile it onto a truck, drive it away. You don't pack it into drums.
-所以他们有液态废料 -但不是有害的 - So, they've got liquid waste. - Not hazardous.
不然的话必须公开的 所以是什么在杀死这些奶牛 Or they'd have to disclose it. So, what is killing these cows?
-反正不是废纸和灰烬 -对 可能这是人的错误 - It's not paper and ash. - Well, maybe it's human error.
他们把一些他们不知情的有毒废料倒进去 They're dumping something in there they don't know is toxic.
金 这可是杜邦啊 他们比环保局知道的多得多 Kim, it's DuPont. They know more than the EPA does.
所有人都比环保局知道的多 Everyone knows more than the EPA does.
所以环保局才让我们自己监管自己 Why else would they let us regulate ourselves?
什么 是吗 - What? - Do we?
是什么 Do we what?
环保局直到1976年才开始监管化学品 The EPA only started regulating chemicals in '76.
所以呢 Yeah?
除非他们知道某种物质有害或者有公司告诉他们 They grandfather in every existing chemical, non-hazardous,
否则他们就不会将算作是有害的 unless they knew it was hazardous or a company told them it was.
- 我们在谈论同一件事情吗 - 不是 我是想说 - We're saying the same thing. - No, we're not. I'm saying
如果公司不告诉他们呢 what if a company didn't tell?
如果 What if
菲利普·唐纳利愿意把那份资料证据交出来 the reason Phil Donnelly agreed to discovery on hazardous
是因为他早就知道 is because he knows
废物填埋场里的东西不受监管 whatever's in that landfill isn't even regulated?
好吧 你现在的语气像极了原告律师 Okay, now you are sounding like a plaintiff's attorney.
- 我还有个会要开 - 嘿 稍等一下 - I've got a meeting. - Hey, oh, wait, one second.
你之前有听说过 呃 PFOA吗 Have you heard of this, um, PFOA?
没有 No.
那个 这里有提到 但是我在文献你找不到任何与它有关的资料 You know, it's mentioned here, but I can't find anything about it
我甚至都不知道它是不是化学物质 in any of the literature. I don't even know if it's a chemical.
-去问菲利普吧 -好吧 谢谢 - Ask Phil. - Well, thank you.
我说过了 唐纳利先生去外地了 As I said, Mr. Donnelly is still out of town.
我上周就打电话给他了 还留了两条信息 但现在还没有听到他的回复 I called last week and left two messages and haven't heard back from him.
我会告诉他您再次来电了 I'll be sure to tell him that you called again.
好 操 Okay. Damn it.
-你去化学联盟晚宴的门票 -哎呀 - Your tickets to the Chemical Alliance dinner. - Argh...
还有别忘了 深色的正装和黑色的领结不搭 And, no, dark suit is not the same as black tie.
菲利普应该也会去吧 Wouldn't he be going?
我不知道罗伯告诉你了没 我在塔夫托的时候是接待员 I don't know if Rob told you, but I was a receptionist at Taft
-之后才去了法学院 -是嘛 - before law school. - Is that right?
不过只有我丈夫最后做了律师 还挺好的 But well, I think the right Bilott ended up there.
哈罗德 你这次别想躲过我 Harold, you're not getting away from me.
-失陪一下 -当然 没关系 - Would you excuse me? - Sure, it was...
-真高兴见到你-是什么时 - It's great to see you. - When is the...
真有意思 That's funny.
我当时马上发现罗伯有一点像我 Right away, I saw a little of myself in Rob.
-是吗 -都特别桀骜不驯 - Oh! - One black sheep to another.
-我父亲生前是个炼钢工人 -是吗 - My dad was a steel worker, you know. - Was he?
你有看见菲利普么 Have you seen Phil?
没 No.
-所以 你是律师 -啊 我快戒掉了 - So, you're an attorney? - Oh, recovering.
我以前帮雇主解决工人的劳务赔付纠纷 I represented employers in workmen's comp disputes.
但现在我在家带娃 But now, I stay at home with our baby.
可不吗 女律师就是这样 Well, that's the thing with lady lawyers.
我想去给陶氏化工的那几个人打个招呼 你有看见他们么 I wanna say hi to the Dow folks. Have you seen them?
没有 我一直在找菲利普 No, I've been looking for Phil.
我有告诉你他们给了我一些活儿干吗 Did I tell you they sent me some work?
-陶氏化工吗 真棒 -只是一个小项目啦 更像一个考验 - Dow? That's great! - Just a small project. Like a try-out.
但要是能给他们留下好印象的话 你能想象我拿下他们吗 But if I impress them, can you imagine if I brought on Dow?
我不用了 谢谢 None for me, thank you.
你不是 You're not...
我 呃 I'm, uh...
你 她 You're... She's...
我 I'm...
我拖一拖再告诉律所 I'm gonna wait as long as I can to tell the firm. Obviously.
你介意我们失陪一会儿吗 Would you excuse us for a moment?
我们这些女律师需要商量点私事儿 These lady lawyers need a quick sidebar.
-你们随意.-别别 - Of course. - No. No.
-可能就是他给你发工资哦 跟他好好聊-别把我一个人扔这儿 - He signs your paycheck. Be nice to him. - Don't leave me.
-恭喜恭喜-我知道 简直难以置信 - Congratulations. - I know. I can't believe it.
失陪一下 Excuse me.
罗伯 你最近怎么样 Rob, how are you?
菲利普 我一直在努力联系你 Phil, I've been trying to reach you.
非常抱歉 我一直在外面跑 明天联系你怎么样 So sorry, all this traveling. How about I give you a shout tomorrow?
我们现在需要填埋场里的所有物质的资料证据 We're gonna need to broaden discovery to everything
不管是不是有害物质 in that landfill, hazardous or not.
抱歉 Excuse me.
你在逗我吗 You kidding me?
没有 No.
我认为填埋场里的问题物质 I think whatever's causing the problems in there
不在环保局的管制范围内或者他们根本不知道 isn't something the EPA regulates or knows to regulate.
什么 Sorry?
在你的文件里有些东西我看不懂 I'm seeing things in your documents I don't understand.
我觉得你是见鬼了 我跟你直说 You're seeing ghosts, is what you're seeing, and frankly,
你在干傻事 you're making an ass of yourself.
好吧 那你帮帮我 Okay, then, help me out.
比如 I mean, like this.
PFOA到底是什么 I mean, what is this PFOA?
到底是什么的缩写呢 What's that stand for?
天啊 Jesus.
你他妈这是在搞非法摸底调查 You're on a goddamn fishing expedition.
就为了个养牛的 You wanna flush your career down the toilet
你连自己前途都不要了吗 for some cowhand?
你随意 我能帮的都帮了 Be my guest. I'm done helping you.
菲利普 我还是坚持要扩大资料证据范围 Phil, I need to insist on broadening discovery.
-那你去告我啊 -呃 - Sue me! - Uh...
我已经把你给告了 I'm already suing you.
欢迎各位 Welcome, everyone,
来参加第14届俄亥俄州化学药品联盟 to the 14th Annual Ohio Chemical Alliance...
-我操你的 -颁奖晚宴 - Fuck you! - ...awards dinner.
傻逼 Hick!
那咱们就开始吧 So, let's get the fun started!
我很抱歉 I'm sorry.
你不是唯一一个做出牺牲的人 You're not the only one who's sacrificed.
我只希望你知道你在做些什么 I just hope you know what you're doing.
你知道生意和娱乐的区别 对吧 You know the difference between business and pleasure, right?
所以 你究竟为什么要在公共场合谈生意 So, why on earth would you engage in business conversations at a public function? -
汤姆 Tom!
他一定有所隐瞒 你看见他的反应了 He's hiding something. You saw his reaction.
不止我 整个屋里的人都看到了 Yeah, me and everyone in that room.
塔夫托现在对杜邦做的事毫无意义 Taft in a pissing match with DuPont.
我要拿到法院传票并且逼他们 I am gonna get a court order and force them
向我说明填埋场里的所有物质 to tell me everything that's in that landfill.
我的天 现在你是真的想把他们告上法庭 Jesus Christ! Now you wanna actually take them to court.
我现在还需要西佛吉尼亚州的地方律师 And I'm gonna need local counsel in West Virginia.
不是说好就和杜邦过一遍流程吗 What happened to routine stuff?
-你自己去问菲利普·唐纳利 -天啊 - Ask Phil Donnelly. - God!
当然 我记得你 Of course, I remember you.
是 上次我见到你 我以为菲利普·唐纳利 Yeah, last time I saw you, I think Phil Donnelly was
想让你和我们一块儿去打高尔夫呢 trying to get you to go out on the links with us.
是 Yeah.
你什么 You what?
-谢谢 Thank you.
早上好 Good morning.
-早上好 拉里 -早 - Good morning, Larry. - Morning.
早 克莱尔 Morning, Miss Claire.
你看起来气色不错 Don't you look nice.
你这套还是留给法官吧 温特先生 Save it for the judge, Mr. Winter.
你要起诉杜邦公司 You're suing DuPont.
是的 女士 Yes, ma'am.
你代表杜邦公司吗 You represent DuPont.
我以前的事务所代表杜邦公司 My old firm did.
我已经出来单干一段时间了 I've been out on my own for a while.
那祝你一切顺利啊 Good luck with that.
我打电话就是想告诉你 Just wanted to let you know personally
你法庭传令的资料证据快到了 that your court-ordered discovery is on the way.
谢谢你 菲利普 Thanks, Phil.
没事 应该的 No, it's my pleasure.
资料证据 Discovery.
这帮混蛋 Son of a bitch.
绝不承认责任 No admission of liability.
所有 And non...
所有术语都要保密 Non-disclosure of any and all terms.
抱歉 等我一下 Pardon me a moment.
谢谢 Thanks.
我的天呐 Holy Jesus!
-到底 -谢谢 - What in the... - Thanks.
怎么回事 ...world?
我觉得他们这是故意整我 I guess the joke's on me.
可不么 Yeah.
这么一大堆 一百万年也看不完啊 No one can go through all this crap. Not in a million years.
他们肯定就是赌我们看不完 Yeah, I'm pretty sure that's what they're banking on.
-哎哟 我去 -罗伯 我的天 - Oh, God! Damn it! - Oh, God, Rob!
-我帮你 -不用不用 怎么能让你收拾这些东西 - Here, let me... - No, no, no, you shouldn't be around this stuff.
-你自己行么 -没问题 谢谢你 - You sure? - I'm positive. Thank you, though.
好吧 Yeah.
辛苦你了 Good luck.
1957 1957
萨利 这上菜怎么这么慢 Hey, Sally, what is the hold up back here?
-嗨 鲍比 最近 -你们吃啥 - Hey, Bobby. How you... - What're you having?
和原来一样 Usual.
粗玉米粉和培根 再加个蛋 Eggs over bacon and grits.
我也要这个 Same.
我要炸玉米粉 然后两个蛋 I need two over, grits, fried.
不满农民起诉本市最大雇主
威尔伯·特侬. Wilbur Tennant.
他现在不在办公室 您方便留言吗 He's not in his office. Can I take a message?
-我一直都在给他留言 -我知道 特侬先生 - I been leaving messages. - I know, Mr. Tennant,
可是他现在真的没法接电话 but he really can't get to the phone right now.
你们服务怎么这样啊 I want service!
-我会告诉他你打过电话了-我的老天爷啊 -I'll let him know that you called again. -For Christ's sakes.
她还习惯住在爸妈家吗 Is she getting accustomed to being at Mom and Dad's?
你了解外婆的 她想念自己的家 You know Grammer. She misses her own house.
-什么 -她想念自己的家 - What? - She misses her own house.
我这信号不好 I have a bad cell.
我说外婆想念她自己家 I said Grammer misses her own house.
好吧 你能 Okay, can you...
我能跟她聊聊吗 Can I talk to her?
她和妈妈去看医生了 She and Mom are at the doctor's.
-你能告诉外婆我有来电吗 -你那边信号好差啊 - Will you tell Grammers I called? - Rob, you're breaking up.
也告诉妈妈一声可以吗 And Mom too?
-我们星期天再通电话看看 -好吧 - Let's try again on Sunday. - All right.
"C-8" "C-8."
你现在看着跟走火入魔了一样 You know you look like a crazy person, right?
那个人的名字叫什么来着 就是你带来 What was the name of that guy that you brought by the...
-谁 -那个化学专家 - What guy? - The chemistry expert.
-就是那个做模型的 -吉莱斯皮. - The guy who does the models. - Gillespie.
请慢用 Here you go.
谢谢 Thank you.
金·伯克以前不是有报销账户吗 Kim Burke had an expense account.
不好意思 并不是那种案子 Oh, sorry. It's not that kind of case.
请问你熟悉PFOA吗 Are you familiar with something called PFOA?
不熟悉 No.
-不熟悉 -不熟悉 - No. - No.
不过我最近的确读过一些关于 好像是叫PFOS的文章 I did read something recently about a PFOS, I think it was.
-听起来有点关系-那是什么 - That sounds related. - And what was that?
人工合成的长链氟碳化合物 Long-chain fluorocarbon, synthetic.
不好意思 化学是我高中最差的一门课 I'm sorry. Chemistry was my worst class in high school.
小伙子 你入错行了 Boy, you in the wrong line of work.
告诉我吧所以呢 Tell me about it. So?
人工合成懂 人造的 So, synthetic. All right? Man-made.
弗兰肯斯坦 Frankenstein.
弗兰肯斯坦是科学怪人
然后呢 And?
长链氟碳化合物是加入氟化物的碳序列 Long-chain fluorocarbon is a sequence of carbon atoms, add a fluoride.
-好吧 在实验室 你拿一个碳原子-嗯嗯 - All right. In the lab you take a carbon atom... - Mmm-hmm.
然后 你加入另一个碳原子 ...and then you add another carbon atom.
然后再加一个 And then another
然后再加一个 你看 and another... Look.
我们是在做碳链对吧 You're making a chain. Right?
-对吧 -可不可以是 - Right? - Could it be...
8个 8个碳原子 Eight? Eight carbons?
嗯 当然可以了 在实验室里几乎是想做什么就做什么 Well, sure. Yeah, In the lab you can do almost anything.
我是想问 为什么要合成这个 And why would you want to? Make this, I mean.
从生物化学的角度上讲这种碳链结构非常坚固 Well, a chain like that's pretty much unbreakable, biochemically speaking.
所以 我觉得在工业上会有应用 So, uh, industrial uses, I imagine.
3M公司以前做过这个 3M made it.
但现在不做了 文章里是这么写的 They don't anymore. That's what I read.
-为什么停下来了 -文章里没说 - Why did they stop? - Didn't say.
要是 What if...
要是你喝了会怎么样 What if you drank it?
喝了 Drank it?
-怎么会喝这个 -喝了会怎样 - You don't. - Well, what if you did?
-可以点餐了吗 -是的 可以 - Ready to order? - Yeah, I think I'd like a...
但是要是你喝了呢 But what if you did?
这就像是在问"我吞了一个轮胎会怎样 " That's like saying, "What if I swallowed a tire?"
我不知道 你要亲自试一试吗 I don't know. You wanna be the guy that finds out?
金枪鱼奶酪三明治 Tuna melt.
让我们从赞美诗的第452首开始 Let us all begin with hymn number 452 in our hymnal books.
"主啊 我在这里"请起身 "Here I Am, Lord." Please rise.
我 是海与天的主, I, the Lord of sea and sky
我听到人们的哭泣, I have heard my people cry
黑暗中罪恶的人啊, All who dwell in deepest sin
我将要救赎 My hand will save
这个东西会发出声音吗 Does it makes sounds?
前方发现行星 Asteroid ahead.
像我这样抓着 You hold like that.
准备点火起飞了吗 Are you ready to blast off?
这个东西我扔掉了 I'm taking off that.
视觉大发现 有趣的牙齿
你之前说这个里面有氟化物 You said it had fluoride?
啥 比洛特先生 今天可是周日 What? Mr. Bilott, it's Sunday.
就是那个化学物质 你说里面有氟原子 That chemical, you said it had a fluoride atom.
这个是一种氟碳化合物 所以是的 上面会有氟原子 It's a fluorocarbon, so, yes. Somewhere along the chain...
喝了之后牙齿会怎样呢 What would it do to your teeth if you drank it?
别跟我说不应该喝 要是喝了呢 Don't tell me if you shouldn't, if you did.
如果喝了很多 牙齿会发生什么变化 If you drank a lot of it, what would it do to your teeth?
那个 微量的氟化物会使牙齿更坚固 Well, in trace amounts fluoride hardens teeth.
但如果太多了的话 会使牙齿变得很脏 呃 甚至是完全变黑 But too much, it's gonna stain 'em. I mean, even turn 'em black.
现在我可以继续和家人共度时光了吗 So, can I get back to my family now?
哈 你现在要去哪儿 What? Where are you going?
-这个东西在他们的水里 -什么 什么东西 - It's in their water. - What? What is?
西佛吉尼亞州·伍德郡 公共供水系統中檢測到的C-8含量
咳了多久了 How long's the coughing been?
几 几个月了 Couple... Couple of months.
一年了 A year.
-你抽烟吗 -不抽 - You a smoker? - No.
把袖子卷起来 我们要采血 Roll up your sleeve. We're gonna take some blood.
-我以为你把它关在家里了 -我有啊 - Thought you left him inside. - I did.
哦 宝贝儿 Oh, baby.
你动这些了 You move this?
什么 What?
-你看这些东西了吗 -没有 - Did you go through this? - No!
他们来过了 They been here.
他们来过了 They been here!
发生什么了 What happened?
去洗洗手 Wash up.
爸爸 Dad?
-那是什么 -安静 - What is it? - Quiet.
这是我的地盘儿 该死的 你给我滚出去 This is my land, damn you! You get out of here!
快走 Go on!
桑德拉 姑娘们 进去 快点 进去 进去 Sandra, girls, get on! Go on, get in! Get in!
我知道你是谁 I know youl!
快乐锅
罗伯 Rob?
-我的天呐 罗伯 -怎么了 - Holy crap, Rob! - What?
我还以为有人闯进来了 我的天啊 I thought someone was breaking in, for God's sakes!
没有 只有我 No, it's just me.
罗伯 你得告诉我这是怎么回事 Rob, you need to tell me what in the hell's going on.
我们被下毒了 We're being poisoned.
-罗伯-什么 - Rob. - What?
我是认真的 杜邦在故意给我们下毒 I mean it. DuPont is knowingly poisoning us.
你是说给那个农民的地 You mean the farmer. His land.
我们所有人 All of us.
拜托别那样看着我 Please don't look at me like that.
他们已经在给婴儿下毒了 They're already poisoning the baby.
-不 我不想听这些-莎拉 - No. I'm not listening to this. - Sarah.
住嘴 你住嘴行吗 Stop it! Just stop it, okay?
你听见你刚刚说的话了吗 你现在像个疯子一样 Do you hear yourself? You are acting like a crazy person.
把我们的地毯拆得七零八落 吓得我心神不宁 Tearing up our floor. Scaring me half to death.
我知道作为妻子我应该支持你 但这并不意味着 I know it's my job to support you, but that does not mean
你可以回到家堂而皇之地告诉我 you get to come into our home, to our family
我们未出世的孩子正在被毒害 and tell me that our unborn child is being poisoned. No!
对不起 可以给我一个机会解释吗 I'm sorry. Can I please explain?
-解释什么 -所有事情 - Explain what? - All of it.
如果到时候你还认为我疯了 我会立马放下这件事 我对天发誓 And if you still think I'm crazy, I'll drop it. I swear to God.
我向你发誓 I swear to you.
有一种人造化学制剂 There is a man-made chemical
在曼哈顿计划中被发明出来 that was invented during the Manhattan project.
曼哈顿计划是第二次世界大战期间研发与制造原子弹的一项大型军事工程
它排斥几乎所有元素 尤其排斥水 It repelled the elements, especially water.
所以科学家们用它制造了史上第一种坦克防水涂层 So they used it to make the first ever waterproof coating for tanks.
它坚不可摧 It was indestructible.
于是有一些公司打上了主意 为什么只将这种材料用在战场上呢 Then some companies thought, "Hey, why just the battlefield?
为什么这种材料不能走进美国的千家万户呢 "Why not bring this chemical into American homes?"
-罗伯到了-好的 - Rob's here. - All right. Good.
他可以见你了 He'll see you now.
杜邦公司便是其中之一 DuPont was one of those companies.
于是他们将这种PFOA化学制剂收入麾下 So they took this chemical, PFOA.
并且将其重命名为C-8 They renamed it C-8.
随后杜邦公司制造出了他们自己的不可透涂层 And they made their own impenetrable coating,
但这种涂层不是用在坦克上 而是用在平底锅上 but not for tanks. For pans.
他们把这个产品叫做特氟龙 They called it Teflon.
这个代表了美国匠心的产品 A shining symbol of American ingenuity,
就在这里 在西弗吉尼亚州 made right here in the USA,
在帕克思堡被制造出来 in Parkersburg, West Virginia.
但是从一开始 这件事就有蹊跷 But right from the start, something wasn't right.
参与特氟龙制造的工人们 The men, and workers who made Teflon
之后病倒伴随着呕吐 发烧 were coming down with nausea, fevers.
杜邦公司想知道原因 DuPont wanted to know why.
所以他们就往香烟中添加特氟龙 So they laced cigarettes with Teflon.
他们对一群工人们说"嘿 过来抽烟" They told a group of their workers, "Hey, smoke these."
工人们照做了 DuPonters did as they were told.
后来他们几乎所有人都住院了 Almost all of those men were hospitalized.
那是1962年 That's 1962.
杜邦公司在产出特氟龙一年以后就知道它的危害了 One year after Teflon launched and already DuPont knew.
有毒灰尘被他们随着烟一起排放到空气中 The dust, they just sent right up the smoke stacks, released into the air.
有毒沉淀物排放到俄亥俄河里 The sludge, tossed it into the Ohio.
或者装进桶里丢弃在切萨皮克 Or, uh, packed into drums and chucked it into the Chesapeake.
不过之后他们的桶开始泄露 But then their drums started washing up.
所以杜邦公司开始挖沟 So, DuPont starts digging ditches
就在西弗吉尼亚州华盛顿工厂所在地 on the grounds of the Washington Works plant.
他们把废弃物都丢进去 And in those pits, they dumped
几千吨C-8的有毒物质和灰尘都丢了进去 thousands of tons of toxic C-8 sludge and dust.
在被雇用挖沟的工人当中有一个男人 One of the men that they hired to dig those ditches
就是威尔伯·特侬 的哥哥吉姆 was Wilbur Tennant's brother Jim.
但杜邦公司不是唯一掩盖他们痕迹的公司 But they weren't the only ones covering their tracks.
3M发明了一种用于制作斯科奇加德防油防水剂的化学物质 3M who pioneered these chemicals for Scotchgard,
他们用猴子做试验 they were testing them on monkeys.
发现大部分猴子都死了 Most of the monkeys died.
杜邦公司也并不是不知道原因 It wasn't like DuPont didn't know that because
他们用老鼠做了试验 they were doing their own tests on rats.
发现它们的器官变得肿大了 Watched their organs balloon.
而且老鼠开始患上癌症 Now the rats are getting cancers.
他们用怀孕的老鼠做试验 Tested them on pregnant rats and watched them give birth
发现新生的老鼠的眼睛是畸形的 to pups with deformed eyes.
于是他们将所有特氟龙生产线上的女工调离 So, they yanked all the young women off the Teflon line
却从未告诉她们原因 and never told them why.
苏·贝利的工作就是擦洗这些 Sue Bailey's job was scrubbing these huge steel vats
装过液体C-8的巨大钢桶 她当时还怀着孕 where they held the liquid C-8. She was pregnant.
-我爱你 -得了吧你 - I love you! - Would you stop?
她生下的孩子只有一个鼻孔并且有一只眼是畸形的 She gave birth to a baby with one nostril and a deformed eye.
你还记得杜邦在老鼠身上发现的畸形吗 Remember how DuPont had seen those deformities in the rats?
-天啊 -他的眼睛怎样 Oh, God. What about his eyes?
蓝色的 就像所有的新生儿一样 Blue. Just like all newborns.
但是正常吗 眼皮瞳孔什么的 But they're normal, the lids, the pupils?
比洛特先生 放轻松 你的孩子很完美 Mr. Bilott, relax. He's perfect.
-嗨-嗨 查理 Hey. Hi, Charlie.
所以苏找到杜邦门上 So Sue goes to DuPont.
她说 "为什么你们把我从特氟龙生产线上撤下 " She says, "Why did you pull me off the Teflon line?
"是C-8让我的孩子变成这样的吗 ""不是的"他们回答她 "Did C-8 make my baby this way?" "No," they tell her.
接着 她在特氟龙生产线上的所有记录消失了 Then all of her records from her time at Teflon disappear.
一年后 他们让所有的女工回到了特氟龙生产线上 One year later, they put all of the women back on Teflon
并且什么也没说 and never say a thing.
他在里面 He's here.
杜邦知道所有事 DuPont knew everything.
他们知道他们泄漏到空气中 They knew that the C-8 they put into the air
以及埋在土里几十年的C-8 and buried into the ground for decades
是致癌的 was causing cancers.
他们知道他们自己的工人陆续开始得癌症 They knew that their own workers were getting these cancers.
他们知道消费者也暴露在致癌物中 They knew that the consumers too were being exposed
C-8不仅仅存在于特氟龙里 还有油漆 and not just in Teflon. In paints,
织物 呃 雨衣 靴子里都有 in fabrics, in, uh, raincoats, boots.
直到今天 To this day...
四十年来 你们一直知道C-8是毒药 For 40 years you knew C-8 was poison.
你们知道所谓的"快乐锅"是一个定时炸弹 You knew the "Happy Pan" was a ticking time bomb.
并且你们知道确切原因 And you knew exactly why.
就是因为C-8 它永远留在我们的身体中 Because C-8, it stays in us forever.
我们的身体没有办法降解这些物质 Our bodies are incapable of breaking it down.
即便是知道这些 你们仍然毫无作为 And knowing all of this, still you did nothing because
因为有所作为意味着 doing something,
"将会从本质上影响该产品部件 "would essentially put the long-term viability
的长期生存能力" "of this product's segment on the line."
你们从中获取了极为丰厚的利润 You were making too much money.
单单特氟龙这一个产品 你们就能年盈利十亿美元 One billion dollars a year just in profits, just in Teflon.
所以你们将数以百万计的 And so you pumped millions more pounds
有毒C-8投放到空气和水里 of toxic C-8 into the air, into the water
数量多到你们都能在水面上看到泡沫 so much so you could actually see it foam.
C-8无处不在.这世上已无干净之处 C-8 was everywhere. There was nowhere left for you to contaminate.
这个时候他们找到了吉姆 And that's when they came to Jim.
因为他们知道他已经患病且需要钱 而他们也需要他的地 They knew he was sick and needed the money and they needed his land.
租到地之后 他们把华盛顿工厂里 And when they got it, they dug up all the C-8
每一处C-8都挖出来 from every single pit at Washington Works.
这一次 他们把1400万磅含有毒C-8的废弃物 Fourteen million pounds of toxic C-8 sludge
填埋在了这里 and they dumped it, again. This time right up there.
离这条小溪 离你家近在咫尺的地方 Steps from your creek, from your house.
厄尔 你的牛每天喝得就是这个啊 That's what your cows have been drinking, Earl.
把他们关进牢里 Put 'em behind bars.
全都他妈的关进去 Whole damn lot of 'em, right in jail.
我理解你 相信我 I understand, believe me.
但这是民事案件 我们只能期待获得一些赔偿 But this is a civil case. The most we can hope for is damages.
我一分钱也不要 这操蛋的世界得 Don't want no money! Whole damn world need...
-得看到他们的所作所为-你说的对 世界应该看到 - Needs to see what they done. - You're right. They should.
他们要是不会看到的话 我也很心痛 And it kills me that they won't.
但这就意味着我们要上法庭 But that would mean going to trial
还要证明C-8毒死了你的牛 and proving that C-8 killed your cows.
但每个对此事哪怕一知半解的科学家 And every scientist who knows anything about any of this
都已经效力于这些化工企业 already works for these chemical companies.
这件事情并不是意外啊 厄尔 That's not an accident, Earl.
厄尔 这些公司有的是钱 有的是时间 Earl, these companies, they have all the money all the time,
并且他们愿意跟你耗 相信我 and they'll use it. Trust me.
我很清楚 因为我曾是其中一员 I know. I was one of them.
你现在依然是 You're still one of 'em.
你认真的吗 你知不知道我现在冒了多大风险 You can't be serious. You know what I put on the line here?
你想得到奖赏 有谁会颁奖给你 You want a prize? Some medal 'cause for once in your life
就因为你人生中第一次站在我们这些弱势者这边 you took the side of the little guy?
很遗憾 没有奖 你只会这些沾满鲜血的钱里分到一杯羹 Sorry, no prize. All you get is your share of this blood money.
-而你今晚还会做个好梦 -告诉你的家人 - And you sleep real good tonight. - Talk to your family.
不止我养的牛中毒了 It ain't just my cows was poisoned.
你以为我家人吃的什么 What do you think I fed my family on?
威尔伯 拜托了 Wilbur, please.
离开这个地方 Leave this place!
从头开始吧 给你家人一个活下去的机会 Start over. Give your family a fighting chance!
太晚了 Too late for that.
桑德拉和我 我们都得了 癌症 We got it, Sandra and me. The cancer.
惊喜吧 Surprise, surprise.
我在这里 In here.
进展如何 How'd it go?
怎么了 What's wrong?
罗伯 Rob?
罗伯 怎么了 Rob, what is it?
发生什么了 What happened? What happened?
天哪 亲爱的 Oh, honey, honey, honey.
你看见一个痛苦的人 You saw a man hurting and
然后你做了应该做的事 你帮助了他 you did the Christian thing. You helped him.
我做了什么 让他一无所有地死去 How? How? Either he dies penniless
还是放任杜邦公司继续蚕食他们的家乡 or he lets DuPont just keep pillaging his community.
那是帮助吗 How is that helping?
你需要好好得睡一觉. Gotta get some sleep.
不敢相信庭外和解就他妈能让这事了结 I can't believe a freaking case settlement could shut this up.
你有读他们的保密协议吗 Have you read their confidentiality agreements?
但你揭露了一个威胁公众健康的元凶. You've uncovered a threat to the public.
这已然超脱了律师的界限 This goes beyond lawyering.
可 可是我只知道如何做一名律师. That's... That's all I know is lawyering.
那好 那就做一个好律师. Fine. Then be the lawyer.
你比任何人都要了解杜邦公司. You know DuPont better than anyone.
什么是他们所想不到的呢 What haven't they thought of?
發件人: 羅伯特·比洛特
收件人:環境保護局/國務院/衛生與公眾服務部
發件人: 羅伯特·比洛特
收件人:環境保護局/國務院/衛生與公眾服務部
回覆 公眾健康風險
發件人: 羅伯特·比洛特
收件人:環境保護局/國務院/衛生與公眾服務部
回覆:公眾健康風險迫在眉睫
天啊 老天爷啊 God. Jesus, Mary and Joseph.
这些是什么 What is that?
额 一份备忘录和136份证据. Uh, a memo and 136 exhibits.
威尔桑德拉 这两份是你们的 Wil, Sandra, this is your copy.
-环保局宣称将对我一直以来调查的一系列化学品 The EPA announced a public hearing into this family of chemicals
-召开听证会 -我从塔克那儿听说了. - I've been looking into. - I heard about it from Tucker.
-孟山都公司的塔克 -他现在去联合碳化了 - Monsanto Tucker? - Union Carbide now.
他对我说"有个塔夫特的律师 He says to me, "Is it true
向联邦政府递送了一份 "that a Taft lawyer sent a phone book's
堪比电话簿厚的杜邦公司机密文件 "worth of confidential DuPont documents
是真的吗 " "to the entire Federal government?"
内部文件 并不是保密的 这两者完全不同 Internal documents, not confidential. Very different.
-所以你要出庭作证 -我申请出庭 - So you're testifying. - I signed up to testify.
但我却听闻杜邦公司 And the next thing I hear
已向法官申请禁止我出庭作证, is DuPont has petitioned a judge
禁止我飞往华盛顿 to stop me from testifying, from flying to D.C,
甚至禁止我接电话 from even picking up the phone
他们申请了封口令 They filed for a gag order.
是的 这正是我们需要面对的 Yes! This is what we're up against.
-天啊 -大卫 - Jesus. - David.
拜托 汤姆 你在期望什么 Come on, Tom. What do you expect?
现在到底是个什么情况 Where do we stand?
法官驳回了他们申请的言论禁制令 Well, the judge rejected the gag order,
我周一飞华盛顿 so I fly out Monday.
很好 那我们就等着在C-SPAN看好戏了 Nice. I guess we'll just watch on C-SPAN.
你下回要是再像这次一样 You ever do anything like this again,
我就把你的蛋给剁了然后亲自送到杜邦公司餐桌上 I will cut your balls off and serve them to DuPont myself.
滚吧 Get out of here.
祝你在华盛顿好运 Good luck in Washington.
谢谢 Thanks, Tom.
这个材料是一种全氟辛酸 This material is a perfluoro...
或叫它PFOA or a PFOA.
也被叫做FC-143 It's also known as FC 143,
全氟辛酸铵 ammonium perfluorooctanoates.
已经被杜邦的科学家证实 It has been shown by DuPont's own science
PFOA C-8这种物质 that PFOA C-8
是有可能威胁人类生命健康的 is possibly life threatening to human health.
我们现在请求政府部门做点什么吧 We are asking this agency to do something.
帕克斯堡·西弗吉尼亚州
达琳·凯格尔 与 乔·凯格尔家
接下来四十年的总统大选 ...the Presidential election in four decades.
看一下最新的民调结果 Just look at these latest polls.
你是忘记交水费了吗 Did you forget to pay the water bill?
啊 What?
你是不是没交水费 You forget to pay the water bill?
交了呀 No.
我们收到了张通知单 We got a notice.
上面写了什么 What's it say?
PFOA是一种持久性的化学品 "PFOA is a persistent chemical
对于接触过他的人来说· "that is slow to be eliminated
很难从血液中被代谢掉 "from the blood stream of people who have been exposed to it.
杜邦公司说 "The DuPont company has advised
卢贝克供水区域有低浓度的此类物质 "the Lubeck Water District that low concentrations
在该区域的水中 "have been found in the district's wells.
杜邦已经通知到该供水区域 "DuPont has advised the district
十分肯定目前的有害物质含量是安全的 "that it is confident these levels are safe."
这他妈什么意思 What the hell does that mean?
去年秋天来了一封信 A letter came last fall.
我觉得这封信有问题 所以我开始打电话 Made no sense to me, so I started making calls.
我告诉乔不要捅马蜂窝 I told Joe don't kick that hornet's nest.
其实我们都做好了心理准备 It's not like we didn't know what we'd signed up for.
什么意思 What do you mean?
我和乔是二婚 Oh, I was married before Joe
我前夫是一位在杜邦的化学家 to a chemist at DuPont.
好工作高薪水 Dream job. Paid real well.
还有额外津贴 无缘无故的礼物 And the perks! Presents for no reason.
我们会收到礼品目录 想要什么就挑什么 We'd get this catalogue. Just pick whatever you want.
还有些小东西 And little stuff.
比如他之前有带回家这种清洁剂 Like he'd bring home this soap,
很神奇的粉末 this miracle powder.
我们把它放到洗衣机或洗碗机里面 You puttin the washing machine or the dishwasher,
只要擦一下东西就变得干净到你难以想象 just wipes stuff clean like you would not believe.
有一天他到家然后说 One day he comes home and says,
"这个东西以后不会往家里面带了" "Can't bring that stuff home no more."
"为什么呢 " 他不告诉我 "Why?" Won't tell me.
然后他生病了好几周 Then he'd get sick for weeks.
他们叫这个特氟龙流感 The Teflon flu, the guys would call it.
我们知道有些事情不对劲了 We knew something wasn't right.
但是比如这个房子 But this house, we bought it just by
我们给银行看看我丈夫在杜邦的工作证就买下来了 showing the bank my husband's DuPont ID.
靠着这个供我两个孩子上完了大学 还是工程学的 Put both our kids through college. Engineers.
在这个地方 这些都是需要代价的 In this town, that doesn't come without a price.
我哥哥肯尼生前不知道这个代价 My brother Kenny didn't know that price.
他19岁就进入杜邦工作了 He joined DuPont at 19.
2年后死在手术台上 Died on the operating table two years later.
-死因是溃疡性结肠炎 -丹·席勒也是得的这个 - Ulcerative colitis. - Just like Dan Schiller had.
丹是谁 Who's Dan?
杜邦的一位化学家 以前是我前夫的同事 A chemist at DuPont. Worked with my ex-husband.
还有罗杰 他姓什么 And Roger, what's his name?
姓威尔金斯 是他们的领班 Wilkins, the foreman.
还有史蒂文·盖拉兰迪·菲尔德 Steven Gellar. Randy Field.
兰迪得了肾肿瘤 但是他活了下来 Randy's was kidney cancer. He survived.
-但他老婆因为这个死了 -才没有 她是因为甲状腺瘤 - His wife didn't. - No, June's was thyroid.
我们都以为那个病可以治好的 It was supposed to be treatable.
但他们没有及时发现她的问题 They didn't catch it in time.
但是在他们孩子身上发现得倒及时 But they caught it in their son.
你们的孩子出生时是健康的吗 Were your children born healthy?
-是健康的-好的 - Yes. Yes, they were. - Good.
但是当我们想要第三个孩子时 我们发现要不了了 But we wanted a third and couldn't.
我去找医生 I went to my doctor.
他说 "你需要立马切除子宫" He says, "You need a hysterectomy. You need it right away."
噢 我很抱歉 I'm so sorry.
我觉得可能是我运气太差了 Bad luck, I guess.
我当年只有36岁 I was 36.
凯格尔先生 Mr. Kiger,
你可以让我复印一下那封信吗 you think I could get a copy of that letter?
你的手怎么了 What's wrong with your hand?
没事 没什么问题 Nothing. It's fine.
呀 罗伯 Whoa, Rob?
罗伯 你想干什么 Rob, what are you doing?
难道毒死这些人还不够吗 I mean, it's not enough to poison these people?
他们还想要欺骗这些人 They gotta swindle them too?
冷静 冷静一点 好吗 Okay, calm down. All right?
那封信是杜邦公司写的 DuPont wrote that letter!
-而不是水务管理局 -你怎么知道 - Not the water authority. - How do you know that?
你以为时到今日我还不知道杜邦公司的信是什么样的吗 You think I don't know what a DuPont letter looks like by now?
好的 好的 Okay. Okay.
天啊 I mean, Jesus!
太邪恶了 莎拉 It's evil, Sarah.
太他妈邪恶了 It's fucking evil!
什么是"踏马的" What's fack?
看看你干的好事 Perfect.
没什么 亲爱的没什么哦 天 It's nothing, sweetie. It's nothing. Oh, boy.
我很抱歉对不起 亲爱的 I'm sorry. I'm sorry, honey.
你可以给查理奶瓶吗 拜托了 Can you give Charlie the bottle, please?
-他的奶瓶在哪 -在袋子里 - Where's his bottle? - It's in the bag.
-这都是什么 -这些带是给外婆的 - What is all this? - It's from Grammer's.
在她家信箱里找到的 It was left in her mailbox.
-"医疗索赔 终身有效" -喏 奶瓶 - "Medical claims, now and forever"? - Here, bud.
-"终身有效"-这是不是所谓的 - "Now and forever." - Is that that...
所谓的 That...
医疗监护 是不是 Medical monitoring. Is that...
我以为你说过政府不会允许医疗监控的 I thought you said that wasn't gonna pass?
-早安-各位 - Morning. - Guys.
我们的首席原告是乔·凯格尔先生 Our lead plaintiff is Mr. Joe Kiger.
他是潜在的原告 前提是合伙人都同意 Potential plaintiff, if the partnership approves.
乔·凯格尔先生 一位体育老师, Mr. Joe Kiger, a Phys Ed teacher
来自于帕克斯堡 西弗吉尼亚州 from Parkersburg, West Virginia.
代表7万当地居民, On behalf of the 70,000 local residents,
居民们的饮用水被杜邦公司在知情的情况下被污染了 whose water DuPont knowingly poisoned
至今为止已经40年 for the last 40 years.
集体诉讼 A class action?
让他说完 Let him finish.
当地水工厂通知凯格尔一家 The Kigers were notified
杜邦公司已经发现了 by their local water company that DuPont had found
在他们的供水中有少量的C-8成分 small concentrations of C-8 in their water supply,
不过不用担心 but not to worry
因为其中C-8的浓度是安全的 because those concentrations were safe.
为什么 因为杜邦公司就是这么说的 Why? Because DuPont said so.
这是杜邦公司自己认为安全的浓度 This is what DuPont considers safe.
就像滴进奥林匹克标准泳池 That's something like one drop of water
里的一滴水 in an Olympic size swimming pool.
换句话说 甚至极少量的C-8 In other words, even a trace of C-8
就能让水变得危险 renders water unsafe.
但是杜邦公司却是这样告诉当地的水质管理局的 But DuPont told the local water authority,
"不必担心" "Don't worry.
"你们水中C-8的浓度比安全浓度低得多" "Your wells have got even less than that."
-除非他在说谎 -说谎 - Except that was a lie. - A lie?
是的杜邦公司已经秘密地 Yes. DuPont has been secretly testing
研究测试这些水数十年了 these wells for decades.
他们知道自己对水源的污染 They knew they had contaminated those wells
达到了这个等级的六倍 up to six times that level.
多亏了特侬的诉讼 现在我们也知道这件事了 And thanks to the Tennant case, now we know too.
等一下这个东西是不受管制的对吧 Hold on. This stuff is unregulated, right?
我的意思是说 环保局可能认为 I mean, as far as EPA's concerned,
它像玫瑰花瓣一样无害 it might as well be rose petals.
环保局确实没有制定一个关于C-8的标准, The EPA hasn't set a standard, that's true,
但是杜邦公司制定了 but DuPont did.
根据法律规定 要想打赢这样一场官司 And all the law requires to win a case like this,
只需要证明杜邦公司所造成的污染 is to show that DuPont exceeded
超出了他们公司自认为安全的程度 what DuPont itself considers safe.
这就是自我监管 Self-regulation.
-如果你所说的都是对的 -他说的没错 - If what you're saying is right... - It is right.
那为什么杜邦要告诉供水区域这件事呢 ...then why would DuPont tell this water district anything at all?
在我看来他们感觉 Seems to me that they're being
像个有担当的好企业啊 a good corporate citizen here.
你必须在这个期限内发起诉讼 That's how long you have to file suit.
自你意识到水被污染的时候起一年内 One year from the moment you realize your water's been contaminated.
这封信表面好像是在告诉公众供水是安全的 This letter looks like it's telling people their water is safe.
但是实际上却是通知他们水是不安全的 In fact, it's notifying them that it isn't.
杜邦已经启动了计时器 DuPont has started the clock.
真聪明 Smart.
我们的话可能会提前告诉人们 We would've counseled that.
这个通知是11个月前寄出去的 It was sent 11 months ago.
也就是他们意识到我们知道的时候 The moment they realized we knew.
30天之后他们就没有后顾之忧了 In 30 days, they're home free.
这就是目前本案的总结 So that's the proposed case in brief.
但是还有一些要说明的 But there's something else to consider.
是吗 You think?
罗伯 Rob.
C-8具有生物累积性 会在我们体内积累 C-8 bio-accumulates. It builds up inside of us.
群体诉讼那些今天没有生病的成员 Some class members who aren't sick today
明天会生病 will get sick tomorrow.
我们需要在未来也能保护他们 We need a way to protect them into the future.
天啊 汤姆 你不会想要搞医疗监护吧 Jesus, Tom! If you're even thinking about using medical monitoring...
等下 等下 Hold on. Hold on.
医疗监护这种索赔方式 Medical monitoring is a claim now permitted
在西弗吉尼亚州的法庭上是合法的 in West Virginia courts.
-要不要啊 -咱们继续听他说 - Oh, come on. - Let's hear him out.
规定是如果有公司让某地居民 It say if a company exposes a community
暴露在致病物质之下 to something that makes them sick,
他们必须永久监护本地居民的健康状况 they must monitor the health of that community indefinitely.
大家听懂了没 暴露就要追责哦 Everybody get that? You're creating liability from mere exposure.
而且这样的事情史无前例 It's also unprecedented.
对啊 所以我们六个月前没打成 Exactly! Which is why not six months ago,
我们当时这么努力在打官司 we fought tooth and nail against it.
但是你们失败了 我们的委托人 And you lost. Our clients have the right
有权利用法律 to avail themselves of the law.
潜在的委托人 Potential clients.
好吧 Okay.
我理解你 罗伯我理解你的热情 I know you, Rob. I know your passion.
你为那个农民争取的庭外和解很不错 You got a great settlement for your farmer.
你应该感到自豪 You should be proud of that.
但是我作为这里最新的合伙人 And perhaps as the newest partner at this table,
或许应该更慎重一点 I should be more circumspect.
他所提议的 But what he's proposing here is
无异于试图去撼动 nothing less than a shakedown
-一家标志性的美国公司 -我们并不是杜邦的代理人 - of an iconic American company. - We do not represent DuPont.
你代理不了任何人 No, you don't represent anyone.
我们律所已经变成这个样子了吗 Is this what we have become?
专门怂恿事故受害者提出诉讼吗 Plaintiff's attorneys. Ambulance chasers.
为什么你不承认 罗伯 你想翻盘 Why don't you just admit it? Rob, you wanna flip.
你想掌握化工企业 You wanna take everything that you know
的运作方式 about how chemical companies operate
然后拿来对付杜邦 就像个告密者一样 and turn it against DuPont. Like an informant.
-够了 -是这样吗 - That's enough. - Isn't that right?
-好了好了 -是这样吗 - Okay! - Isn't that right?
-是这样对吗 -是的 - Isn't that right? - Yes.
那么 我建议我们投票 Okay, then, I... I say we take a vote
来决定我们要不要继续践行 and determine whether or not
让我们律所出类拔萃 we continue in the tradition
的传统 that has distinguished this firm from everyone else...
好了 这样会议的主持者是我好吗 Okay, I'm running this meeting. Okay?
你明白了吗 You got that?
有人读过他收集的数据吗 Has anyone even read the evidence this man has collected?
故意疏忽 腐败 The willful negligence, the corruption?
都给我读 Read it!
然后再看你们有没有脸跟我说我们该坐视不管 And then tell me we should be sitting on our asses!
所以美国人才这么讨厌律师 That's the reason why Americans hate lawyers.
所以世界各地才冒出这么多拉尔夫·纳德这样的人 This is the crap that fuels the Ralph Naders of the world.
拉普尔·纳德是现代消费者权益之父 曾催生汽车召回制度
我们应该去揭露杜邦 We should want to nail DuPont.
我们所有人都应该 All of us should!
美国商业理应做到更好啊 各位 American business is better than this, gentlemen.
如果做不到的话 我们应该帮它们一把 And when it's not, we should hold them to it.
只有这样才能在这个体系里建立起信心 That's how you build faith in the system.
我们一直认为公司就像人 We're always arguing that companies are people.
而这些人已经越过线了 Well, these people have crossed the line!
去他妈的 To hell with them!
对你们这种专做企业辩护的来说 It may come as a surprise
这些东西可能会有点出乎意料 to corporate defense types like yourselves,
但法律不仅仅是 but there's more to the law than just flooding
用白纸黑字状告对方 the other side in papers.
在我看来 你还需要去打动人 From where I sit, you have to touch people.
这些女孩 她们负责联络 These girls, they handle the calls
集体诉讼的成员们 from the class action members.
不管是什么样的案子 都有成千上万的人要联络 And there's thousands of 'em on any given case.
我们通过这样的方式知悉他们的痛苦 And it's here that we come to know their pain.
不是吗 海泽尔 Isn't that right, Hazel?
是的 我们每天听到这些 Yes. We hear it every day
我的工作就是让陪审团感受这些痛苦 and it's my job to make a jury feel that pain.
不是出于怜悯 而是出于恐惧 Not out of pity, but out of fear.
不管我的委托人发生了什么事 Whatever it is that happened to my client,
一定要让陪审员这么想 that juror has to think,
"这可能也会发生在我身上" "That could happen to me."
我只需要不断强调这种可能 You just keep hammering it.
十亿分之一的含量 十亿分之一的含量 One part per billion. One part per billion.
这是他们自己的文件 自己的科学家 It's their own documents. Their own scientists.
当然了 Absolutely.
他们自己制定了规则 那么也必须去遵守它 They set that standard, they have to live with it.
我觉得我们应该放松一下 罗伯 Yeah, I think we can relax, Rob,
现在他们发起驳回起诉的动议不会被通过的 though, there's no way they're gonna prevail with a motion to dismiss.
这是程序 This is procedural.
放心 我们今天会得到审判的机会的 It's nonsense. We'll get a trial today.
嗯 我等会去找你们 Okay, I'll catch you guys in there.
是我的话我就不会喝 I wouldn't drink that.
厄尔 Earl.
你最近怎么样 How ya doing?
还活着 Still here.
了不起对吧 That's somethin', right?
是很了不起 Yes, that's something.
真高兴再见到你 小罗 Good to see ya, Robbie.
你千万不要 Can't let 'em
被他们打倒 shut you down.
不会的 我答应过你 I won't. I promise.
这个世界 Whole world
需要知道真相 needs to know.
他们会的 厄尔 他们会的 They will, Earl. They will.
罗伯 开始了 Hey, Rob? It's time.
我要走了 I have to go.
我们在此是为了决定是否通过此项动议 We are here on defendant's motion
来驳回由凯格尔先生等人提出的诉讼 to dismiss the case brought by Mr. Kiger, et al.
那么现在 在座哪位是华莱士先生 Now, which one of you is Mr. Wallace?
法官阁下 我是爱德华·华莱士 Edward Wallace, Your Honor,
代表E.I.内穆尔杜邦公司 on behalf of the E.I. DuPont de Nemours and Company,
也就是杜邦公司 better known as DuPont.
嗯 我听过 Yes, I've heard of it.
-提出你的动议吧 -谢谢 - Your motion. - Thank you.
法官阁下 今天我们在这儿都是因为一款美国的特殊发明 Your Honor, we're here today because of a uniquely American invention.
特氟龙 Teflon.
自1961年以来 特氟龙解放了许多家庭主妇 Since 1961, Teflon has liberated housewives...
-停停停 -不好意思 是操持家务的人 - No, no, no. - Excuse me. Homemakers...
这里是法庭 华莱士先生 This is a courtroom, Mr. Wallace.
不是家庭购物台 Not the Home Shopping Network.
原告宣称 Plaintiffs have alleged that DuPont
杜邦公司在给当地的供水中C-8含量 did not meet its own standard of safety
没有达到其自身的安全标准 with regard to the level of C-8 in the local water supply.
但法官阁下 这一点根本是无关紧要的 That's irrelevant, Your Honor.
我们请求驳回诉讼的理由是 We ask you to dismiss on grounds
唯一重要的标准 that the only standard that matters,
就是民选政府认为安全的标准 is the one that elected government deems safe.
不受监管的物质可不一样 Not if it's unregulated.
作出决定是政府的职责 It's government's job to make these determinations.
-而不是公司的 -这是个陷阱 - Not any one company. - It's a trap.
他们不会重提 They can't revert back to...
我明白 I got it.
有什么问题吗 德兹勒先生 Is there a problem, Mr. Deitzler?
抱歉 法官阁下 Apologies, Your Honor,
但是杜邦公司已经向政府 but DuPont has been hiding the dangers of this chemical
隐瞒特氟龙的危害有一段时间了 from the government for a while now.
现在他们又在规避责任 And they're asking you to let them off the hook
因为他们以前就靠着这个策略成功过 because they've succeeded in their strategy.
政府根本不管制C-8 Government doesn't regulate C-8.
不 不是这样的 Actually, that's not true.
不 不是 No, no.
西弗吉尼亚州的C-8调查小组 The West Virginia's C-8 Working Group
刚刚公布了标准 has just issued a standard.
今天在坐的是 Here with us today,
对此事做出贡献的政府官员 is the governmental official who led that effort,
玛丽·苏·金博尔博士 Dr. Mary Sue Kimball.
金博尔博士作为国家环保局 And, Dr. Kimball, as a senior member
的高级官员 of the State's Department of Environmental Protection,
保护西弗吉尼亚州的居民 isn't it, in fact, your duty,
-是不是您的责任呢 -华莱士先生 - to protect the citizens of West Virginia... - Mr. Wallace.
我就直入正题吧 I'll cut to the chase.
西弗吉尼亚州政府认为 What is the level of C-8 in drinking water
饮用水中C-8含量多少以下 that the State of West Virginia
算绝对安全呢 has determined to be completely safe?
看着它从十亿分之一上升到 Watch it go from one part per billion to?
-十亿分之五 -还是十亿分之十 - Five. - Ten?
十亿分之一百五 150 parts per billion.
-欢迎来到西弗吉尼亚州 -本案六个供水区域 - Welcome to West Virginia. - The levels found in the wells
水中的C-8含量 of all six water districts represented in this suit,
是否在这个最高安全含量之下 do they fall below this maximum level?
是的 Well below.
我没有其他问题了 法官大人 Nothing else, Your Honor.
您的证人 德兹勒 先生 Your witness, Mr. Deitzler.
等等 还有谁在调查小组里边 Wait. Who's on the working group?
除了 杜邦公司还有谁 DuPont, of course, and who else?
-谁做的水质鉴定 -德兹勒先生 - Who did the water testing? - Mr. Deitzler?
-这个检测什么时候做 -马上好 法官大人 - When was it done? - One moment, Judge.
样本量是多少 What was the sample size?
我们应该能看到 We should be able to see...
一次 二次 Going once, going twice...
金博尔博士 你称之为C-8工作组 Dr. Kimball, who were the members of this cabal
的这个阴谋小集团的成员是谁 you call the C-8 working group?
反对 Objection.
请注意你的言辞 德兹勒先生 Cool it, Mr. Deitzler.
该你回答了 金博尔博士. Go ahead, Dr. Kimball.
机构官员, Agency officials,
科学界的代表 还有一些利益相关者 representatives of the scientific community, um, stakeholders.
利益相关者 哪些利益相关者 Stakeholders? Which stakeholders?
噢 等等 让我猜一下 其中一位是不是和杜胖押韵吗 Oh, wait, let me guess. It rhymes with bouffant?
杜邦是利益相关者之一 没错 DuPont is a stakeholder. Yes.
那么 我明白了 So, I see.
既然如此 你不觉得奇怪吗 So, don't you find it peculiar that on the eve
在这起集体诉讼前夕 of a class action lawsuit,
被认为对毒害这个区域 where DuPont might be considered liable
负有责任的杜邦 for poisoning this community,
让你突然出现在这里 they get you to come in here suddenly
并且推翻了自己几十年来所谓的先驱科学 and reverse decades of their so-called heralded science?
不是那样的 我并不为杜邦工作 That's false. I don't work for DuPont.
我也并没有说你为他们工作 I didn't say you did.
但既然你提到了这个 我们会在一个月内核查清楚再回来 But now you bring it up, we'll check back in a month.
-尊敬的法官阁下 -说实话 你刚刚是打算 - Your Honor... - You honestly, was gonna plan on
告诉这个地方的人他们可以再多喝150倍的C-8 telling this community that they can drink 150 times more C-8?
大家一起来 举杯痛饮 I mean, come on, people, bottoms up.
说真的 法官 Honestly, Judge...
行了 德兹勒先生 够了 All right, Mr. Deitzler, enough.
我们会在即将到来的公众听证会上 We'll be unveiling the new standard
揭晓新标准的 at an upcoming public hearing.
揭晓 听起来想要开派对啊 Unveiling. Oh, that sounds like a party.
我们一定会去 We'll be there!
他们所谓的安全标准 根本就是一派胡言 Their safety standards thing, that's all a sham.
多亏了法官的明断 Thanks to the Judge's decision,
接下来的出庭我们胜券在握 we will have our day in court.
没错 我们赢定了 Yes, we will!
因为倘若西维吉尼亚州政府 Because if the state of West Virginia
仍未阻止杜邦 won't stop the DuPont Corporation
毒害民众的行为 from literally poisoning its citizens,
那身为民众的我们就自己来做 then we, the citizens, will stop them ourselves.
晚上好 欢迎收看20/20 Good evening and welcome to 20/20.
它用于锅具涂层 免于烹饪食物时的糊底 Well, it coats the pots you cook with so the food doesn't stick.
它还能保护小宝宝的爬行垫 It protects the carpet your baby crawls on.
我想念爬行垫 I miss carpet.
你的护肤乳液 甚至是化妆品 ...your skin lotion, even your makeup.
它就是特氟龙 We're talking about Teflon.
今晚 20/20调查节目将揭露 And tonight our 20/20 investigation uncovers
这款被广泛应用材料的惊人内幕 alarming information about this much-used material.
的确非常惊人 芭芭拉 .我自己烹饪就会用到特氟龙 It is very alarming, Barbara. I cook with Teflon.
我也是看了调查报告才知道 接下来你们就将看到 I didn't know until I watched this report that you're about to see,
如果特氟龙遇高温 that if Teflon gets hot enough...
数百万家庭都使用 ...millions of people have in their homes.
特氟龙已经成了司空见惯的 Teflon has become such a familiar...
制衣和汽车制造 甚至连隐形眼镜 都同样使用了特氟龙 ...Substance that is also used in clothing and cars. Even in contact lenses.
已在大部分美国人的血液里检测出 ...already found in the blood of most Americans.
遍及上百万澳洲家庭特氟龙 一种不粘涂层 ...millions of homes across Australia. Teflon, a non-stick surface...
国家环境保护局 The Environmental Protection Agency
于今晨宣布已展开针对化学物质C-8的优先级审查 this morning announced it has opened a priority review of the chemical C-8,
并提起对 currently the subject of a class action lawsuit
化学巨头杜邦的集团诉讼 against the chemical giant DuPont.
乔 Joe!
乔 哦 我的天啊乔 等一下 Joe! Oh, my Lord! Joe, just wait!
亲爱的 求你了 等消防队来处理吧 Wait for the fire department, please, honey!
求你不要发疯了 Please don't go crazy!
已经在中国消费者间引起了巨大的恐慌 ...have triggered a mass panic amongst Chinese consumers.
快扔掉你的不粘锅吧 很多专家 ...just throw away your non-stick pans, many experts...
你家用的锅让你感觉不舒服吗 Are your pans making you sick?
这是最近人们常问的问题 That's the question being asked...
使用了特氟龙涂层的厨房器具 ...kitchen implements coated in Teflon.
这个房子是空的 是我父亲的房子 The house was empty. It belongs to my father.
我不知道它怎么就着火了 I don't know how it could've started.
他姓凯格尔吗 His name Kiger?
可不可能是有人找错了地方 Think someone might have got the wrong house?
所有这些乱七八糟的说法都太傻了 All of this hullabaloo is just silly.
特氟龙对于烹饪是完全无害的 Teflon is completely safe for cooking.
所以我们创立了健康烹饪运动组织 That is why we founded the Cook Healthy campaign,
为了澄清事实真相 to set the record straight.
而且除了完全无害 它也 And besides being completely safe, it is also...
收到 Copy that.
一路直走 All the way down.
我们现在在录像 We're now on the record.
这是小查尔斯·奥·霍利迪的证人陈述录像 This is the videotaped deposition of Charles O. Holliday, Jr.,
由凯格尔等人诉杜邦公司一案的 taken by the plaintiffs in the matter of Kiger et al
原告录制 v. the E.I. DuPont de Nemours and Company.
举起你的右手 Raise your right hand.
你是否愿意发誓一切居实禀告毫不欺瞒 Do you swear to tell the whole truth and nothing but the truth?
我愿意 I do.
嗯 请说出您的名字 Uh, please state your name.
小查尔斯·奥·霍利迪 Charles O. Holliday, Jr.
你目前还在职吗 And are you presently employed?
是的 Yes.
您的职务是什么 What is your position?
我是杜邦公司的总裁和首席执行官 I'm the chairman and chief executive officer of the DuPont Company.
在杜邦向美国证券交易委员会提交的最新文件中, In DuPont's most recent filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission,
你们声称 "根据过去50年的行业经验 you state, "Based on over 50 years of industry experience
"和广泛的科学研究, "and extensive scientific study,
"杜邦认为 没有证据表明PFOA会 "DuPont believes there is no evidence that PFOA causes
对人体健康以及环境产生任何不利的影响 "any adverse human health effects or harms the environment."
您签署了该法律文件 对吗 You signed that legal filing, correct?
我记不清确切的说法 但是感觉你说得没错 I don't recall the exact statement, but that sounds right to me.
那您是否意识到 杜邦公司在这份文件中的结论, Are you aware that DuPont has, in its own files,
和公司于1970年代的研究结论完全相反呢 studies dating back to the 1970s that say just the opposite?
PFOA 或称C-8 That PFOA, or C-8, as it's called,
对人体生命健康存在的威胁 has potentially life-threatening effects on human health?
我不熟悉这份文件中确切的研究内容 I'm not familiar with the exact studies we may have in our files.
我带您梳理一下 呃 第9号证据 Then I'll take you through them. Uh, Exhibit 9.
您现在拿着的是第9号证据 Uh, you were just handed Exhibit 9.
-呃 您看到上面的日期是1979年3月13日了吗 -是的 - Uh, do you see the date March 13th, 1979? - Yes.
-您看到文件上方杜邦公司的商标了吗 -是的 - Do you see the DuPont logo at the top? - Yes.
-您看到这个单词了吗 突出标注的那个 -是的 - Do you see this word here, highlighted? - Yes.
-您能念出来吗 -研究对象 - Would you read it for me, please? - "Receptors."
您知道"研究对象"是指什么吗 Do you know what that word refers to, receptors?
在这个语境中吗 我不清楚 Um, in this context, I do not.
它指人类 It means human beings.
贵公司将暴露于C-8中的男性和女性 DuPont refers to the men and women
称为研究对象 that your company exposed to C-8 as receptors.
在这些研究对象中 你们的科学家发现 And in these receptors, your scientists found,
"过敏性内分泌 "significantly higher incidents of allergic endocrine
"和代谢紊乱的发生率明显变高了 "and metabolic disorders."
"罹患肝病的风险大幅增加" As well as, "excess risk of developing liver disease."
-您看到这里了吗 -看到了 - Do you see that? - Yes.
而且 你们有过特氟龙导致的不孕事件 Moreover, you have infertility at Teflon.
白血病事件 Occurrences of leukemia.
癌症高发 You have excess of cancers.
包括膀胱癌 肾癌 口腔癌 咽喉癌 Bladder, kidney, oral, pharynx.
下一段 78号证据 Next paragraph. 78.
您看到这个标题了吗 您看到这个日期了吗 您看到了吗 Do you see that heading? Do you see that date? Do you see that?
96号证据 53号证据 Exhibit 96. Exhibit 53.
我想谈谈先天缺陷的部分 I'd like to move on to birth defects.
这个已经进行了快七个小时了 We've gone almost seven hours.
霍利迪先生 您知不知道在1981年 Mr. Holliday, you're aware that in 1981
3M告知杜邦他们在老鼠身上进行了研究 3M notified DuPont that it had conducted studies on rats.
这些研究表明 And these studies showed
持续暴露在C-8中会导致面部畸形 that sustained C-8 exposure can cause facial deformities?
我对3M的研究毫不知情 I'm not aware of a study by 3M.
那么您知道杜邦自己的研究结果也得出了相同的结论吗 How about DuPont's own studies that showed the same thing in humans?
这是1981年杜邦关于妊娠的研究报告 That's DuPont's pregnancy study from 1981.
您看这是杜邦的文件吗 Does that look like a DuPont document to you?
看起来是的 It looks to be.
您知道杜邦否认 Are you aware that DuPont has denied that any such study
这些研究的存在吗 ever even took place?
我并不清楚这些研究的具体情况 I'm not familiar with specific statements we've made about that.
七名怀孕的女性 都是杜邦的员工, Seven pregnant women, all DuPont employees,
都来自于特氟龙生产线 all from the Teflon line.
您看到这里了吗 Do you see this here?
"一个孩子 四个月大 只有一个鼻孔 " "Child, four months, one nostril,
-"眼部缺陷" -看到了 - "eye defect." - Yes.
七名女性中的两个 将近百分之三十的概率, Two of the seven women, nearly 30%, gave birth
生出的孩子都出现了面部畸形症状, to babies that had the exact facial deformities that your company
-这是你们公司早已悉知的-我们到此结束 - already knew about. - We're done here.
先生 Sir.
他父母给他取名布基 His parents named him Bucky.
布基·贝利 Bucky Bailey.
这就是你们的研究对象 This is your receptor.
我要说的就是这些 Now we're done.
环保局针对化工巨擘杜邦 The Environmental Protection Agency has levied the largest fine
征收了有史以来最高的罚款 in agency history against the chemical giant, DuPont.
环保局认为该公司未能公布 The EPA concluded the company failed to report the health dangers of C-8
用于制造特氟龙的C-8对健康的危害 used in the manufacture of Teflon.
杜邦将付给环保局1650万美元 DuPont will pay the EPA 16.5 million.
但其每年从特氟龙生产中获利达十亿美元 It earns a billion dollars in profits from Teflon each year.
调解会议进行中 请安静
总的来说 To recap,
我们以达成一致的是杜邦公司将清洁当地供水 we've agreed that DuPont will clean local water supplies.
并且在共六个水域中安装渗滤系统 Install infiltration systems in all six water districts.
另外 杜邦公司还将向该地居民支付7000万现金 Additionally, DuPont will pay 70 million in cash to the Class.
特氟龙生产线三天的收益 Three days' revenue on the Teflon line.
现在就剩下最具挑战性的问题了 "医疗监护" Which leaves our most challenging issue. Medical monitoring.
我们已经同意成立一个独立的科研小组 We've agreed to establish an independent science panel
由三名与双方都毫无关系的科学家组成 comprised of three scientists who have no relationship to either side.
独立小组将对该地居民进行研究 This independent panel will study the members of this Class
以确定C-8的泄露 to determine whether C-8 exposure has led to increased incidents
是否导致了该地区更多疾病的发生 of disease in this region.
如果小组确实认为某一疾病与其相关 If the panel finds that there are probable scientific links
那么社区里每一个人 to a particular disease, the health of everyone in the Class
将被永久地监护这种疾病 will be monitored for that disease in perpetuity
杜邦将对此花费高达2.35亿美元 at DuPont's cost, up to 235 million.
并且任何患上这种疾病的社区成员 And any Class member who develops that disease
都可以起诉杜邦要求赔偿损失 can sue DuPont for damages.
然而 However...
如果小组无法将某一疾病与C-8关联起来 If the science panel fails to establish probable scientific links,
那么 这个案子就结了 then this case is over.
不会再有监护 不会再有诉讼 不会再有异议了 No monitoring. No lawsuits. No exceptions.
那好 各位先生们 你们的命运就掌握在科学手中了 Good. Well, gentlemen, you are now officially in the hands of science.
嘿 我没想到你喝迈泰鸡尾酒 Well, wouldn't have pegged you as a Mai Tai guy.
-这酒比较喜庆 -我也没想到你是这样的人 - It's festive. - Wouldn't have pegged you for that either.
我们应该庆祝一下对吧 We have something to celebrate. Yeah?
是么 Do we?
听着 我们要怎么知道那个独立科研小组将会证明 Look, how do we know that the panel's gonna prove
是杜邦公司把所有人弄病了 that DuPont made all these people sick?
我不是科学家 但即使是我也知道你会需要 I'm no scientist, but even I know you'd need
海量的医学数据 更不要说 huge amounts of medical data, not to mention
成千上万的血液样本 thousands of blood samples and...
来自那些不相信我们的人 From people who don't trust us.
"嗨 各位父老乡亲 我们要往你们身上扎针你们不会介意吧 " "Hey, folks, we wanna stick you with some needles. You won't mind, will ya?"
我了解这些人 I know these people, you know.
他们会拿了钱就跑 They're gonna take the money and run.
你不这么认为吗 Wouldn't you?
我觉得比起钱 他们更想要其他的东西我认为他们 I think they want more than just the money. I think they
他们想要知道他们是不是会生病 They wanna know if they're gonna get sick or not.
或者知道他们的血里是否有C-8 然后会对他们和家人 Or if they have C-8 in their blood, and what that's gonna do
产生什么样的影响 to them and their families.
所以 我们只需要相信他们会出现 So, we're just gonna trust that they show up?
-信任 但要核查 -什么意思 罗伯 - Trust, but verify. - What does that mean, Rob?
呃 就是让大家进屋做个检查 Well, come in for an exam.
嗯 给我们一份血样 Um, give us a blood sample.
然后我们就给你钱 Then, we'll give you your check.
我又想了下 我的也换成迈泰鸡尾酒 On second thought, make mine a Mai Tai.
一人一杯 谢谢 All around, please.
-罗伯·比洛特. -对 - Rob Bilott. - Yeah.
你怎么想出这个点子的 Where'd you pull that out of?
健康的饮用水对我们所有人来说都是必不可少的 Healthy drinking water is vital to all of us.
所以科学家们需要了解化学物质C-8是否 That's why scientists need to know if the chemical C-8
会导致健康问题 causes any health problems.
从今天开始 您可以通过完成健康问卷来帮助 Starting today, you can help by completing a health questionnaire and having...
哦 快点儿 Oh, come on!
市中心的医疗车 那你呢 ...medical van's downtown. Well, how about you?
-你会做血液检查吗 -算了 我讨厌针头 - You gonna get your blood tested? - Nah. I hate needles.
检查血液可以拿400美元哦 老兄 It's $400, buddy.
真的吗 Really?
成功引起了你的注意 不是吗 Got your attention, didn't I?
好的好的好的好的 Okay. Okay. All right. All right.
是啊 可以的 Yeah. That'll work.
我们带他们到这里边来 We bring them back here.
抽血 然后给他们支票 Draw the blood, hand them a check.
-400美金 -一个人400哦 - $400? - Each.
可得花不少钱 Lots of money around here.
你今天带来了多少人 卢安女士 How many you brought with you today, Miss LUAnn?
我的丈夫 我的三个孩子 还有我 My husband, and my three kids, and me.
两千美金 $2,000.00
-圣诞节马上到了 这钱可不少-对 - Not too shabby right before Christmas. - Yup.
但是你什么也不会找到的 But you ain't gonna find nothing.
杜邦是好人哦 走着瞧 DuPont's good people. You'll see.
吉吉 吉吉 吉吉 Gigi, Gigi, Gigi!
轮到你把天使放到圣诞树顶上了 It's your turn to put the angel on the top.
-你去放吧 亲爱的 -吉吉太累了 - You do it, sweetie. - Gigi's too pooped.
你为什么不让本叔叔托你一把呢 Why don't you get your Uncle Ben to give you a boost?
-哇哦 -妈妈 你还好吗 - Ooh. - Mom, you okay?
还好 Yeah.
说真的 的确很了不起 Seriously, it's huge.
你今年也会被提拔成合伙人的 They're gonna be making you partner this year. I know it.
他们最好这样 Well, they'd better. I mean...
妈咪 过来看 Mommy, come see!
你把装饰挂上去了吗 宝贝 Hey, baby, did you hang that ornament?
-你能接下电话吗 -让妈妈看看 - Rob, can you get that? - Let me see.
好的 我来接 Okay, I'm coming.
喂 Hello?
-你做好心理准备了吗 -怎么了 拉瑞 - Rob, you sitting down for this? - Larry, what's wrong?
-六万九千 -六万九千个什么 - Sixty-nine thousand. - Sixty-nine thousand what?
六万九千个人做了检测 六万九千个 Sixty-nine thousand people got tested. Sixty-nine thousand!
你知道这个数据有多大吗 Do you realize how much data this is?
这就是我们所需要的啊 罗伯 就是我们需要的 It's what we needed, Rob! This is it!
-我的天呐 -你从一开始就是对的 我的朋友 - Oh, my God. - You were right all along, my friend.
-圣诞快乐 -谢谢你 - Merry Christmas! - Thank you!
-当然-谢谢你 - You bet. - Thank you!
回头聊 Talk real soon.
-是谁的电话 -你不会信的 - Hey, who was that? - You won't believe it.
-爹地 猜我刚干了什么 -什么 你刚干了什么 - Daddy, guess what I just did? - What? What'd you just do?
我把天使放在了圣诞树的顶端 I put the angel on the top.
-是吗 -本叔叔把我举起来的 - Yeah? - Uncle Ben lifted me.
他举的你 像这样吗 哦 He did? Like this? Oh!
-大家圣诞快乐 -圣诞快乐 - Merry Christmas, everyone! - Merry Christmas!
特侬案开始十一年后
我们今天聚在这里是为了纪念威尔伯·厄尔·特侬 We are gathered here today in the memory of Wilbur Earl Tennant.
"上帝是我的牧者 我别无所求 "The Lord is my shepherd, I shall not want.
"上帝让我躺在绿茵草地 "He makes me lie down in green pastures.
"他指引我来到宁静水边他恢复了我的灵魂 "He leads me besides still waters. He restoreth my soul.
"纵使我穿越了死亡阴影之谷 "Even though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death,
"我将无惧邪恶 " "I will fear no evil..."
所有人 快一点 芥末还是番茄酱 Quick, everybody. Mustard or ketchup?
泰迪 我跟你说了多少次了 那是我的番茄酱 Teddy, for the tenth time, that's my ketchup.
-查理 别挑事 -什么啊 这个是我的 我拿的 - Charlie, don't start. - What? It's mine. I got it.
-他拿的是他自己的 好吗 -你就是那个律师 - He's got his own, okay? - You're that lawyer.
快吃完 Finish up.
我的兄弟 戴尔·兰姆 你抽过他的血 他说你会帮助他 My brother's Dale Lamb. You took his blood. Said you'd help him.
我是说过 我们 我们还在努力 我保证 Yeah, I did. We're... We're working on it. I promise.
他死了 He's dead.
睾丸癌 Testicular cancer.
留下了三个比你的孩子还小的男孩 Left three little boys younger than yours.
但你在这享天伦之乐 But you enjoy your family.
好了 大家都起来吧 Okay. Everybody up.
-可我还没吃完 -起来 - I'm not finished. - I said up.
达琳一出门就会被骚扰 Well, Darlene can't even leave the house without being harassed!
一开始 他们责怪我们起诉杜邦 First, they blame us for suing DuPont,
现在他们又因为什么也得不到而怨恨我们 and now they hate on us 'cause they ain't seen nothing from it!
-我很抱歉 乔 -道歉有什么用 - I'm sorry, Joe... - Well, that ain't good enough!
他们现在想知道为什么分析个傻逼血液样本 And they wonder why in the hell it takes four damn years
得花他妈四年时间 也难怪别人要这么想 to read a lousy blood sample, and I don't blame 'em!
我们曾经相信你 罗伯 我们曾经如此信任你 We trusted you, Rob. We put our faith in you.
-我知道 乔 我真的非常 --你明白了吗 - I know, Joe. I'm so... - All right?
你们的研究有了任何进展吗 Isn't there just some kind of a progress report?
任何我可以分享给居民们的东西 Anything that I can share with these folks?
他们 他们都还在等着 I mean, they... They have been waiting.
我很抱歉 比洛特先生 I'm sorry, Mr. Bilott.
专家们还在分析来自上千份血液样本 The Panel is still in the process of
的复杂的数据模型 analyzing complex data and modeling
还有医疗记录 from thousands of samples and medical histories.
真的很对不起 但可以麻烦你稍等一会吗 I'm so sorry. Could you hold a moment?
查理 多吃点 Charlie, don't pick at your food.
什么是妓女 What's a hooker?
你从哪学的这个 Where did you learn that?
他跟我说抹大拉的玛利亚以前是个妓女 He told me that Mary Magdalene was a hooker.
抹大拉的玛利亚是耶稣的女追随者
-什么啊 她以前确实是呐 -你应该说性工作者的 - What? She was. - You're supposed to say prostitute.
然而她之后开始信仰上帝 And then she found God
并且成为了耶稣最虔诚的门徒之一 and became one of Jesus's most fervent disciples.
看到没 我只是在教他圣经 See? I was just teaching him the Bible.
我今天没心情跟你闹 小崽子们都给我动起来 I can't today. So everybody up.
快点动起来 Everybody up!
-我们还能负担得起吗 -什么 - Can we still afford it? - What?
天主教学校 Catholic school.
我哥哥又去康复中心了 你知道吗 My brother's back in rehab. Did you know that?
-对不起 我不知道-今天是 - No, I'm sorry. - Today's...
今天是妈妈化疗的第一天 Today's Mom's first day at chemo.
我忘记了 I forgot.
因为和你的官司没关系对吧 罗伯 'Cause it's not about your case, Rob.
上车 Car!
天呐 Gosh
泰迪伪造了我的签名 托尼 托尼退出了橄榄球队 Teddy forged my signature, and Tony's quitting football. Tony.
但是您怎么会知道这些呢 对吧 But how would you know about that, right?
因为您眼里能看到的 都是关于您的那个 Because all you see, all that you...
你 孩子们看到的全是你一天到晚痴迷于这个案子 You... The boys have ever seen is you, obsessing about this...
我有抱怨过什么吗 Have I ever complained?
说话 天啊 罗伯 Say something, for God's sakes, Rob!
-没抱怨过 -没有 - No. - No?
-没有 -没有 - No. - No.
因为我知道你肯定有所需 Because I knew that you needed something.
比如沟通什么的 Some connection... Something.
以及 And...
所以我才说这样的话 So I took it on.
但是如果你突然想开始算账 开始说 But if you want to start accounting, if you want to start with,
"喔 我们还能不能负担得起 " 那么 "Oh, can we afford," then...
我只能说我也不知道 罗伯 I don't know, Rob.
孩子们可以负担得起连句话都不说的父亲吗 Can the boys afford a father who can't string two words together?
我们的婚姻能负担得起十三年的 Can our marriage afford 13 years of...
十三年都笼罩在你这桩案子里吗 Thirteen years of this?
你看这样行吗 罗伯 你想谈什么 谈谈我们现在的生活 How about it, Rob? You wanna talk about it? About our lives?
就知道你是这个反应 Of course not.
我会向妈妈转达你的关心 I'll tell Mom you asked about her.
那个专家组到底在搞什么名堂 为什么还一直找我们要钱 What in God's name is that Panel doing? Why are we still getting bills?
是日常运营费用 呃 Overhead. Uh...
当地律师的费用 Local counsel.
-哈里的电话客服服务费 -每小时1000美金 - Harry's call center... - $1,000 an hour.
这个人是 是技术专家 That... That was a technical expert.
当时杜邦开始游说政府的时候 我们得做公示文件的归档 We needed to do filings when DuPont started lobbying Washington...
这是政府的事情啊 不是我们的 That's Washington's problem, not ours.
不然我们把政府牵扯进来干什么 你的备忘 That's why you got them involved. Your memo.
就是个罚款而已啊 汤姆 1600万美元的罚款 It was just a fine, Tom. It's a fine. Sixteen million.
这点钱对这些人来说啥也不是 九牛一毛而已 It's... It's nothing for these people. It's pocket change.
是 但如果他们被指控刑事隐瞒的话不就完了吗 Yes, but if they get charged with criminal concealment, game over.
-你说过司法部在调查这事来着 -调查停止了 - You said DOJ was investigating. - Not anymore.
-什么 -司法部停止了调查 - What? - They dropped the investigation.
-司法部停止了 停止了什么 -司法部停止了调查 没有说为什么 - They dropped... What? - They dropped it. No reason given.
汤姆 我们的政府和杜邦同一战线 Tom, our government is captive to DuPont.
这个案子 是我们唯一的希望了 This case, it's the only hope we have.
政府知道事情的来龙去脉 所以他们尽可能地增加我们的日常花销, They know that, and they're trying to make it as expensive
希望可以迫使你阻止我继续这桩案件 as they can to force you to make me stop.
-你就告诉还需要多久吧 -我 - Just tell me how much longer. - I...
我 我不知道 我 我也希望我知道 I... I can't. I... wish I could.
-汤姆 我 -你还好吗 - Tom, I... - Are you okay?
嗯 我没事 我只是 Um, I'm fine. I'm just...
罗伯 我现在是管理合伙人 我要经营律所的 Rob, I'm a Managing Partner now. I have a firm to run.
我知道 汤姆 我觉得结案之后会有巨额的赔偿的 I know. And Tom, I think there could be a huge payout here...
你觉得我是为了钱才这么做 You think I'm in this for money?
-不 我只是 -你觉得我会 - No, I... - You think I am...
让你将这个律所的名声毁于一旦 Letting you drag this firm's reputation through a meat grinder
只是为了原告的钱吗 for some kind of plaintiff's payoff?
我 我不知道你为什么同意打这个官司 I... I don't know why you're doing it.
罗伯 听着 我 我很抱歉, Rob, listen, I... I'm sorry,
但是你还得再减一次薪 but you're gonna have to take another pay cut.
汤姆 这是 这已经是我第四次减薪了 Tom, that's... That's my fourth pay cut.
我 我的薪水现在已经降到三分之一了 I... I'm down to a third now.
你现在一个客户都没有 都没人愿意接你的电话 You don't have any clients. No one will take your calls.
现在我还能再做什么 你看 我是站在你的角度考虑 但是 What am I supposed to do here? Now, I'm on your side, but...
罗伯 Rob?
艾米 艾米 Amy? Amy!
- 凯瑟琳 - 快来帮忙啊 - Kathleen! - Get some help!
罗伯 罗伯 Rob! Rob!
我们可能要取消 Looks like we should, uh, cancel
四点钟和杰瑞的预约然后 my 4:00 with Jerry and...
我不知道我们现在还在等结果 I don't know. We're waiting to find out.
当时 呃 It was, uh...
一 一定要让 呃 杰瑞知道情况 Make... Make sure that, uh, Jerry knows that...
我 我得挂了 I... I have to go.
- 比洛特夫人 - 是我 - Mrs. Bilott? - Yes.
我们认为你的丈夫很可能是经历了一次TIA We think your husband's most likely experienced a TIA.
短暂性脑缺血发作 A transient ischemic attack.
血液短时间内无法进入大脑 类似于中风的症状 Blood is briefly cut off to the brain, mimicking the symptoms of a stroke.
呃 打扰一下短暂性脑缺血发作 这次发作的时间并不短 Uh, excuse me. A TIA? This wasn't short.
它 它一直在发作 It... It kept going on.
有没有中毒的可能性呢 What about poison?
不好意思 I'm sorry?
有被人下毒的可能吗 Could someone be poisoning him?
不可能 比洛特夫人 这是神经障碍 No, Mrs. Bilott. This is neurological.
你刚刚说它不是中风 You just said it wasn't a stroke.
这次还不是 Well, not this time.
-什么意思 -呃 这意味着 - What does that mean - Well, it means that
他必须终身服药 he needs to never miss his medication
并且要减少生活各方面的压力 And needs to reduce all sources of stress in his life.
他现在就处于工作的巨大压力下 He's under enormous pressure at work.
好吧 这点得改改 但他还这么年轻 Well, that needs to change. But he's a young man.
不应该发这样的病的 He shouldn't be having these incidences.
他刚打过镇静剂 但是你可以去看看他 He's sedated, but you can see him.
-我明天再给他检查一下 -谢谢 谢谢 - I'll check in on him tomorrow. - Thank you. Thank you.
我就不打扰了 I'll give you some privacy.
有需要给我打电话就好了 Anything you need, call me.
你以后不要让他自我感觉像个失败者了 I need you to stop making him feel like a failure.
我对你家所经受的压力感到抱歉 I appreciate the stress that your family must be going through.
请不要将我视为一个主妇来对话 Please don't talk to me like I'm the wife.
罗伯曾和你说过他小时候一直搬家的事情吗 Did Rob ever tell you about moving around as a kid?
我 I...
高中毕业以前搬了十次家 Ten times before senior year.
没有朋友 没有牵挂 没有 No friends, no ties, no...
只有他自己 他姐姐 他的亲戚 Just him, his sister, his folks.
然后我和你来到他身边 还有 Then I came along and you came along and...
塔夫托律所对他这不仅仅是一份工作 Taft, it's not just a job.
对他来说 这是归宿 To him it's... It's home.
他愿意为需要他帮助的陌生人 And he was willing to risk all that
承担所有风险 for a stranger who needed his help.
你和我也许现在不明白 Now, you and I may not know what that is,
但他绝不是失败者 but it's not failure.
"主阿 我的心你一览无余" Lord, you have searched my heart
我坐下 我起来 你都晓得 And you know when I sit and when I stand
你的大手握着我 Your hand is upon me
把我从死亡中拯救 Protecting me from death
带我远离伤痛 Keeping me from harm
噢 主啊 我知道你就在附近 Oh, Lord, I know you are near
总是守候 Standing always at
在我的身旁 My side
嘿 你知道比分吗 Hey, do you know the score?
就是比赛的得分 不好意思 我的收音机坏了 The game? Sorry, my radio's busted.
抱歉 我不知道 Sorry.
没事 结果会是个惊喜的 Don't worry about it. It'll be a surprise.
布基 快走吧 我们要迟到了 Bucky, come on. We'll be late.
祝你今天过得愉快哦 Have a good one.
嘿 罗伯 我是比尔·李里我们还没见过面 Hey, Rob, Bill Leary. We haven't met.
我是新来的印第安纳波利斯的审计官 I'm the new comptroller out of Indianapolis.
听着 我们现在得谈下没付工资的工作时长和还没报销的 Listen, we need to talk about these unbilled hours and these unreimbursed...
-你好 -比洛特先生吗 - Hello? - Mr. Bilott?
是的 Yes?
我得先向您道歉 I guess I should start by apologizing for taking...
等了七年才打给您 well, seven years to call you.
-你是 -不好意思 - Who is this? - Oh, yes, of course.
-我是凯伦·弗兰克博士来自 -科研小组 - It's Dr. Karen Frank from the... - Science Panel?
再次说明 我真的很抱歉让您等了这么长时间 比洛特先生 Again, I'm so sorry to have kept you waiting this long, Mr. Bilott.
-但是数据量太大了 -拜托了 博士 拜托 - But there was just so much data... - Please, Doctor, please,
你能 can you...
请告诉我到底发生了什么吧 Would just please tell me what's happened?
现在到底发生了什么 你们发现了什么 What's happening? What you've found out?
好的 您给我们的数据量前所谓有 Yes. You gave us an unprecedented amount of data.
这是人类史上最大规模的流行病学调查 The largest epidemiological study in human history.
这点是肯定的 我们现在已经把持续暴露在C-8环境下和 It's irrefutable. We have linked sustained exposure to C-8
这六大类疾病关联起来了 to six categories of serious illness.
肾脏癌 睾丸癌 Kidney cancer, testicular cancer...
甲状腺疾病 先兆子痫 thyroid disease, preeclampsia...
高胆固醇 溃疡性结肠炎 high cholesterol, ulcerative colitis.
这儿已经有3635人患了病 3,635 people in the Class already have these diseases.
以后或许会更多 Many more will develop them.
但多亏了您 这片区域居民健康状况会被持续监护 Thanks to you the entire Class will be monitored...
病人们也可以寻求赔偿 and those who get sick can seek restitution.
您做了好事 比洛特先生 您已经做得很好了 You did a good thing here, Mr. Bilott. You did good.
谢谢 Thank you.
罗伯 怎么了 Rob? What happened?
罗伯 Rob?
杜邦 杜邦毁约了 DuPont, they're reneging.
-哪部分 - 全部 - Which part? - All of it.
他们撕毁了协议 They're tearing up our agreement.
拒绝科研小组 Rejecting the Science Panel.
每一起索赔都要和他们打官司 They're gonna fight every claim in court.
数以千计的索赔 那些病人们一定会放弃 Thousands of claims. People, sick people, they'll give up.
他们根本告不过杜邦的 They can't fight DuPont!
他们怎么可以反悔 How can they go back on...
-莎拉 -他们不能想反悔就反悔啊 - Sarah. - They can't go back on everything.
杜邦是行业巨头 They're a titan of industry.
在这里可以他妈的为所欲为 They can do whatever the hell they want.
没人管得了 Nothing else matters.
他们想怎么告你就怎么告你 They can fight you all they want.
但这不是说你所做的一切都功亏一篑了啊 It doesn't take away from what you've done!
当然可以 这就是他们的目的 Of course, it does. That's exactly what it does!
他们想昭告世界 和他们斗毫无意义 They want to show the world that it's no use fighting.
"大家看呀 这个迷宫他自己都走不出去 Look, everybody, even he can't crack the maze
还是他自己造的呢 " and he's helped build it!
整个体制都被操控了 The system is rigged!
他们想让我们以为体制能保护我们, They want us to think it'll protect us,
但其实这只是一个谎言 but that's a lie.
只有我们自己保护自己 We protect us. We do.
而不是任何其他人 Nobody else.
不是那些公司 也不是那些科学家 Not the companies. Not the scientists.
更不是政府是我们自己 Not the government. Us.
这些都是一个高中毕业的农民告诉我的 A farmer with a 12th grade education told me that.
从一开始他就知道了 我却认为他不可理喻 On day one, he knew and I thought he was crazy.
真的不可理喻吗 Isn't that crazy?
不是这样的 No.
哥伦布·俄亥俄州
全体起立 All rise.
我们尊敬的 The honorable Timothy Burg...
美国阿拉斯加地区地方法院首席法官提摩太·伯吉斯 United States District Judge for the Southern District of Ohio presiding.
现在开庭 直到暂时休庭 This court is now in session pursuant to the adjournment.
你们当听 你们当听 你们当听 Hear ye, hear ye, hear ye.
所有庭上之人 All persons having business with this honorable court
侧身靠近 凝神专注 主将听见他们所言所语 draw near, give their attention and they shall be heard.
上帝保佑美国和本法院 God save the United States and this honorable court.
请就坐 Please be seated.
我们今早在此是为了陪审团审判 And we're here this morning for a jury trial.
所以 3535份索赔 So, 3,535 claims.
以每年四到五宗的速度 At a rate of four or five cases a year,
估计我们在这需要呆到 we can all expect to be here till...
如果我们足够幸运的话 2890年 Well, the year 2890. If we're lucky.
我们最好快点开始 Guess we'd better get started.
约翰逊女士 请问您的律师在场吗 Mrs. Johnson, is your attorney present?
早上好啊 法官大人 Good morning, Your Honor.
我是原告的律师罗伯·比洛特 Rob Bilott for the plaintiff.
还是你啊 Oh, still here, huh?
还是我 Still here.
这系列案件中的第一起 陪审团判给罗伯160万美元赔偿裁决
第二起 560万美元
第三起 1250万美元
杜邦最终用6亿7千零70万美元对3535起诉讼 进行了调解
的血液之中 PFOA存在于地球上所有生物
包括99%的人类
由于罗伯所作的努力 全球各地兴起越来越多运动 并且对600多种相关的 "永久化学物"进行调查 要求禁止PFOA
它们都是不受管制的物质
从威尔伯·特侬踏进律所门 迄今已有20多年
罗伯·比洛特依旧在战斗
布基·贝利本人
背景音乐 I Won't Back Down - Johnny Cash
达琳·凯格尔 与 乔·凯格尔
吉姆·特侬（威尔伯·特侬的哥哥）
莎拉·比洛特 与 罗伯·比洛特