本字幕由NEW字幕組譯制 僅供英語交流學習使用 嚴禁用於商業途徑
NEW字幕組招新群：720899169 快來加入我們 歡樂做劇
翻譯: yy超靠譜 鋅原子 巧手菲比 金相映 攝政王 ringo 柳小兔 沈格子 西比鵝 小漱 平果貓 柴 桃子 SelinaG A.shin 守法泡芙 十一
時間軸: 超能力是吃 顧涼茶 網魚選 汪鵝鵝 格物致知 黑眼圈很重 空集
校對: Laiyx DarthEsther 龍雀後宮三千人
總監: Laiyx
《Stop the world and let me off》——David Ball
*停下世界 讓我離去* *Stop the world and let me off*
《黑水》
*我已疲於週而復始* *I'm tired of going round and round*
*看透了愛情和失去* *I've played the game of love and lost*
*停下世界 讓我離去* *So stop the world and let me off*
讓我離去 Let me off!
*你可看出我的夢想已經破碎* *My dreams are shattered, don't you see*
全能的主啊 Oh, Lord Almighty.
*如今你也不再關心我* *Now you no longer care for me *
-你也不再關心我 -到你了 - You don't care for me. - Here you go.
*我懷念你的吻* *I miss the wonder of your kiss*
*你怎能就這樣離我而去* *How could you leave me here like this*
*停下世界 讓我離去* *Stop the world and let me off*
讓我離去 Let me off!
*我已疲於週而復始* *I'm tired of going round and round*
1975年 西弗吉尼亞州 帕克斯堡市
*世界停下 讓我離去* *So stop the world and let me off*
別忘了啤酒 Hey, don't forget the beers. Okay?
-我才不會把啤酒忘了 -走吧 - I ain't gonna forget the beers. - Go!
來吧 Come on.
要是你需要的話 我可以幫你一把 I'll give you a boost if you want.
我才不用你幫呢 I don't need your help.
媽呀 你可被她晾著了 夥計 Ooh, hell, she got you, buddy.
-啤酒扔過來 -接著 - Toss the beers. - Here you go.
-接住了嗎 -行了 走吧 - You got it? - Okay, let's go.
來嘍 來嘍 All right, all right.
等等 你倆等下 酒給我 Hold up, hold up. The beer.
拿走 拿好 Take this. Take this.
快來 Come on.
這該死的鞋 These damn shoes.
快下水啊 挺暖和的 Come on in. It's warm.
來呀夥計 Come on, buddy.
你下水的話還能順便洗個頭 Look, you can even wash your hair.
我上個月才洗過 I washed mine last month.
-壞蛋 -看這個 來潑我 - Jerk. - Watch this. Do it to me.
勞拉 基斯 過來看我發現了什麼 Laura, Keith, come here. Look what I found.
-我去 -那是個啥 - Holy shit. - What the hell is that?
-那是什麼 -你們在那幹什麼 - What is it... - Hell you doing?
快離開 立刻 Get out of here! Now!
-天吶 -快走 - Geez! - Come on!
一群小破孩 Goddamn kids.
快把我的衣服給我 快點 Give me my damn clothes! Come on!
走 走 走 Go, go, go, go!
快把探燈關掉 白癡 Turn off the beam, fool.
1998年 俄亥俄州 辛辛那提市
參會的有 道爾律所的史蒂夫 We got, uh, Steve from Dow,
聯合碳化公司的泰德 艾克森石油公司的傑瑞 Ted from Union Carbide, Jerry from Exxon
還有安奈特的安迪 and Andy from Allied.
歡迎各位來到塔夫特律師事務所 Welcome to Taft Law, gentlemen.
開會之前 說點兒題外話 Before we get started, a little housekeeping.
大家都知道這位年輕人 Um, all of you know this young man
我們塔夫特律所的律師 as the dedicated Taft associate
在過去的八年裡 兢兢業業 who for the past eight years,
致力於攻克超級基金法相關的案件 has buried himself in the Superfund law.
美國為解決危險物質洩漏的治理及其費用負擔而制定的法律
我可不會為清理工作花錢 I'm not paying for that cleanup.
還是很榮幸告訴大家 Well, still it is my pleasure to share with you
就在上周 that just last week
羅伯·畢洛剛剛晉陞為 Rob Bilott was welcomed as a partner
塔夫特&斯特蒂紐斯&霍利斯特律所的合夥人 here at Taft, Stettinius & Hollister.
-好樣的 -恭喜 - Good. Good. - Congratulations.
早上好 塔夫特律師事務所 Good morning. Taft Law.
稍等片刻 我給您接通 One moment. I'll connect you.
早上好 塔夫特律師事務所 Good morning. Taft Law.
請稍等片刻 One moment, please.
州長辦公室打來的 It's the governor's office calling for, um...
找伯克先生 calling for Mr. Burke.
塔夫特&斯特蒂紐斯&霍利斯特律師事務所
請問需要什麼幫助 May I help you?
威爾伯·坦南特 找羅比·畢洛 Wilbur Tennant calling on Robbie Bilott.
環境保護局罰了他們全款 EPA saddled them with the whole bill,
再看看你客戶以前在那裡的行為 and given your client's history at that site,
真的有這種可能 that... that's a real possibility.
-我會轉告他們 -很好 - I'll take it back to them. - Good.
第12項 米德爾頓 Tab 12, Middletown...
我知道 抱歉 I know. I'm sorry.
-但是他們不肯走 -"他們"是誰 - But they won't leave. - Who's "They"?
我不知道 I don't know.
他們說認識你 They say they know you.
羅比·畢洛 Robbie Bilott?
呃 是我 Um... yes.
他們聲稱那是填埋 They call it a landfill.
其實就是傾倒垃圾 A dump's what it is.
他們跟我和我兄弟說裡面沒有化學物質 They told my brother and me no chemicals, just trash,
但是我們又不傻 but we ain't stupid.
我全都錄下來了 Made them videotapes myself.
你需要的證據都在這裡 All the proof you need.
他們污染了溪水 我的牲口都被毒死了 They're poisoning the creek, killing my animals.
-我正在開會 -我需要一名律師 - I'm in the middle of a meeting. - So I want a lawyer.
帕克斯堡的律師都膽子太小了 不敢接我的案子 Every damn one in Parkersburg too yellow to take my case.
羅伯 他要你進去 Rob, he wants you back in there.
杜邦公司把他們嚇得屁滾尿流 They're all scared shitless of DuPont.
但是我誰都不怕 Well, I ain't scared of nobody.
好的 凱思琳是我的助理律師 Okay. Kathleen is my paralegal.
她會給你一份律師名錄 She's gonna give you a directory of lawyers.
所以我就打電話找了你奶奶 That's why I called your grandma.
什麼 What?
我鄰居告訴我 "找阿爾瑪·懷特" My neighbor tells me, "Call Alma White.
"她孫子在辛辛那提 "Her grandson's some fancy environment lawyer
-是個小有名氣的環境律師" -前台 - down in Cincinnati." - Reception.
是的先生 他就在這裡 沒錯 Yes, sir, he's right here. Uh, yes...
先生 Uh, sir,
我是個企業辯護律師 I am a corporate defense attorney.
所以呢 So?
我為化學企業辯護 I defend chemical companies.
是嘛 那你也可以為我辯護 Well, now you can defend me.
羅伯 Rob.
就半分鐘 湯姆 Uh, thir-thirty seconds, Tom.
-對不起 這位先生 -坦南特 - Uh, uh, I'm sorry, Mister...? - Tennant.
我可以給您推薦一位律師 但是我不能 I can offer you a referral, but I'm just...
我沒明白我能怎麼幫上忙 I just don't see how I can be of any help to you.
你可以從看錄像開始 You can start by watching them tapes, for one thing.
我們走吧 厄爾 Oh, let's go, Earl.
實在抱歉 祝你好運 I'm sorry. I... I wish you all the luck.
我不需要你祝我好運 Don't need your damn luck, boy.
-我需要你的幫助 -羅伯 - I need your help. - Rob!
我一會回來 好吧 I'll be back for this, all right?
好 當然 Okay, sure.
走吧 Come on.
我不是對全面分析沒有異議 I'm not arguing with the overall analysis.
我只想說 無論我們做何決定 My only point is that whatever we decide upon...
謝謝各位 Thank you, gentlemen.
-咱們去哪吃 -怎麼說呢 - Do you know where we're going? - It's, uh...
-在街角那邊有家店 -是嘛 - a place right around the corner. - Yeah?
剛才到底怎麼回事 What the hell was that all about?
他認識我外婆 He knows my grandmother.
是嗎 Really?
西弗吉尼亞屬於美國較為貧窮落後的州
嗯 我媽媽是西弗吉尼亞人 Well, my mom's from West Virginia,
那兒的一個小城 帕克斯堡 uh, uh, from a town, Parkersburg.
我家不全是 我爸以前是空軍 Not us. My... my father was Air Force.
我們經常搬家 We... we moved around a lot,
但會去那裡過暑假 but we spent the summers there.
快來 特雷普 你買單 Come on, Terp. You're buying.
沒問題 Of course I am.
你來自西弗吉尼亞沒關係 羅伯 You can be from West Virginia, Rob.
我不會告訴其他人的 I won't tell anyone.
好各位 就去莫爾頓牛排坊[美式高端餐廳] All right, gentlemen. Morton's it is.
三巡馬提尼午餐 Three martini lunch.
象徵有閒有錢的精英商務餐
要屈尊和我們這些低級律師一起吃嗎 Still deign to eat with us lowly associates?
你怎麼能開美國車 You can't drive an American car.
塔夫特-哈特利法 打擊工會 Taft-Hartley, union busting?
美國1947年頒布的反勞工法案 由塔夫特和哈特利提出
簡直是我們發明的 We practically invented it.
"我們" "We"?
再說 我認識一位受人尊敬的合夥人 Besides, I know a highly esteemed partner
他還開著美國車 who still drives American.
也會開貨真價實的老爺車 Some real clunkers, too.
好吧 但他是收藏 Okay, yeah, but... but he collects them.
這不一樣 That's different.
就像他上的不是名牌大學和法學院 Like his no-name college and law school.
-無意冒犯 -天啊 你在聽嗎 - No offense. - Are you listening to this?
你們先去 好嗎 Hey, you guys go ahead, all right?
聽著 我沒別的意思 Hey, look, I... I didn't mean anything by it.
不是 我得打個電話 Oh, no, I got to make a call.
沒事 飯店見 It's all right. I'll see you there.
-好的 給你留塊魚排 -好 - Okay, we'll save you a fish log. - Yeah.
你真是太討人厭了 You can be such an asshole.
卡拉 玩笑罷了 Karla, it was a joke.
-是 -咱們總是開玩笑 - Yeah. - We always joke.
對 你們是幫玩笑大王 Oh, yeah, you guys are a couple of jokesters.
總之 Anyway...
這裡是阿爾瑪·懷特家 You've reached the residence of Alma White.
我現在不方便接聽電話 I can't come to the phone right now...
他很好 He's good.
今晚還提早回家了 He's home early tonight, actually.
幫我轉告 "你好 合夥人" Tell him I say, "Howdy, partner."
她說 "你好 合夥人" She says, "Howdy, partner."
以後周天還能見到他嗎 Are we ever gonna see him again on Sundays?
能 他周天會照樣來吃飯的 媽媽 Yes, he can still come to Sunday dinners, Mom.
他是合夥人 又不是美國總統 He's a partner, not the President of the United States.
我想做 對了 我的蛋糕模子在你家嗎 I want to make... Oh, do you have my bundt pan?
-還你了 -在哪 我找了櫃檯下面 - Returned it. - Where? I looked under the counter.
就在右手邊的碗櫃裡 裝在塑料盒裡 It's in the right-hand cupboard, in the plastic.
-沒錯 -我以為 - Yeah. - Oh. I thought...
-我們剛坐下 -好吧 親愛的 - Okay, well, we just sat down. - All right, dear.
-所以我得先掛了 -幫我向羅伯和泰迪問好 - So I got to go. - Love to Rob and Teddy.
好 周天見 All right, see you Sunday.
-幫我向老爸問好 -回聊 - Love to Dad. - Talk to you later.
到時候你能裝得對蛋糕驚訝一點嗎 Can you pretend to be surprised about the cake?
她希望能搞得特別一點 She wants it to be very special.
對了 花崗岩瓷磚的樣品到了 Oh, and the granite samples came in.
你明天能順路拿回家嗎 Can you pick them up on your way home tomorrow?
-嗯 -羅伯 - Mm. - Rob?
當然可以 Hmm? Oh, sure.
因父 及子 及聖神之名 感謝 Father, Son and the Spirit. Thank you.
你沒事吧 You okay?
沒事 Yes.
天主降福我等 Bless us, our Lord,
暨所將受於主普施之恩惠 and these thy gifts which we are about to receive
為我等主基督 from thy bounty, through Christ our Lord.
阿門 感謝您賜予我們食物 Amen. Thank you, God, for our food.
感謝您賜福我們家 Thank you for family.
第五街市區 出口
前往 哥倫布 帕克斯堡
哥倫布 138公里 帕克斯堡 209公里
歡迎來到西弗吉尼亞 狂野又精彩
謝謝 Thank you.
嗨 外婆 Hi, Grammers.
你怎麼來了 What on earth?
我給你打過電話 但你沒接 I... I tried to call, but you weren't picking up.
你知道的 Oh, well, you know me.
我膝蓋不好 My two fake knees.
你來幹什麼 What are you doing here?
一位農夫去找我了 A, uh, farmer came to see me.
威爾伯·坦南特 Wilbur Tennant?
你還真認識他 You do know him.
我和他不熟 如果你是這個意思 I don't socialize with him, if that's what you mean.
伊內茲·格雷厄姆的農場和他的挨著 Inez Graham owned the farm next to his.
我經常帶你和貝絲去那裡 I used to take you and Beth over there
那時候你還小呢 when you were little.
是那裡啊 That's the place?
你騎過這匹小馬 You rode that pony.
我喜歡那個地方 I loved that place.
你第一次見到奶牛 You saw a cow for the first time.
學著擠奶 Learned to milk it.
我記得你一坐就是幾個鐘頭 I remember you sitting there for hours
最後一滴奶也要擠乾淨 making sure you got every last drop.
和現在一模一樣 Just like you.
四歲 7月16日
看 There.
所以 你要幫他嗎 So, you gonna help him?
干運垃圾填埋場 閒人免進 華盛頓工廠
干運垃圾填埋場 禁止擅入及下班時間處理
沿山谷上去 You come up the holler.
垃圾場在山上 Dump's up the hill.
我投訴河的問題後 周圍就建起了圍欄 Since I started complaining about my creek, fence goes up.
都封住了 All blocked off.
你好 我是羅伯 Hi. I'm Rob.
桑德拉 Sandra.
州政府 還有帕克斯堡 The state, and every veterinarian
我企圖聯繫的每位獸醫 I called in Parkersburg,
都不回我電話 they will not return my phone calls.
-像我在恩將仇報一樣 -不用 沒事 - Like I bite the hand that feeds. - No, it's all right.
-我已經 -這是個膽囊 - I've already... - This here's a gall.
看看它有多大 Look at the size of it.
從沒見過這麼大的 Ain't never seen no gall that big.
比心臟都大 Bigger than the heart.
這是你牛的膽嗎 That your cow's?
再看看它們的牙 Look at them teeth.
像夜晚一樣黑 Black as night. Here.
還有蹄子 全都向內翻 Hoof, all turned in on itself.
我一半的小牛犢都是這樣的蹄子 Half my calves born hooves like that.
我從小母牛背上切下來的腫塊 Tumor I done cut off the back a heifer.
這要是擺在你桌子上你會怎麼想 How'd you like that on your table?
我應該看出什麼嘛 What am I looking for?
你瞎嗎 You blind, boy?
那些石頭像我的白髮一樣白 Stones as white as the hairs on my head.
石頭被漂白了 我告訴你 那是化學物質 Bleached. That's chemicals, I'm telling you.
我的牲畜在這喝水 在這乘涼 My animals drink this water, cool off in there.
這水讓它們傷痕纍纍 眼睛無神 Get them bloody welts, them dead eyes.
像瘋了一樣衝向我 Charge at me, crazy-like.
那些畜生之前可是能溫順地吃我手上的東西 Animals that used to eat out of my own hand.
剩下的牲畜呢 Where are the rest of them?
跟我來 Come on.
一開始 我一個一個埋葬了它們 In the beginning, I'd bury 'em, each one.
它們是一家人 They're family.
後來死的牲畜太多了 就堆起來燒了 It got to be so many, pile 'em up, set fire to...
你損失了多少了 How many did you lose?
一百 九十 A hundred... ninety.
190頭牛嗎 190 cows?
你再告訴我這兒什麼問題都沒有 You tell me nothing's wrong here.
那個 And...
垃圾填埋場不是一直在這嗎 this landfill wasn't always here?
不是 No.
我兄弟吉姆原來 My brother Jim used to dig ditches
在杜邦工廠挖壕溝 over at DuPont plant.
後來生病了就不再干了 Got sick, couldn't do it no more.
有一天他們找到我兄弟 One day, they come to him,
提出要買他的地 就在山谷那邊 offering to buy his land right up that holler.
他們承諾不會有化學物質的 They promised no chemicals.
我猜你聯繫了杜邦公司 And I assume you reached out to DuPont?
杜邦 州政府 聯邦政府 DuPont, the state, the Feds.
我給那裡的每個人都打了幾十次電話 I called everybody there is dozens of times.
環境保護局過來了 EPA finally comes out here.
-是嗎 -他們說會寫寫報告的 - Oh, they did? - Well, all for some report.
他們說什麼了 What did it say?
你覺得他們會給我看嗎 You think they're gonna show me?
嘿 Oh, hey.
他今天一天都這樣 He's been like this all day.
-好吧 -過來抱抱 - Okay. Go on. - Come here. Aw.
你真是爸爸可愛的小天使哦 Of course you're a perfect angel for Daddy.
拿到瓷磚了嗎 Did you get the tile?
抱歉 沒有 Um, I'm sorry. No.
羅伯 Rob.
今天我沒開車進城 抱歉 I didn't drive into town today. I'm sorry.
什麼意思 你沒進城嗎 What do you mean, you didn't drive into town?
我去了趟帕克斯堡 I... I had to go to Parkersburg.
帕克斯堡 為什麼去那裡 Parkersburg? Why'd you have to go to Parkersburg?
我有個客戶在那 I... I may have a client there.
在西弗吉尼亞嗎 In West Virginia?
你又接了個什麼案子 What kind of a case would you have...?
他是個農夫 認識我外婆 He's a farmer. He knows my grammer.
-不太好 但是 -所以你看到她了嗎 - Not well, but... - So, you saw her?
-你媽媽在那嗎 -拜託薩拉 - Was your mother there? - Oh, come on, Sarah.
我沒有 我沒有溜去看我媽媽 I didn't... I didn't sneak off to see my mother.
那你為什麼溜去呢 So, why did you sneak off?
我沒有 I didn't.
今晚的發言人對塔夫特家族來說並不陌生 Our speaker tonight's no stranger to the Taft family.
菲利普·唐納利 我們的菲爾 Phillip Donnelly... Phil to us...
擔任杜邦公司內部法律顧問 Serves as in-house corporate counsel at DuPont.
杜邦不僅是美國最受尊敬的化學公司之一 Not only one of America's most revered chemical companies,
還是塔夫特不代理的 but one of the few giants of the industry
少數行業巨頭之一 that Taft doesn't represent.
只是現在還沒有 Not yet, anyway.
要的就是這種信念 詹姆斯 That's the spirit, James.
今晚我們請菲爾來 We asked Phil here tonight
不僅是告訴他錯過了什麼 not just to show him what he's missing,
還要聽聽我們這個行業的知名領袖 but to hear how a renowned leader of our industry
是如何保持地位的 stays that way.
讓我們有請菲爾·唐納利 Please welcome Phil Donnelly.
祝我好運吧 Wish me luck.
加油菲爾 Go get 'em, Phil.
謝謝 Thank you.
我們杜邦 At DuPont, we're not
不是為了化學而生產化學制劑 producing chemicals for chemicals' sake.
而是為了人們能生活的更好 We're producing them for people's sake.
讓人們生活的更輕鬆 To make folks' lives easier,
更幸福 更長久 happier, longer.
這就是為什麼"化學讓生活更美好" That's why "Better living through chemistry"
不僅是杜邦的口號 is not just a slogan at DuPont.
更是我們的內核 It's our DNA.
-羅伯 -菲爾你好 - Hey, Rob. - Hello, Phil.
湯姆告訴我的都是真的嗎 Is it true what Tom tells me?
-是的 -對他們是好事 - Yeah, it's true. - Well, good on them.
-他們有你真幸運 -謝了菲爾 - They're lucky to have you. - Thanks, Phil.
就像我經常對年輕律師同事說的 Like I always tell my young associates,
就應該低頭踏踏實實幹活 just keep your head down and do the work.
謝謝 菲爾 能問你個奇怪的問題嗎 Thanks. Uh, Phil, can I ask you sort of an odd question?
說吧 Shoot.
威爾伯·坦南特這個名字聽起來耳熟嗎 Does the name Wilbur Tennant ring a bell?
-你是說泰南特嗎 -坦南特 - Tennet, did you say? - Tennant.
那就不是 不熟 No, not that I recall.
坦南特先生是西弗吉尼亞的一個農夫 Mr. Tennant's a farmer from West Virginia.
他的農場緊挨著你們垃圾填埋場 名字是干運 His property abuts one of your landfills, Dry Run.
他的牛都病倒了 And his cows have been getting sick,
他覺得可能是垃圾填埋場的廢水 he thinks possibly because of the runoff
流進了他的小溪裡 from the landfill into his creek.
你開玩笑呢吧 你怎麼知道這事的 You're kidding. How did this come to you?
菲爾 Hey, Phil.
他是個農夫 他 He's a... a farmer. He's...
我外婆住在帕克斯堡 My grandmother's from Parkersburg.
是嗎 Really?
你在華盛頓的大公司工作 Washington Works. Great plant.
嗯 她認識坦南特 Right. She knows the Tennants.
外婆很支持你對吧 So, Grandma's on your back, huh?
差不多是吧 Something like that.
不管怎麼樣 Anyway, uh...
農夫說環境保護局去了一趟 四處看了看 the farmer said the EPA came out, took a look around.
我想知道 I wondered...
-你再說一遍填埋場的名字 -干運 - The name of the landfill again? - Dry Run.
干運 干 Dry Run. Dry...
你這麼一說的話 我好像有點印象 You know, that does ring a bell, now that you mention it.
我們確實派了些人過去 We may have even sent some folks out there,
如果我沒記錯的話 去協助環境保護局 if I remember correctly, to help EPA check it out.
應該就是你說的那個 That's got to be it.
我很樂意分享 So, I'd love to share whatever came of that
告訴 坦南特先生 幫他放輕鬆點 with, uh, Mr. Tennant, help settle his nerves.
當然 我一回威爾明頓就會去看看 Absolutely. Soon as I'm back in Wilmington, I'll take a look.
謝謝 菲爾 真的很感謝你 Thanks, Phil. I really appreciate it.
願意效勞 Happy to do it.
我們現在去喝一杯吧 你是我朋友 Now, let's get a drink and toast you, my friend. You.
-好 -走吧 - All right. - Okay, then.
坦南特先生 Mr. Tennant!
坦南特先生 Mr. Tennant.
我拿到報告了 I have the report.
狗娘養的 Sons of bitches.
他們以為他們是誰 Who the hell they think they are?
誰給他們的權力 Who gives them the right?!
-他們做了個評估 -"評" - It's an evaluation. - "Evalu..."
這分明是誹謗 Hatchet job's what it is.
我一輩子都在經營我的農場 I've been farming my entire life.
一輩子 Entire life!
你看看 You read that.
然後你再告訴我我農場是這樣的 You tell me you recognize my farm.
-坦南特先生 -讀 - Mr. Tennant... - Read it!
"牛群健康調查 "The herd health investigation
顯現了對牛群的管理有缺陷 "Revealed deficiency in herd management,
包括營養不良 "Including poor nutrition,
缺少獸醫照料 "Inadequate veterinary care
以及蠅類治理不足" and lack of fly control."
你看這裡有蒼蠅嗎 You see any flies here?
現在在下雪啊 It's snowing.
你能不能別給他們找借口了 Can't stop making excuses for 'em, can you?
有可能是因為害蟲 他們咨詢過獸醫了 It could be pests. They... they consulted a vet.
誰的獸醫 杜邦的嗎 Whose vet? DuPont?!
看看你 Look at yourself.
他們說什麼你就信什麼 Swallowing whole whatever they've been feeding you.
不能發現謊言背後的真相 Can't tell truth from lie.
你是不是連我給你的錄像都沒看過 You even watch them tapes I gave you?
先生 我是在幫你呢 Sir, I am trying to help.
別說話 Quiet.
試著幫你 Trying to help.
別動 Stop moving.
放鬆 放鬆 Easy, now. Easy.
進去 Get in.
慢慢的 Slow.
原諒我 姑娘 Forgive me, girl.
天哪 Jesus.
杜邦華盛頓工廠
想要暖心一刻嗎 Need something to warm you up right about now?
聽聽這個吧 Well, how about this?
《Take Me Home, Country Road》——John Denver
*好似天堂* *Almost heaven*
*西維福尼亞州* *West Virginia*
杜邦社區中心
*藍嶺山脈* *Blue Ridge Mountains*
*雪納杜河* *Shenandoah River*
*這裡有古老的生命* *Life is old there*
*比森林古老* *Older than the trees*
*比群山年輕* *Younger than the mountains*
杜邦環路
帕克斯堡高中
*像清風般生長* *Growing like a breeze*
*鄉村小路* *Country roads*
人人有責
*通往我的家* *Take me home*
*那裡* *To the place*
*是我的歸屬* *I belong*
*西維福尼亞州* *West Virginia*
*山脈之母* *Mountain mama*
總得有個原因 One thing or another.
這頭牛雙眼渾濁 This cow's eyes are cloudy with...
他們說是得了紅眼病 the pink eye is what they'll call it.
她的眼睛凹陷進了腦袋裡 Anyway, her eyes are sunk way back in her head.
她像夜鷹一樣可憐 She's poor as a whip-poor-will.
我現在要切開她 And I'm gonna cut her open
找出她的死因 and find out what caused her to... to die.
因為我並沒有餓著她 'Cause I was feeding her enough feed
她體重本該上升 that she should've gained weight
而不是下降 instead of losing weight.
她牙齒是這個樣子 This is what her teeth looks like.
這是上面的 That's the upper one.
但是這一顆 But this one here,
我這輩子還沒見過像它的東西 I've never seen any-anything like it in my lifetime.
甚至獸醫也說不知道是怎麼回事 Even the veterinarian, he'd been in it,
他從沒遇見過這種情況 he would've never saw anything like this
這輩子都沒有 before in his life, either.
坦南特農場 牛
所以 So, what...
你想要我們做什麼 are you proposing we do?
提出訴訟 然後就會有相應的調查 File a claim, trigger discovery,
找出那個垃圾填埋場的真相 and find out what's in that landfill.
你想起訴杜邦 You want to sue DuPont?
說對了 財產糾紛 Targeted. Property dispute.
-我們經常做這種 -並不是 - Routine stuff. - Not routine.
起碼我們這裡不行 Not around here.
我知道 但是湯姆 如果你親眼所見 I know, but, Tom, if you'd actually seen it.
他的農場像塊墓地 His farm is like a graveyard.
肯定有什麼非常不對勁的地方 There... there's something very wrong.
所以他應該雇一個當地的律師 So he should hire a local lawyer.
沒人願意幫他 None of them will do it.
他們都害怕杜邦 They're all terrified of DuPont.
-那你還沒明白嗎 -我們瞭解杜邦 - Well, what does that tell you? - We know DuPont.
他們肯定樂意知道 They're gonna want to hear if
他們的某個當地負責人搞砸了 some of their local guys are screwing something up.
是嘛 所以他們會感謝我們起訴他們嗎 Oh, oh, oh, so... so they're gonna thank us for suing them?
總比被環境管理局起訴好 Better us than the EPA.
我是說 新合夥人應該 I mean, new partners are supposed to
帶來業務 對吧 bring in business, right?
你的農夫付得起每小時275的費用嗎 So your farmer can swing $275 an hour?
可以用勝訴補償啊 It'd be, uh, on... on contingency.
天哪 Jesus.
我們現在是飢不擇食了嗎 What are we, coupon chasers now?
就是家裡朋友遇到點小問題 It's a small matter for a family friend.
我能飛快解決這件事的 I'll get in, and I'll get out.
幫助需要幫助的人 Help a guy who needs it.
誰 那個農夫還是你 Who? The farmer or you?
小心行事 聽見了嗎 Surgical. You hear me?
當然 謝謝你 Absolutely. Thank you.
別這樣 羅伯 Come on, Rob.
我當然會接你電話 Of course I'm gonna take your call.
即使我有點 我承認 Even though I was, I admit,
有點吃驚 a little surprised.
被塔夫特律師事務所起訴 I mean, getting sued by Taft Law?
這很罕見 或者說從未有過 坦白說 It's not every day... Or any day, frankly.
我知道 我很抱歉 I know. I'm sorry.
你我是朋友 這只是個小問題 Look, you and I are friends. This is a minor issue.
沒必要搞得這麼大 No reason it should get messy.
謝謝 我 完全同意 Uh, thank you. I, uh, totally agree.
我把你轉到免提電話了 Yeah, I'm putting you on speakerphone.
所以 你想知道我們是否違反許可了 So, you want to know if we violated our permits.
基本上 是的 Pretty much, yeah.
那好吧 我會派人過去調查 Okay, then. I'll have our guys send over
干運垃圾填埋場有害廢棄物相關的事 anything related to hazardous waste at Dry Run,
這次我會讓他們快點 and I'll tell them to hurry it up this time.
-怎麼樣 -謝謝 - How's that? - Thank you.
-那聽起來太棒了 -別太在意 - That sounds great. - And don't stress.
-我原諒你了 -謝謝你 菲爾 - I forgive you. - Thanks, Phil.
1999年 坦南特案開始一年後
你居然開著你的寶貝車去上班了 You took your baby into the office.
我需要一個更大的後備箱 I needed a bigger trunk.
為什麼 Why?
坦南特案的調查結果今天送過來了 Discovery for the Tennant case came in today.
你居然搶在我前面開始了 Oh, you started before me.
你喜歡嗎 Oh, you like that?
你可真快 You're so fast!
你覺得怎麼樣 What do you think about that?
好孩子 Good boy.
羅伯正在錯過美好的一天 Rob's missing such a lovely day.
法律是一個善妒的情婦 媽媽 Law's a jealous mistress, Mom.
它時不時要宣示一下主權 Means it comes with the territory.
我們到這來 Let's go over here!
很好 謝謝 Nice! Thank you.
這正是我想看到的 That's what I'm talking about right there.
55加侖的鐵桶
沒得分 只落在第一次的上面 No score, just underway in the top of the first.
來吧 再進一個 再進一個 All right, let's go. One more, one more. All right.
全氟辛酸銨
"poly"詞根 "Poly."
那是什麼 What's that?
PFOA
您是指"委託書"嗎
不是 No.
P-F-O-A 沒有"P-F-O-A"搜索結果
我最得意的原告律師最近怎麼樣啊 How's my favorite plaintiff's attorney?
幫幫我 好嗎 Hey, help me out, will you?
你那純粹是個垃圾場 除了垃圾沒別的 You're a run-of-a-mill dump, nothing but trash.
你這語氣跟我初戀女友一樣 You sound like my first girlfriend.
為什麼要用要55加侖的容器 Why a requisition order for 55-gallon containers?
陰謀論 Conspiracy.
那只是標準尺寸的桶 Standard-size drums.
灰 副產物的灰 Ash, ash by-product,
玻璃管 塑料 廢紙 glass tubing, plastic, paper waste.
都只是垃圾 It's just trash.
你只用摞起來裝在卡車上 拉走就好了 You pile it onto a truck, drive it away.
沒必要裝進桶裡吧 You don't pack it into drums.
有液體廢棄物唄 So they've got liquid waste.
肯定無害的 Not hazardous.
否則他們有義務作出相應披露 Or they'd have to disclose it.
那麼 是什麼殺死了這些牛呢 So, what... what is killing these cows?
-不是廢紙 也不是灰 -或許是人為失誤 - It's not paper and ash. - Well, maybe it's human error.
他們倒了一些他們不知道有毒的東西 They're dumping something in there they don't know is toxic.
吉姆 那可是杜邦公司 Kim, it's DuPont.
他們 他們知道的比環境保護局多得多 They... they know more than the EPA does.
每個人知道的都比環境保護局多 Everyone knows more than the EPA does.
否則為什麼他們讓我們自覺監管呢 Why else would they let us regulate ourselves?
怎麼了 What?
我們做到了嗎 Do we?
我們做到什麼了 Do we what?
-環境保護局76年才開始監管化學品 -是嗎 - The EPA only started regulating chemicals in '76. - Yeah?
他們管控著所有現存的無害化學品 They grandfather in every existing chemical nonhazardous
除非他們知道是有害的 unless they knew it was hazardous
或者公司告訴他們是有害的 or a company told them it was.
-我們說的是一個意思 -不 不一樣 - We're saying the same thing. - No, we're not.
我是說 如果公司不告訴環保局呢 I'm saying, what if a company didn't tell?
如果 What if...
菲爾·唐納利同意調查有害化學品的原因 the reason Phil Donnelly agreed to discovery on hazardous
是因為他事先知道 is because he knows
垃圾填埋場的所有化學品都不受監管呢 whatever's in that landfill isn't even regulated?
現在你聽起來更像個原告律師了 Okay, now you are sounding like a plaintiff's attorney.
我要去開會了 I've got a meeting.
等一下 Hey. Oh, wait one second.
你 你聽說過PFOA嗎 Have you... have you heard of this, um, PFOA?
沒聽過 No.
在這上面提到了 但是我 Uh, you know, it's mentioned here, but I...
我找不到關於這東西的任何文獻 I can't find anything about it in any of the literature.
我甚至都不知道它是不是化學物質 I don't even know if it's a chemical.
問菲爾吧 Ask Phil.
謝謝 Well, thank you.
我說了 As I said,
唐納利先生出城了 Mr. Donnelly is still out of town.
我上周打了他電話 還留過兩次言 Well, I... I called last week and left two messages
至今都沒收到回復 and haven't heard back from him.
我一定會告訴他您又打來了 I will be sure to tell him that you called again.
好的 該死 Okay. Damn it.
這是你去化學製品聯盟晚宴的門票 Your tickets to the Chemical Alliance dinner.
俄亥俄州化學製品聯盟
再說一遍 深色西裝跟黑色領帶不一樣 And no, dark suit is not the same as black tie.
他也應該會去吧 Wouldn't he be going?
俄亥俄州化學製品聯盟 1999年年會晚宴
我不知道羅伯告訴你了沒 I don't know if Rob told you,
在念法學院之前 我是塔夫特的前台 but I was a receptionist at Taft before law school.
-是嗎 -對啊 但是 - Is that right? - Yeah. But, well,
我覺得畢洛終究會去那裡的 I think the right Bilott ended up there.
哈洛德 你別走 Harold, you're not getting away from me.
-失陪了 -當然 這是 - Would you excuse me? - Sure, it was...
很高興見到你 It's great to see you.
什麼時候 Uh, when is the...
真有趣 That's funny.
現在 我在羅伯身上看到了我當年的影子 Ah. Right away, I saw a little of myself in Rob.
跟我一樣的寒門貴子 One black sheep to another.
你知道嗎 我父親是個煉鋼工人 My dad was a steelworker, you know.
-是嗎 -對 - Was he? - Yeah.
你看到菲爾了嗎 Have... have you seen Phil?
沒有 No.
你是一名律師嗎 So, you're an attorney?
還在恢復身子 Oh, uh, recovering.
我過去代表老闆處理勞資糾紛 I represented employers in workmen comp disputes,
但現在我呆在家看孩子 but now I stay at home with our baby.
女性律師大都是這個結局嘛 Well, that's the thing with lady lawyers.
傑拉德 Oh. Oh, Gerald!
我想向道爾事務所的人打個招呼 你看到過嗎 I want to say hi to the Dow folks. Have you seen them?
還沒 我一直在找菲爾 No, I've been... I've been looking for Phil.
我有跟你講過我收到他們的委託了嗎 Did I tell you they sent me some work?
道爾律所嗎 這太棒了 Dow? That's great.
只是個小項目 像是一次試用 Just a small project, like a tryout,
但如果我做得好能達成長期合作的話 就更棒了 but if I impress them, can you imagine if I brought on Dow?
我不用了 謝謝 Uh, none for me, thank you.
你不會 You're not...?
我 I'm, um...
你不會 You're...?
-她不會 你 -我... - She's... You... - I'm...
我會盡量多工作一會兒再告訴公司 I'm gonna wait as long as I can to tell the firm,
-顯然 -介意我倆先失陪一下嗎 - obviously. - Would you excuse us for a moment?
女律師們需要進行一次簡短的私下會談 These lady lawyers need a quick sidebar.
-恭喜呀 -謝謝 - Congratulations. - Thank you.
當然沒問題 Of course.
-不不不 -他可能會是個大客戶 - No, no, no... - He probably signs your paycheck.
-好好跟他聊聊 -別把我一個人丟在這兒 - Be nice to him. - Don't leave me.
恭喜你 Congratulations.
我都不敢相信 I know. I can't believe it.
失陪一下 Uh, uh, excuse me.
羅伯 最近還好嗎 Uh, Rob, how are you?
菲爾 我最近一直在嘗試聯繫你 Yeah, Phil, I've been... been trying to reach you.
真的很抱歉 我老是出差 So sorry, all this traveling.
要不約在明天跟你談談 How about I give you a shot tomorrow?
我們需要擴大證據開示的範圍 We're gonna need to broaden discovery to
垃圾填埋場裡的所有物質 有害與否 everything in that landfill, hazardous or not.
事實證明 大律師 事實證明 Turns out, good lawyer. Turned out...
失陪一下 Excuse me.
你在開玩笑嗎 You kidding me?
沒有 No. Um...
我覺得造成污染的物質 I... I think whatever's causing problems in there
沒被環境保護局列入管制 可能他們根本不清楚 isn't something the EPA regulates or knows to regulate.
什麼 Sorry?
我覺得 你提交的文件裡 I'm... I'm seeing things in your documents
有些部分不太明確 I don't understand.
你完全是在疑神疑鬼 You're seeing ghosts is what you're seeing.
恕我直言 你知道你有多可笑嗎 And, frankly, you're making an ass of yourself.
行吧 那你不如幫我指點一下迷津 Okay, then... then help me out.
比如 比如說 告訴我 I mean... I mean, like this.
PFOA 到底是什麼 I mean, what... what is this, uh, PFOA?
它是什麼化學物質 What's that stand for?
老天爺 Jesus.
你這簡直是在釣魚執法 You're on a goddamn fishing expedition.
你 你難道想為了一個養牛的 You want to... you want to flush your career
葬送自己的職業生涯嗎 down the toilet for some cowhand?
好好享受晚宴吧 我不想再回答了 Be my guest. I'm done helping you.
菲爾 我還是要求擴大證據開示的範圍 Phil, I need to insist on broadening discovery.
-那起訴我啊 -我 - Sue me! - I'm...
-我已經在起訴你了 -歡迎各位來到 - already suing you. - Welcome, everyone,
俄亥俄州化學製品聯盟
一年一度的俄亥俄州化學製品聯盟第十四屆 to the 14th annual Ohio Chemical Alliance...
-操你媽 -頒獎晚會 - Fuck you! - Awards dinner.
土鱉 Hick.
那麼 晚會正式開始 So, let's get the fun started!
我很抱歉 I'm sorry.
你不是唯一一個做出犧牲的人 You're not the only one who's sacrificed.
我只希望你能清醒點 I just hope you know what you're doing.
你知道工作和娛樂是有區別的 對吧 You know the difference between business and pleasure, right?
所以你到底為什麼 So, why on earth would you engage
要在公共晚宴上談論工作呢 in business conversations at a public function?
湯姆 他有事瞞著我們 Tom. He's hiding something.
你看到他的反應了 You saw his reaction.
是啊 所有人都看見了 Yeah, me and everyone in that room.
我們律所和杜邦一起丟人現眼 Taft in a pissing match with DuPont.
我要去申請法院命令 強迫他們 I am gonna get a court order and force them
公開垃圾填埋場裡所有的物質 to tell me everything that's in that landfill.
老天爺 你現在真的想鬧到法庭上了 Jesus Christ, now you want to actually take them to court.
我還需要找一個西弗吉尼亞當地的顧問 And I'm gonna need local counsel in West Virginia.
說好的例行公事呢 What happened to routine stuff?
-說好的很快解決呢 -去問菲爾·唐納利啊 - Get in, get out? God! - Ask Phil Donnelly.
我當然記得你 Of course I remember you.
上一次見到你的時候 我感覺菲爾·唐納利 Yeah, last time I saw you, I think Phil Donnelly
還想讓你跟我們一起給杜邦做事 was trying to get you to go out on the links with us.
-是啊 -其實我正在起訴他 - Yeah. - Actually I'm suing him
然後我想聽聽當地律師的建議 and I was looking for some advice on local counsel.
你正在啥 You what?
西弗吉尼亞州 伍德郡 司法大樓
-拉裡 -謝啦 - Larry. - Thank you.
-早上好 -好 - Good morning. - Okay.
-早上好 拉裡 -早上好 - Good morning, Larry. - Morning.
早上好 克萊爾小姐 Morning, Miss Claire.
你看起來真漂亮 Don't you look nice.
把好話留著給法官說吧 溫特先生 Save it for the judge, Mr. Winter.
民事訴狀
你要起訴杜邦公司 You're suing DuPont.
是的 女士 Yes, ma'am.
你不是代理杜邦嗎 You represent DuPont.
我的老東家才是 My old firm did.
我出來單干已經有一陣了 I've been out on my own for a while.
祝你好運 Good luck with that.
只是想告訴你 Just wanted to let you know personally
你申請法院命令的證據開示程序已經生效了 that your court-ordered discovery is on the way.
謝了 菲爾 Thanks, Phil.
不客氣 我的榮幸 No, it's my pleasure.
證據開示 Discovery.
媽的混蛋 Son of a bitch.
不承認負有責任 All right, no admission of liability.
並且 And non...
所有條款保密 Nondisclosure of any and all terms.
失陪一下 Pardon me a moment.
謝了 Thanks.
我的天 Holy Jesus.
-這什麼 -謝了 - What in the... - Thanks.
什麼鬼 World?
現在我感覺自己就像個玩笑 I guess the joke's on me.
可不是 Yeah.
這麼多資料你根本看不完 No one can go through all this crap,
-一百萬年內看不完 -是啊 我覺得 - not in a million years. - Yeah, I'm pretty sure
這正是他們想要的 that's what they're banking on.
-該死的 -媽呀 羅伯 - Oh, goddamn it! - Oh, God, Rob.
-來 我幫你 -別別別 - Here, let me... - No, no, no, you...
你沒必要跟我一起收拾這些 you shouldn't be around this stuff.
-你確定 -我確定 - You sure? - I'm... I'm positive.
不過還是謝謝你 Thank you, though.
祝你好運 Good luck.
你們必從救恩的泉源歡然取水 ——以賽亞書 12:13
華盛頓工廠祝您聖誕快樂 1957年12月
1957年 1957.
科斯塔斯飯店
-嘿 博比 你今天 -要吃什麼 - Hey, Bobby. How you... - What are you having?
老樣子 Usual.
雙面煎蛋 培根和玉米片 Eggs over, bacon and grits.
我也一樣 Same.
我要兩個雙面煎蛋 玉米片雙倍 I need two over, grits, twice.
農民因不滿起訴市內最大企業
威爾伯·坦南特 Wilbur Tennant.
他不在辦公室 He's not in his office.
-要留言嗎 -我留言好幾次了 - Can I take a message? - I been leaving messages.
我知道 坦南特先生 但是他現在 I know, Mr. Tennant, but he really can't
沒辦法接電話 get to the phone right now.
我需要服務 I want service!
-我會告訴他你又打電話了 -幹點人事兒吧 - I'll let him know that you called again. - For Christ's sakes.
她已經習慣待在爸媽家了嗎 Is she getting accustomed to being at Mom and Dad's?
你知道奶奶的 她想念自己的家 Well, you know Grammer. She misses her own house.
什麼 What? Uh...
她想念自己的家 She misses her own house.
我這信號不太好 Um, I have a bad cell.
我說奶奶想念自己家 I said Grammer misses her own house.
好吧 你能不能 能讓我和她說句話嗎 Okay, can... can you... can I talk to her?
她和媽媽去看醫生了 Well, she and Mom are at the doctor's.
你能不能 告訴她我打過電話 Will you... will you tell Grammers I called?
羅伯 你說話斷斷續續的 Rob, you're-you're breaking... you're breaking...
-還有媽媽 -我們周天再通話吧 - And Mom, too. - Let's try again on Sunday.
好吧 All right.
生產PFOA/C-8
C-8 "C-8."
和PFOA一樣嗎
你知道你現在看起來像個瘋子 對吧 You know you look like a crazy person, right?
那個人叫什麼名字來著 Wh-What was the name of that...
你帶來的那個男的 that guy that you brought by?
-叫... -哪個人 - The, um... - What guy?
那個 那個 化工專家 The-the-the... th-th-the chemistry expert.
-做模型的那個人 -吉萊斯皮 - The guy who does the models. - Gillespie.
你們的飲品 Here you go.
謝謝 Thank you.
金·伯克有張報銷單 Kim Burke had an expense account.
哦 抱歉 Oh, sorry.
不是那一類案子 It's not that kind of case.
你瞭解PFOA這個東西嗎 Are you familiar with something called PFOA?
金·伯克-吉萊斯皮博士 1月9日 星期四 下午三點
不瞭解 No.
沒聽過 No. No.
我最近讀到過關於PFOS的東西 I did read something recently about a PFOS,
聽起來好像有點關係 I think it was. That-that sounds related.
那是什麼 And what was that?
長鏈碳氟化合物 合成物 Long-chain fluorocarbon, synthetic.
不好意思 I'm sorry.
化學是我高中學的最差的一門課 Chemistry was my worst class in high school.
夥計 那你可接錯案子了 Boy, you in the wrong line of work.
跟我講講吧 Tell me about it. So?
這麼說 合成物 So, synthetic.
對吧 人造的 Right? Man-made.
弗蘭肯斯坦 Uh, Frankenstein.
科學怪人
還有呢 And?
長鏈碳氟化合物是一系列的碳原子 long-chain fluorocarbon is a sequence of carbon atoms,
再加上一個氟化物 add a fluoride.
在實驗室裡 你可以拿一個碳原子 All right, in-in the lab, you take a-a carbon atom.
然後再添加另一個碳原子 And then you add another carbon atom.
然後再加一個 再加一個 And then another and another.
看 Look.
你在製造一個分子鏈 對嗎 Y-You're making a chain, right?
對嗎 Right?
可能是八個嗎 Could it be... eight?
-八個碳原子 -當然可以 - Eight carbons? - Well, sure. Yeah.
在實驗室 你可以隨心所欲 In the lab, you can do almost anything.
那你們為什麼想要這樣 And why-why would you want to?
我是說 做這個 Make this, I mean.
這樣的化學鏈基本是難以打破的 Well, a chain like that's pretty much unbreakable,
從生物化學角度來講 biochemically speaking.
所以 我想應該是用於工業用途 So, uh, industrial uses, I imagine.
3M公司生產過 3M made it.
美國公司 世界著名的產品多元化跨國企業
他們現在不做了 文章是這麼說的 They don't anymore. That's what I read.
他們為什麼不做了 And why did they stop?
文章裡沒說 Didn't say.
如果 What if...
如果喝了這個會怎樣 What if you drank it?
喝這個 Drank it?
你不會喝的 You don't.
-但是如果喝了呢 -可以點餐了嗎 - But what if you did? - Ready to order?
-可以 我想點一個... -等下 - Yeah, I think I'd like a, um... - Wait, what...
如果喝了呢 What if you did?
那就類似於 "我吞了個輪胎會怎樣" That's like saying, "What if I swallowed a tire?"
我不知道 I don't know.
你想試試嗎 You want to be the guy that finds out?
金槍魚三明治 Tuna melt.
2000年
讓我們開始 Let us all begin
歡唱聖歌集中的452號聖歌 with hymn number 452 in our hymnal books:
"我在這裡 上主" "Here I Am, Lord."
請起立 Please rise.
*我 海洋與天空的主* *I, the Lord of sea and sky*
*我已聽到我子民的哭訴* *I have heard my people cry*
*所有深陷罪惡的人* *All who dwell in deepest sin*
*我的雙手會拯救你們* *My hand will save I have made...*
這兒會發聲 It makes sounds here.
前方有小行星 Asteroid ahead.
準備好發射了嗎 Are you ready to blast off?
《視覺大發現》
有趣的牙齒
我要把這個拿下來 I'm taking off that.
你說那裡面有氟化物 You said it had fluoride?
什麼 畢洛先生 今天是周天 What? Mr. Bilott, it's Sunday.
那個化學物 你說裡面含有氟原子 That chemical, you said it had a fluoride atom.
它是碳氟化合物 所以沒錯 It's a fluorocarbon, so yes.
在化學鏈上會有氟原子 Somewhere along the chain...
如果喝了會對你的牙齒有什麼影響 What would it do to your teeth if you drank it?
別跟我說不能喝 Don't-don't tell me if you shouldn't.
如果確實喝了 喝了很多 If you did... If you drank a lot of it,
你的牙會怎麼樣 what would it do to your teeth?
微量的話 氟化物會讓牙齒更堅硬 Well, in trace amounts, fluoride hardens teeth,
但是如果攝入太多 會污染牙齒 but-but too much, it's gonna stain 'em.
甚至會讓牙齒變黑 I mean, even turn 'em black.
現在我能和家人過週末了嗎 So, can I get back to my family now?
你要去哪兒 Whoa, what? Where-where are you going?
-在他們的水裡 -什麼 什麼東西 - It's in their water. - What? What is?
出口
1996年 俄亥俄河C8排放量
公共自來水體系中檢測到的C-8濃度
你像這樣咳嗽多久了 How long's the coughing been?
幾...幾個月吧 Couple... couple months.
-有一年了 -你抽煙嗎 - A year. - You a smoker?
不抽 No.
把袖子捲起來 我們需要抽點血 Roll up your sleeve. We're gonna take some blood.
我以為你把它關起來了 Thought you left him inside.
我關了啊 I did.
寶貝 Oh, baby.
你動過這些嗎 You move this?
什麼 What?
你有沒有動過這些文件 Did you go through this?
沒有啊 No.
他們來過了 They been here.
出什麼事了 What happened?
洗洗手吧 Wash up.
爸爸 Dad?
-那是什麼聲音 -安靜點 - What is it? - Quiet.
這是我的農場 你去死吧 This is my land, damn you!
趕緊離開這裡 You get out of here!
趕緊走 Go on!
走啊 Go on!
-桑德拉 姑娘們趕緊進去 -這是怎麼回事 - Sandra, girls, go on! - What's going on?
趕緊 進去 進去 Go on, get in! Get in!
我知道你是誰 I know you!
文件編號
志願者所吸的煙中添加一定量碳氟化合物
特氟龍
快樂鍋 讓主婦的笑容依然閃耀
羅伯 Rob?
嚇死我了 羅伯 Holy crap. Rob!
怎麼了 What?
我以為有人闖進來了 我的老天 I thought someone was breaking in, for God's sakes!
不是的 是我 No, it's just-just me
羅伯 你必須告訴我到底發生了什麼 Rob, you need to tell me what in the hell's going on.
我們被下毒了 We're being poisoned.
-羅伯 -怎麼了 我是說真的 - Rob. - What? I'm... I mean it.
杜邦公司在蓄意給我們下毒 DuPont is knowingly poisoning us.
你說的是那個農民和他的農場 You mean the farmer, his land.
是我們所有人 All of us.
別用那種眼神看著我 Please don't look at me like that.
他們也在給我們的孩子下毒 They're already poisoning the baby.
不 不 我不想聽你說這些 No. No, I'm not listening to this.
-薩拉 -住口 別說了行嗎 - Sarah. - Stop it! Just stop it, okay?!
你知道你在說什麼嗎 Do you hear yourself?
你簡直和瘋了一樣 You are acting like a crazy person.
把地板都毀了 把我嚇個半死 Tearing up our floor, scaring me half to death.
我知道我應該要支持你的工作 I know it's my job to support you,
但這不代表你可以把工作帶到家裡來 but that does not mean you get to come into our home,
帶進我們的家庭 然後告訴我 to our family, and tell me
我們還沒出生的孩子被下毒了 that our unborn child is being poisoned.
-不 -對不起 - No! - I'm sorry.
-能讓我解釋一下嗎 -解釋什麼 - Can I please explain? - Explain what?!
所有的一切 All of it.
如果解釋完你還是覺得我瘋了 那我就不再提 And if-if you still think I'm crazy, I'll drop it.
我對天發誓 I swear to God.
我向你保證 I swear to you.
有一種人造化學物質 There is a man-made chemical.
美國研製原子彈計劃代號
是在曼哈頓計劃期間發明的 It was invented during the Manhattan Project.
它排斥其他元素 尤其是水 It repelled the elements, especially water.
所以他們用它製作了第一個 So they used it to make the first ever
二戰期間
坦克防水外甲 waterproof coating for tanks.
它堅不可摧 It was indestructible.
於是就有一些公司開始思考 Then some companies thought,
"為什麼只在戰場使用呢" "Hey, why just the battlefield?"
"為什麼不用這種化學物質造福美國的家庭呢" "Why not bring this chemical into American homes?"
-羅伯到了 -好的 - Rob's here. - All right, good.
他現在可以見你 He'll see you now.
杜邦就是其中一家公司 DuPont was one of those companies.
他們把這種化學物質 PFOA So they took this chemical, PFOA,
重命名為C-8 they renamed it C-8,
讓家務變得更簡單
並用它製作了堅固的塗層 and they made their own impenetrable coating,
不是坦克的 而是煎鍋的 but not for tanks. For pans.
連煎蛋也不是特氟龍的對手
他們給塗層命名為特氟龍 They called it Teflon.
一個代表了美國智慧的卓越產品 A shining symbol of American ingenuity
就在這裡生產 美國西弗吉尼亞州的帕克斯堡 made right here in the USA in Parkersburg, West Virginia.
歡迎來到充滿野性與奇妙的西弗吉尼亞
但從一開始 就有些不太對勁 But right from the start, something wasn't right.
所有參與生產特氟龍的人 The men and workers who made Teflon
都感到噁心 開始發燒 were coming down with nausea, fevers.
免疫毒性
杜邦公司想要找出原因 DuPont wanted to know why.
所以在香煙中摻入少量特氟龍 So they laced cigarettes with Teflon.
讓一群工人來抽 They told a group of the workers, "Hey, smoke these."
這些工人依照指示做了 DuPonters did as they were told.
幾乎所有人都進了醫院 Almost all those men were hospitalized.
這件事發生在一九六二年 That's 1962,
特氟龍問世一年後 杜邦公司就已經知道真相了 one year after Teflon launched, and already DuPont knew.
他們把煙塵通過煙囪 The dust, they just sent right up the smokestacks,
排入大氣中 released into the air.
工業廢料被運到俄亥俄州丟棄 The sludge, tossed it into the Ohio.
或是裝入大桶 Or, uh, packed into drums
五十五加侖鐵桶
運到切薩皮克[美國東部海灣]丟棄 and-and-and chucked it into the Chesapeake.
可後來這些桶被衝上了岸 But then the drums started washing up.
於是杜邦公司開始 So DuPont starts digging ditches
在華盛頓工業區挖掘填埋坑 on the grounds of the Washington Works plant.
在這些填埋坑裡 And in those pits,
他們丟棄了成千上萬噸有毒的C-8粉塵和廢渣 they dumped thousands of tons of toxic C-8 sludge and dust.
威爾伯·坦南特的弟弟吉姆 One of the men that they hired to dig those ditches
就是挖填埋坑的工人之一 was Wilbur Tennant's brother Jim.
掩蓋罪行的可不止這一家公司 But they weren't the only ones covering their tracks.
3M公司首創將這一化學物質用於生產皮革保護劑 3M, who-who pioneered these chemicals for Scotchgard,
明尼蘇達礦務及製造業公司
他們在猴子身上做實驗 they were testing them on monkeys.
大部分猴子都死了 Most of the monkeys died.
別以為杜邦不知道這些 It wasn't like DuPont didn't know that,
他們也用老鼠進行了實驗 because they were doing their own tests on rats.
觀察到它們的器官膨脹 Watched their organs balloon.
後來這些老鼠都得了癌症 Now the rats are getting cancers.
他們又繼續在懷孕母鼠身上試驗 Tested them on pregnant rats
觀察到它們生下 and watched them give birth
眼睛畸形的小鼠 to pups with deformed eyes.
於是他們緊急調離了特氟龍生產線的所有年輕女工 So they yanked all the young women off the Teflon line,
從不曾告訴她們原因 never told them why.
蘇·貝利的工作是清洗這些 Sue Bailey's job was scrubbing these huge steel vats
儲存C-8液體的巨型鐵桶 where they held the liquid C-8.
當時她懷孕了 She was pregnant.
我愛你 I love you.
你能不能別說了 Would you stop?
她生下的寶寶 She gave birth to a baby
只有一個鼻孔 還有一隻眼睛畸形 with one nostril and a deformed eye.
還記得杜邦公司是怎麼在老鼠身上發現畸形的嗎 Remember how DuPont had seen those deformities in the rats?
天哪 Oh, God.
他的眼睛怎麼樣 What about his eyes?
藍色的 和所有新生兒一樣 Blue, just like all newborns.
它們正常嗎 眼瞼瞳孔什麼的 But they're normal... The lids, the-the pupils?
畢洛先生 放輕鬆 Mr. Bilott, relax.
-他完美無缺 -嗨 - He's perfect. - Ah, hey.
我的小查理 Hi, Charlie.
於是蘇來到杜邦公司 So Sue goes to DuPont.
她說 "為什麼把我從特氟龍生產線上撤下來 She says, "Why did you pull me off the Teflon line?
是C-8把我的孩子變成這樣的嗎" Did C-8 make my baby this way?"
"沒有的事" 他們告訴她 "No," They tell her.
接著她在特氟龍生產線工作的所有記錄被抹去 Then all of her records from her time at Teflon disappear.
一年後 他們把女工重新拉回特氟龍生產線上 One year later, they put all of the women back on Teflon
對此隻字未提 and never say a thing.
他到了 He's here.
杜邦公司對此心知肚明 DuPont knew everything.
他們知道 They knew
幾十年來他們排放到空氣中的 that the C-8 they put into the air
還有填埋在地下的C-8 and buried into the ground for decades
能誘發癌症 was causing cancers.
他們知道自己的工人 They knew that their own workers
得了這些癌症 were getting these cancers.
他們知道消費者同樣被暴露在這種危險中 They knew that the consumers, too, were being exposed.
不只是在特氟龍裡 And not just in Teflon.
還有油漆 布料 In-in paints, in fabrics,
雨衣 還有靴子 in raincoats, boots.
直到現在 To this day.
40年來 For 40 years,
你們知道C-8有毒 you knew C-8 was poison.
你們知道快樂鍋是個定時炸彈 You knew the Happy Pan was a ticking time bomb.
你們完全知道原因 And you knew exactly why.
因為C-8能永久留存於人體 Because C-8, it stays in us forever.
人體沒辦法分解它 Our bodies are incapable of breaking it down.
你們知道這些卻仍然無動於衷 And knowing all of this, still you did nothing,
因為一旦採取措施 以下引述 because doing something, quote,
"本質上會讓這個產品的 "Would essentially put the long-term viability
長期可行性受到影響" 引述完畢 of this product segment on the line," End quote.
你們賺了太多黑心錢 You were making too much money.
每年光特氟龍這條生產線的利潤就有十億美元 $1 billion a year just in profit, just in Teflon.
所以你們就繼續把數以萬計 And so you pumped millions more pounds
有毒的C-8排放到空氣和水裡 of toxic C-8 into the air, into the water,
多到看得見它們泛起的泡沫 so much so you could actually see it foam.
C-8無處不在 C-8 was everywhere.
已經沒有一處淨土供你們污染了 There was nowhere left for you to contaminate.
於是他們找到了吉姆 And that's when they came to Jim.
他們知道他生病需要錢 They knew he was sick and needed the money,
他們正好需要他的地 and they needed his land.
拿到了土地後他們就挖出了 And when they got it, they dug up all the C-8
華盛頓工廠所有填埋坑裡的C-8 from every single pit at Washington Works...
635萬公斤有毒的C-8污泥 14 million pounds of toxic C-8 sludge...
把它們再次掩埋 And they dumped it again.
這次就埋在了那裡 This time right up there.
離你的小河和房子只有幾步遠 Steps from your creek, from your house.
厄爾 那就是你的牛喝水的河 And that's what your cows have been drinking, Earl.
把他們關進監獄 Put 'em behind bars.
所有該死的人 讓他們爛在監獄裡 Whole damn lot of 'em, rot in jail.
我理解 相信我 但這是個民事案件 I understand, believe me, but th-this is a civil case.
-最多能指望拿到損害賠償金 -我不要錢 - The most we can hope for is damages. - Don't want no money!
全天下都得看到 Whole damn world need...
看到他們幹的事 needs to see what they done.
你說得對 這是他們應得的 You're right. They should.
他們沒有受到應有的懲罰我也很煎熬 And it... and it kills me that they won't.
但是這意味著我們要受審 But that would mean going to trial
證明C-8毒死了你的牛 and proving that C-8 killed your cows.
每一個對此有所瞭解的科學家 And every scientist who knows anything about any of this
都在為這些化學公司工作 already works for these chemical companies.
這不是偶然 厄爾 That's not an accident, Earl.
厄爾 這些公司有錢有時間 Earl, these... these companies, they have all the money,
他們會利用這些來擺平一切 all the time, and they'll use it.
相信我 我曾是他們中的一員 Trust me, I know... I was one of them.
你現在還是 You're still one of 'em.
你在開玩笑吧 You-you can't be serious.
你知道我冒著多大的風險嗎 You-you know what I put on the line here?
你想要獎賞嗎 You want a prize?
獎牌之類的 因為這是你唯一一次 Some medal 'cause, for once in your life,
站在弱勢人群這一邊 you took the side of the little guy?
抱歉 沒有獎賞 Sorry, no prize.
你能分到的只有他們的血腥錢 All you get is your share of this blood money.
你便可以一夜好夢 And you sleep real good tonight.
和你的家人說說 Talk to your family.
被下毒的不僅僅是我的牛 It ain't just my cows that was poisoned.
你覺得我家人吃的是什麼 What you think I fed my family on?
威爾伯 Wilbur...
拜託了 please!
離開這裡 Leave this place!
重新開始 Start over!
給你的家人一個活命的機會 Give your family a fighting chance!
太晚了 Too late for that.
我們已經得了 桑德拉和我 得了癌症 We got it, Sandra and me... The cancer.
驚喜連連 Surprise, surprise.
房屋出售
我在這兒 In here.
怎麼樣 How'd it go?
出什麼事了 What's wrong?
羅伯 Rob?
羅伯 怎麼了 Rob, what is it?
發生什麼了 發生什麼了 What happened? What happened?
親愛的 親愛的 親愛的 Oh, honey, honey, honey.
你看到受傷的人 You saw a man hurting, and...
就做了慈悲的事情 you did the Christian thing.
-你幫了他 -怎麼幫的 - You helped him. - How?
怎麼幫了 他要麼身無分無地死去 How? How? Either he dies penniless
要麼就讓杜邦繼續糟蹋他的社區 or he lets DuPont just keep pillaging his community.
這算什麼幫忙 How is that helping?
我得睡一會 Got to get some sleep.
真不敢相信一個破協議 I can't believe a freaking case settlement
就能結束這一切 could shut this up.
你見過他們的保密協定嗎 Have you read their confidentiality agreements?
你揭露了一個對公眾的威脅 You've uncovered a threat to the public.
這已經超出律師事務了 This goes beyond lawyering.
我只會當個律師 That's... That's all I know is lawyering.
好吧 那就當那個律師 Fine. Then be the lawyer.
你比任何人都瞭解杜邦 You know DuPont better than anyone.
他們還有什麼沒考慮到 What haven't they thought of?
來自 羅伯特·畢洛
收件人 美國國家環境保護局 美國司法部
美國衛生與公眾服務部 主題:公眾健康受到威脅
主題:刻不容緩 公眾健康受到威脅
我滴個老天爺 God, Jesus, Mary and Joseph.
這是什麼 What is that?
一份備忘錄和136項證據 A memo and 136 exhibits.
原始 0 數量 15 複印 0
塔夫特律師事務所
杜邦傾倒數千噸C-8垃圾
原始 8 數量 15 複印 7
代表坦南特一家 起訴杜邦公司
杜邦哈斯科爾實驗室
原始 11 數量 15 複印 10
飲用水法案 清潔空氣法案
遞送至: 美國國家環境保護局 代理地區管理員
威爾伯 桑德拉 這是你們的複印件 Wilbur, Sandra, this is your copy.
12條未讀信息 文件洩露
環保局已經宣佈 將會對這一系列 The EPA announced a public hearing
我正在調查的化學物質舉行公開聽證 into this family of chemicals I've been looking into.
我從塔克那兒聽說了 I heard about it from Tucker.
-孟山都那個塔克 他現在在聯合碳化了 - "Monsanto" Tucker? - Union Carbide now.
孟山都和聯合碳化都是美國的化工企業
他跟我說 "一個塔夫特的律師 He says to me, "Is it true that a Taft lawyer sent
把和電話本一樣厚的杜邦機密文件 a phone book's worth of confidential DuPont documents
美國電話本厚度至少是《現代漢語詞典》的一半
-全發給了聯邦政府" -內部文件 - to the entire federal government?" - Internal documents,
不是機密的 not... not confidential.
-區別很大 -所以你會出庭作證 - Very different. - So you're testifying.
我簽字同意作證 結果我聽說 I signed up to testify, and the next thing I hear is
杜邦立刻請求法官 DuPont has petitioned a judge
不讓我作證 不讓我飛去華盛頓特區 to stop me from testifying, from flying to D.C.,
甚至不讓我接電話 from even picking up the phone...
-他們申請了禁言令 -是的 - They filed for a gag order. - Yes.
-這就是我們的對手 -天啊 - This is what we're up against. - Jesus.
-大衛 -你看看 湯姆 - David. - I mean, come on, Tom.
-你以為會怎樣 -我們站哪邊 - What do you expect? - Where do we stand?
不過法官拒絕了禁言令 Well, the judge rejected the gag order,
我週一就飛過去 so I fly out Monday.
很好 Nice.
我們到時候會在電視上看你的 I guess we'll just watch on C-SPAN.
如果你再敢幹這種事 You ever do anything like this again,
我會親手把你蛋蛋割了送給杜邦公司 I will cut your balls off and serve them to DuPont myself.
行了 滾吧 Now get out of here.
祝你好運 Good luck in Washington.
謝了 湯姆 Thanks, Tom.
這種材料是全氟碳 或者叫PFOA This material, uh, is a perfluoro, or a PFOA.
也被稱為FC-143 It's also known as FC-143,
羅伯·畢洛 塔夫特律師事務所 合夥人
直播
全氟辛酸銨 ammonium perfluorooctanoate.
杜邦自己的科學實驗就已經證實了 It has been shown by DuPont's own science
PFOA/C-8 that PFOA/C-8
對人體可能有生命威脅 is possibly life-threatening to human health.
我們請求環保局能採取行動 We are asking this agency to do something.
帕克斯堡 西弗吉尼亞州
喬·基格和達琳·基格的家
四十年一遇的總統競選 Presidential election in four decades.
看這個今天早上最新民意結果 Just look at these latest polls this morning...
布什 47% 戈爾 44% 納德 3%
你忘了交水費嗎 Did you forget to pay the water bill?
什麼 What?
你忘了交水費嗎 You forget to pay the water bill?
沒有啊 No.
這有一份通知 We got a notice.
上面怎麼說 What's it say?
"PFOA是一種穩定的化學物質 "PFOA is a persistent chemical that is slow
呂貝克 公共服務區
暴露在這種物質中的人 to be eliminated from the bloodstream
其血液很難排出這種物質 of people who have been exposed to it.
杜邦公司通知呂貝克供水區域 The DuPont Company has advised the Lubeck water district
區內的水井裡 that low concentrations have been found
已發現低濃度的此物質 in the district's wells.
杜邦還通知本區 DuPont has advised the district
這種濃度是安全的" that it is confident these levels are safe."
這都是什麼鬼 What the hell does that mean?
去年秋天收到一封信 A letter came last fall.
我完全看不懂 所以我開始打電話問人 Made no sense to me, so I started making calls.
我告訴喬不要捅那個馬蜂窩 I told Joe, don't kick that hornet's nest.
我們不是不清楚要幹什麼 It's not like we didn't know what we'd signed up for.
您這是什麼意思 What do you mean?
嫁給喬之前 我前夫是杜邦的化學家 Oh, I was married before Joe, um, to a chemist at DuPont.
理想職業 工資很高 Dream job. Paid real well.
還有津貼 And the perks.
各種福利 Presents for no reason.
我們有個產品名錄 We'd get this catalog.
隨便挑 Just pick whatever you want.
還有些小東西 And little stuff.
他會帶回了一種肥皂 神奇的粉末 Like he'd bring home this soap, this miracle powder.
放進洗衣機或者洗碗機 You put it in the washing machine or the dishwasher...
把東西洗得難以置信的乾淨 Just wipes stuff clean like you would not believe.
有天他回家時說 One day, he comes home and says,
"不能再帶那東西回來了" "Can't bring that stuff home no more."
"為什麼" 他不肯告訴我 "Why?" Won't tell me.
然後他病了好幾周 Then he'd get sick for weeks.
他們稱之為特氟龍流感 The Teflon flu, the guys would call it.
我們知道事有蹊蹺 We knew something wasn't right.
但是 我們當初買這房子時 But this house, we bought it
銀行僅僅是看了我前夫的杜邦工作證就同意了 just by showing the bank my husband's DuPont I.D.
讓兩個孩子都上了大學 Put both our kids through college.
都是工程師 Engineers.
在這鎮上 這些事都是有代價的 In... in this town, that doesn't come without a price.
我兄弟肯尼並不知道這個代價 My brother Kenny didn't know that price.
他19歲就加入杜邦 He joined DuPont at 19.
兩年後死在了手術台上 Died on the operating table two years later.
潰爛性結腸炎 Ulcerative colitis.
丹·席勒也是 Just like Dan Schiller had.
-丹是誰 -一個杜邦的化學家 - Who-who's Dan? - A chemist at DuPont.
我前夫的同事 Worked with my ex-husband.
羅傑 他姓什麼來著 And, uh, Roger, what's his name?
威爾金斯 那個工頭 Wilkins, the foreman.
史蒂文·蓋勒 Steven Gellar.
蘭迪·菲爾德 Randy Field.
蘭迪得的是腎癌 Randy's was kidney cancer.
-他活下來了 -是的 但是他妻子沒有 - He survived. - Yeah, his wife didn't.
不 朱恩是甲狀腺問題 No, June's was thyroid.
本來說是能治好的 And it was supposed to be treatable.
但是他們發現得晚了 They didn't catch it in time.
不過他們兒子的病發現得很及時 But th-they caught it in-in their son.
你們的孩子生下來是健康的嗎 Were your children born, uh, healthy?
-是的 都很健康 -那就好 - Yes. Yes, they were. - Good.
我們想要三胎 但是懷不了 But... we wanted a third and couldn't.
我去看醫生 I went to my doctor.
他說 "你得切除子宮 He says, "You need a hysterectomy.
立刻 馬上" You need it right away."
抱歉 I'm so sorry.
就是不走運吧 Bad luck, I guess.
我那時才三十六 I was 36.
基格先生 Mr. Kiger, you...
您能否給我一份那封信的複印件 you think I could get a copy of that letter?
你的手怎麼了 What's wrong with your hand?
沒事 好得很 Nothing. It's fine.
天啊 羅伯 Whoa. Rob?
羅伯 你在幹什麼 Rob, what are you doing?
給這些人下毒還嫌不夠 I mean, it's not enough to poison these people?
-他們還要欺騙這些人嗎 -冷靜 冷靜行嗎 - They got to swindle them, too? - Okay, calm down. All right?
信是杜邦公司寫的 DuPont wrote that letter,
-不是水務管理局 -你是怎麼知道的 - not the water authority. - How do you know that?
你以為我到現在都不知道杜邦公司的信長什麼樣嗎 You think I don't know what a DuPont letter looks like by now?
好吧 Okay. Okay.
天啊 I mean, Jesus!
這太邪惡了 薩拉 It-it-it's evil, Sarah.
太他媽邪惡了 It's-it's fucking evil.
"他馬"是什麼意思 What's "Fack"?
這下好了 Perfect.
沒什麼意思 親愛的 天啊 It's nothing, sweetie. It's nothing. Oh, boy.
對不起 I'm sorry.
-真對不起 親愛的 -請把奶瓶給查理好嗎 - I'm sorry, honey. - Can you give Charlie the bottle, please?
-奶瓶放哪兒了 -在包裡 這兒 - Where's his bottle? - It's in the bag. Here.
這些是什麼 What is all this?
都是外婆的 It's from Grammer's.
在她信箱裡找到的 Left in her mailbox.
"醫療津貼 即刻終身享有" "Medical claims, now and forever"?
人身損害 醫療津貼 即刻終身享有
-給 -"即刻終身享有" - Here, bud. - "Now and forever."
這是 Is that the... that...
醫療監控 Medical monitoring... is that...
我以為你說過通過不了的 I thought you said that wasn't gonna pass.
早上好 Morning.
大家早 Morning, guys.
喬·基格先生是首席原告 Our lead plaintiff is Mr. Joe Kiger.
合夥人同意的情況下 他也是潛在原告 Potential plaintiff, if the partnership approves.
喬·基格先生是體育老師 Mr. Joe Kiger, a Phys Ed teacher
來自西弗吉尼亞州的帕克斯堡 from Parkersburg, West Virginia,
代表七萬名當地居民 on behalf of the 70,000 local residents
過去40年 居民用水被杜邦公司蓄意污染 whose water DuPont knowingly poisoned for the last 40 years.
-集體訴訟 -讓他說完 - A class action? - Let him finish.
當地自來水公司告知基格一家 The Kigers were notified
杜邦公司在供水中發現了 by their local water company that DuPont had found
低濃度的C-8成分 small concentrations of C-8 in their water supply
但他們不必擔心 因為該濃度是安全的 but not to worry because those concentrations were safe.
為什麼 Why?
因為杜邦公司是這麼說的 Because DuPont said so.
十億分之一
這是杜邦公司所認為的安全濃度 This is what DuPont considers safe.
就像奧林匹克規格游泳池 That's something like one drop of water
裡面的一滴水 in an Olympic-size swimming pool.
換言之 即使有微量的C-8 水源也不安全 In other words, even a trace of C-8 renders water unsafe.
但杜邦公司告訴當地水務局 But DuPont told the local water authority,
"別怕 你們水中C-8濃度比安全濃度低" "Don't worry. Your wells have got even less than that."
-但那是個謊言 -謊言嗎 - Except that was a lie. - A lie?
是的 杜邦公司數十年來在秘密測試這些水源 Yes. DuPont has been secretly testing these wells for decades.
他們知道這些水源被他們污染了 They knew they had contaminated those wells
污染程度比該標準高六倍 up to six times that level.
多虧坦南特案 現在我們也知道這件事了 And thanks to the Tennant case, now we know, too.
慢著 這是不受監管的吧 Hold on. This stuff is unregulated, right?
我是說 在環境保護局看來 I mean, I mean, as far as EPA's concerned,
-這東西可能是無害的 -對 - it might as well be rose petals. - Yeah.
環境保護局沒有定標準 The EPA hasn't set a standard...
這話不錯 但杜邦公司定了 That's true... but DuPont did.
根據法律 打贏這樣的官司 And all the law requires to win a case like this
只要證明污染超過了 is to show that DuPont exceeded
杜邦公司設下的安全標準 what DuPont itself considers safe.
自我監管 Self-regulation.
如果你說的是對的 If what you're saying is right...
就是對的 It is right.
為什麼杜邦公司要告訴該供水區域這些呢 Then why would DuPont tell this water district anything at all?
在我看來他們挺遵紀守法啊 Seems to me that they're being a good corporate citizen here.
這是提起訴訟所需的時間 That's how long you have to file suit.
從你認識到飲用水 One year from the moment
被污染那一刻起算有一年 you realize your water's been contaminated.
這封信看起來 This letter looks like
是在告訴人們他們的水是安全的 it's telling people their water is safe.
而實際上 是在說並不安全 In fact, it's notifying them that it isn't.
-杜邦開始了提起訴訟倒計時 -真聰明 - DuPont has started the clock. - Smart.
我們也會建議這麼干 We would've counseled that.
信在11個月前發出 It was sent 11 months ago,
即他們意識到我們已經知道了的時刻 the moment they realized we knew.
30天後 他們就徹底安全了 In 30 days, they're home free.
這就是案件的概要 So that's the proposed case in brief.
但還有待商榷之處 But there's something else to consider.
是嗎 You think?
羅伯 Rob.
C-8有生物積累性 在我們體內累積 C-8 bioaccumulates. It builds up inside of us.
有的人即使今天沒生病 Some class members who aren't sick today
明天也會病倒 will get sick tomorrow.
我們要找到一個在未來也能保護他們的辦法 We need a way to protect them into the future.
天啊 湯姆 如果你在 Jesus, Tom, if you're even thinking about
-考慮用醫療監控 -慢著 慢著 - using medical monitoring... - Hold on. Hold on.
醫療監控
醫療監控是在西弗吉尼亞 Medical monitoring is a claim
允許使用的索賠手段 now permitted in West Virginia courts.
-行了 -聽他說完 - Oh, come on. - Let's hear him out.
據其規定 當一家公司讓一個社區 It says, if a company exposes a community
暴露在致病物質之中 to something that makes them sick,
該公司應無限期地監控社區的健康狀況 they must monitor the health of that community indefinitely.
大家懂了嗎 Everybody get that?
這是在製造暴露即擔責的責任 You're creating liability from mere exposure.
這是無前例的 It's also unprecedented.
對 這也正是不到6個月前 Exactly. Which is why, not six months ago,
我們竭力反對它的原因 -但你們沒反對成 - we fought tooth and nail against it. - And you lost.
我們的客戶有利用法律的權利 Our-our clients have the right to avail themselves of the law.
是潛在客戶 Potential clients.
好吧 Uh, okay. Um...
我瞭解你 羅伯 I-I-I know you, Rob.
我知道你充滿熱情 I-I-I know your passion.
你為農民們爭取到了很不錯的庭外和解 Uh, you... you got a great settlement for your farmer.
你該為之自豪 You should be proud of that.
我作為這裡最新的合夥人 Uh, and perhaps as the newest partner at this table,
應當更慎重一點 I should be more circumspect.
但他現在提出的 But, uh, what he's proposing here
無異於扳倒 is nothing less than a-a shakedown
-一家著名美國公司 -我們不為杜邦公司辯護 - of an iconic American company. - We do not represent DuPont.
是你不再為杜邦公司辯護 No, y-you don't represent anyone.
我們走到這一步了嗎 Is this what we have become?
當原告律師 事故賠償律師 Plaintiff's attorneys? Ambulance chasers?
你幹嘛不承認了呢 I mean, why don't you just admit it?
羅伯 你想翻身 Rob, you want to flip.
你想用你所知道的 You want to take everything that you know
關於化工企業運作的一切 about how chemical companies operate
來對付杜邦公司 像個告密者一樣 and turn it against DuPont, like an informant.
-夠了 -不是嗎 - That's enough. - Isn't that right?
-好了好了 -不是這樣嗎 - Okay. - Isn't that right?
-難道不是嗎 -是的 - Isn't that right? - Yes.
行 那我們 我們就投票 Okay, then I-I say we take a vote
來決定是否繼續踐行 and determine whether or not we continue
本讓我們律所首屈一指獨樹一幟 in the tradition that has distinguished this firm
的這項傳統... from everyone else in the industry or...
夠了 主持會議的是我 Okay, I'm running this meeting.
好嗎 聽懂了嗎 Okay? You got that?
有人看過他 Has anyone even read the evidence
收集的數據嗎 this man has collected?
故意疏忽 腐敗 The willful negligence, the corruption?
去看 Read it.
然後看還說不說得出口我們應該坐視不管 And then tell me we should be sitting on our asses.
所以美國人 That's the reason
才這麼討厭律師 why Americans hate lawyers.
曾催生汽車召回制度 五次參選美國總統
所以世界各地才冒出各種拉爾夫·納德這樣的人 This is the crap that fuels the Ralph Naders of the world.
我們應該主動去揭露杜邦 We should want to nail DuPont.
我們所有人都應該 All of us should.
美國商業不應只是如此啊 各位 American business is better than this, gentlemen.
如果他們自身做不到 And when it's not,
我們就得幫一把 we should hold them to it.
想在這個系統裡建立信念就得這樣 That's how you build faith in the system.
我們總是在爭論 說公司就是人 We're always arguing that companies are people.
而現在 這些人 Well, these people...
已經越線了 have crossed the line!
去他們媽的 To hell with them!
你們這種專做企業辯護的人 It may come as a surprise
可能會對此感到驚訝 to corporate defense types like yourselves,
但法律不僅僅只是 but there's more to the law
用白紙黑字狀告對方 than just flooding the other side in papers.
以我的立場來說 你必須打動別人 From where I sit, you have to touch people.
這些姑娘們負責接聽處理 You know, these girls, they handle the calls
集體訴訟成員的電話 from the class action members.
而各種案子裡都涉及上千數的人需要聯絡 And there's thousands of 'em on any given case.
正是在這裡我們瞭解他們的痛苦 And it's here that we come to know their pain.
不是嗎 海茲爾 Isn't that right, Hazel?
是啊 Yes.
我們每天都能聽到 We hear it every day,
而我的工作就是讓陪審團也感受到這份痛苦 and it's my job to make a jury feel that pain,
不是出於憐憫 而是出於恐懼 not out of pity, but out of fear.
不論我的客戶遭遇了什麼 Whatever it is that happened to my client,
都要讓陪審員覺得 that juror has to think,
"那可能也會發生在我身上" "That could happen to me."
你只要不停強調這一點 You just keep hammering it.
十億分之一 十億分之一的含量 One part per billion, one part per billion.
這是他們自己的文件 自己的科學家 It's their own documents, their own scientists.
-當然了 -好嗎 他們... - Absolutely. - All right? They-they...
他們自己制定的標準 就必須得遵守 They set that standard. They have to live with it.
我覺得我們可以放鬆一點 羅伯 Yeah, I think we can relax, Rob, though.
他們駁回起訴 You know, there's no way
的動議是不可能通過的 they're gonna prevail with a motion to dismiss.
這只是走程序 This is procedural.
別擔心 我們今天會得到審判的機會的 It's nonsense. We'll get a trial today.
好 我待會兒去找你們 Okay, I'll catch you guys in there.
我喝點水 I'm gonna get a drink.
我可不會喝那個 I wouldn't drink that.
厄爾 Earl.
你最近如何 How you doing?
還沒死 Still here.
已經不錯了 對吧 That's something, right?
對 很了不起 Yes, that-that's something.
見到你真好 羅伯 It's good to see you, Rob.
千萬別 Can't let 'em...
被他們打倒 shut you down.
我不會的 跟你保證 Oh, I-I won't. I-I promise.
全世界 Whole world...
都得知道真相 needs to know.
會的 厄爾 They will, Earl.
會知道的 They will.
嘿 羅伯 Hey, Rob.
開始了 It's time.
我 我得走了 I-I have to go.
我們在此是為了決定是否通過此項動議 We are here on defendant's motion
-來駁回由基格先生提出的訴訟 -喬 你好 - to dismiss the case Brought by Mr. Kiger, et al. - Hey, Joe. How are you?
那麼 Now...
在座哪位是華萊士先生 which one of you is Mr. Wallace?
法官閣下 我是愛德華·華萊士 Edward Wallace, Your Honor,
代表E.I.杜邦德內穆爾公司 on behalf of E.I. Du Pont de Nemours and Company,
也就是杜邦公司 better known as DuPont.
好的 我聽過 Yes, I've heard of it.
-提出你的動議 -謝謝法官 - Your motion. - Thank you.
法官閣下 我們今天在此 Your Honor, we're here today
都是因為一款美國的特殊發明 特氟龍 because of a uniquely American invention: Teflon.
自1961年起 特氟龍解放了家庭主婦... Since 1961, Teflon has liberated housewives...
-停停停 -抱歉 - No, no, no, no, no, no. - Oh, uh, excuse me.
操持家務的人... Homemakers throughout...
這兒是法庭 華萊士先生 This is a courtroom, Mr. Wallace,
不是家庭購物網站 not the Home Shopping Network.
原告宣稱 杜邦在 Plaintiffs have alleged that DuPont did not meet
-給當地的供水中 -她很厲害啊 - its own standard of safety... - She's good, huh? She's good.
C-8含量未達到 with regard to the level of C-8
-自定的安全標準 -是的 - in the local water supply. - Okay.
但這根本無關緊要 法官閣下 That's irrelevant, Your Honor.
我們請求駁回訴訟的理由是 We ask you to dismiss on grounds
唯一重要的標準 that the only standard that matters
是民選政府認為安全的標準 is the one that elected government deems safe.
-除了不受監管的物質 -作出這類決定 - Not if it's unregulated. - It's government's job
是政府的職責 而不是任何一家公司的 to make these determinations, not any one company.
-這是個陷阱 -他們不會重提... - That's a trap. - They can't revert back to...
我知道 I got it.
有什麼問題嗎 戴茲勒先生 Is there a problem, Mr. Deitzler?
抱歉 法官閣下 但杜邦已經 Apologies, Your Honor, but DuPont has been hiding
向政府隱瞞這種化學物質的危害 the dangers of this chemical
有一段時間了 from the government for a while now.
他們希望能通過您的判決來逃避責任 And they're asking you to let 'em off the hook
因為他們早已用這種策略成功過 because they've succeeded in their strategy.
政府根本不管制C-8 Government doesn't regulate C-8.
不 其實不是 Uh, actually, that's not true.
-是嗎 -是的 - Oh? - No, no.
西弗吉尼亞州的C-8調查小組 The West Virginia's C-8 Working Group
剛公佈了標準 has just issued a standard.
今天與我們同坐的就是為此做出貢獻 Here with us today is the governmental official
那些政府官員 who led that effort,
瑪麗·蘇·金伯爾博士 Dr. Mary-Sue Kimball.
金伯爾博士作為高級官員 And, Dr. Kimball, uh, as a senior member
保護西弗吉尼亞州的公民 of the state's Department of Environmental Protection,
難道不是你們美國國家環境保護局 isn't it, in fact, your duty to protect
-的職責所在嗎 -華萊士先生 - the citizens of West Virginia... - Mr. Wallace.
我不說廢話了 I'll cut to the chase.
西弗吉尼亞州認定 What is the level of C-8 in drinking water
C-8在水中的 that the state of West Virginia
安全含量標準是多少 has determined to be completely safe?
看著他從十億分之一漲到 Watch it go from one part per billion to...
-十億分之五 -十億分之十 - Five? - Ten?
十億分之150 150 parts per billion.
-歡迎來到西弗吉尼亞 -這個官司所包含的 - Welcome to West Virginia. - The levels found in the wells
六個水區的井中的含量 of all six water districts represented in this suit,
他們是不是低於最高限制 do they fall below this maximum level?
遠遠低於 Well below.
法官 沒有別的問題了 Nothing else, Your Honor.
證人發言 戴茲勒先生 Your witness, Mr. Deitzler.
這個工作組裡都有哪些人 Wait, who-who's on the working group?
杜邦公司肯定在 還有哪些 DuPont, of course, and who else?
-誰做的水質測驗 -戴茲勒先生 - Who did the water testing? - Mr. Deitzler?
-你們什麼時候能發言 -馬上 法官 - When was it done? -One moment, Judge.
樣本量有多大 What was the sample size?
是啊 我們應該能夠... Yeah, I mean, we should be able to see...
第一次提醒 Going once.
第二次提醒 Going twice.
你所謂的"C-8工作組"這個陰謀集團裡 Dr. Kimball, who were the members of this cabal
-都有哪些人 金伯爾博士 -提出異議 - you call the C-8 Working Group? - Objection.
冷靜點 戴茲勒先生 Cool it, Mr. Deitzler.
你可以回答了 金伯爾博士 Go ahead, Dr. Kimball.
機構的工作人員 Agency officials,
科學圈子裡的代表 representatives of the scientific community,
利益相關者 um, stakeholders.
利益相關者 哪些利益相關者 Stakeholders? Which stakeholders?
等等 讓我猜猜看 Oh, wait, let me guess...
和"圖龐"相近 It rhymes with "Bouffant."
杜邦公司是利益相關者 沒錯 DuPont is a stakeholder, yes.
我懂了 所以 你不覺得奇怪嗎 So, I see. So, don't you find it peculiar
在一個集體訴訟案的前夜 that on the eve of a class action lawsuit
並且本案中杜邦公司有可能 where DuPont might be considered liable
因毒害社區而承擔法律責任 for poisoning this community,
而他們突然把你找到這裡 they get you to come in here suddenly
推翻他們數十年以來都稱作"先進"的科學 and reverse decades of their so-called heralded science?
你的陳述有誤 That's false.
我不為杜邦公司工作 I don't work for DuPont.
我沒說你為杜邦公司工作 I didn't say you did.
但是既然你說起了這事 But now you bring it up,
我們一個月之後我再來看一看 we'll check back in a month.
-法官 不 -你真的準備 - Your Honor... No. - Were you honestly gonna
告訴這些社區居民 plan on telling this community
他們能喝下超150倍的C-8嗎 that they can drink 150 times more C-8?
來啊 朋友們 乾杯吧 I mean, come on, people, bottoms up.
-這種事情嗎 -法官 說真的 這不 - That kind of thing? - Honestly, Judge, this is not...
好了 戴茲勒先生 夠了 All right, Mr. Deitzler, enough.
我們將會在接下來的公開聽證會上 We'll be unveiling the new standard
揭幕我們的新標準 at an upcoming public hearing.
"揭幕" 哇 聽起來像是要開派對了 "Unveiling." Whoa, that sounds like a party.
我們會來的 We'll be there!
清潔水源
他們的安全標準 Their safety standards thing,
全是假的 that's all a sham.
多虧了法官的決定 Thanks to the judge's decision,
我們能在法庭上聲張正義 we will have our day in court.
是的 我們會的 Yes, we will!
因為 如果西弗吉尼亞州 Because, if the state of West Virginia
不制止杜邦公司 won't stop the DuPont corporation
毒害市民的行為 from literally poisoning its citizens,
那麼我們這些市民就應自己來制止他們 then we the citizens will stop them ourselves.
晚上好 歡迎收看20/20 Good evening, and welcome to 20/20.
ABC的一檔調查類節目
它覆蓋在你烹飪鍋的表面 Well, it coats the pots you cook with
這樣食物不會粘在上面 so the food doesn't stick,
它保護著你們家嬰兒會爬的地毯 it protects the carpet your baby crawls on...
我想念地毯 I miss carpet.
以及羽絨服 你的潤膚液 甚至你的化妝品 Winter jacket, your skin lotion, even your makeup.
它就是特氟龍 We're talking about Teflon.
今晚 我們20/20節目的調查將揭露 And tonight, our 20/20 investigation uncovers
這種常用材料令人擔憂的信息 alarming information about this much-used material.
非常令人擔憂 芭芭拉 It is very alarming, Barbara.
我用特氟龍做飯 I cook with Teflon.
我之前都不知道 直到我看到 I didn't know until I watched this report
這個你也將看到的報告 that you're about to see
如果特氟龍足夠熱... that if Teflon gets hot enough...
數百萬人家裡都有特氟龍 millions of people have in their homes.
暗藏危機
特氟龍變成了一個... Teflon has become such a familiar...
特氟龍之鎮
特氟龍 一種被用來做衣服 汽車 Teflon, a substance that is also used in clothing and cars,
甚至是隱形眼鏡的東西 even in contact lenses.
被發現已經在大部分美國人的血液中了 Already found in the blood of most Americans.
現在科學家在說... Now scientists are saying...
PFOA...
全澳大利亞百萬人的家中 millions of homes across Australia.
健康危機
特氟龍 用來做不粘鍋的表面 Teflon, a nonstick surface...
美國國家環境保護局今早 The Environmental Protection Agency this morning
宣佈他們開啟了對於化學物C-8的 announced it has opened a priority review
重大調查 of the chemical C-8,
也是現在一樁對於化學巨頭杜邦公司 currently the subject of a class action lawsuit
訴訟的內容 against the chemical giant DuPont.
喬 Joe!
我的天 喬 等一等 Oh, my Lord, Joe, just wait!
親愛的 求你了 等消防員來吧 Wait for the fire department, please, honey!
求你不要頭腦發熱 Please don't go crazy!
在中國的消費者中引起了巨大的恐慌 have triggered a mass panic among Chinese consumers.
你應該扔掉不粘鍋嗎 Should you throw away your nonstick pans?
-你的鍋是否會毒害你 -許多專家說 - Are your pans making you sick? - Many experts say...
這是問題所在... That's the question being asked...
對於含有特氟龍的產品 Returns of kitchen implements
提出退貨 coated in Teflon.
這棟房子是空的 是我爸爸的 The house was empty. It belongs to my father.
我不明白這怎麼可能燒起來 I don't know how it could've started.
他叫基格嗎 His name Kiger?
可能有人弄錯了房子 Think someone might have got the wrong house?
這些爭吵是愚蠢的 All of this hullabaloo is just silly.
威爾明頓州 特拉華
用特氟龍來做飯是完全安全的 Teflon is completely safe for cooking.
這就是我們贊助"健康做飯"活動的原因 That is why we founded the Cook Healthy campaign
來糾正大家的誤區 to set the record straight.
活動抵擋"特氟龍瘋狂"
除了完全安全之外 它也... And besides being completely safe, it is also...
明白了 Copy that.
走到底 All the way down.
我們現在正在錄像 We are now on the record.
這是小查爾斯·歐·霍利迪的 This is the videotaped deposition
證詞錄像 of Charles O. Holliday, Jr.,
由杜邦公司訴訟中的 taken by the plaintiffs in the matter of Kiger et al.
原告方 基格等人拍攝 Versus E.I. Du Pont de Nemours and Company.
舉起你的右手 Raise your right hand.
你發誓說出所有實情 Do you swear to tell the whole truth
並保證只說實話嗎 and nothing but the truth?
我發誓 I do.
請說出你的名字 Please state your name.
小查爾斯·歐·霍利迪 Charles O. Holliday, Jr.
你現在有任職嗎 And are you presently employed?
有 Yes.
你的職位是 What is your position?
我是杜邦公司的董事長 I'm the chairman and chief executive officer
兼首席執行官 of the DuPont Company.
在杜邦公司最近向 In DuPont's most recent filing
美國證券交易委員會提出的文件中 with the Securities and Exchange Commission,
你陳述引用了 you state, quote,
"基於50多年的行業經驗 "Based on over 50 years of industry experience
和大量的科學研究 And extensive scientific study,
杜邦公司相信沒有證據表明 DuPont believes there is no evidence
PFOA會對人體產生不良影響 That PFOA causes any adverse human health effects
或是危害環境" or harms the environment."
你簽了那個法律文件 對嗎 You signed that legal filing, correct?
我不記得確切的措辭 I don't recall the exact statement,
但聽上去的確是我說的 but that sounds right to me.
你知道杜邦公司 在自己的文檔中 Are you aware that DuPont has, in its own files,
所記載的上世紀70年代的研究數據 studies dating back to the 1970s
與你所說背道而馳 that say just the opposite?
PFOA 或是所謂的C-8 That PFOA... Or C-8, as it's called...
對人體健康有著潛在的 Has potentially life-threatening effects
致命影響 on human health?
我對那些研究並不熟悉 I'm not familiar with the exact studies
也許是在我們的文檔裡 we may have in our files.
那我就帶你看一遍 Then I'll take you through them.
證據九 Exhibit nine.
剛遞給你的是證據九 Y-you were just handed exhibit nine.
你看到日期1979年3月13日了 You see the date March 13, 1979?
看到了 Yes.
-你看到最上面的杜邦標誌了 -看到了 - You see the DuPont logo at the top? - Yes.
-你看到劃重點的這個詞了嗎 -看到了 - Do you see this word here highlighted? - Yes.
受體
可以請你給我念一下嗎 Would you read it for me, please?
"受體" "Receptors."
你知道"受體"指的什麼嗎 Do you know what that word refers to... "Receptors"?
在這段文字裡 我不知道 In this context, I do not.
它意味著人類 It means human beings.
杜邦公司將公司內接觸了 DuPont refers to the men and women
C-8的男人和女人稱為"受體" that your company exposed to C-8 as "Receptors."
在這些受體中 你們的科學家發現 引用 And in these receptors, your scientists found, quote,
"變應性內分泌以及代謝紊亂事件 "Significantly higher incidents of allergic endocrine
明顯上升" 結束引用 and metabolic disorders," End quote.
以及 引用 As well as, quote,
"患肝病的風險極大" "Excess risk of developing liver disease."
-你看到了嗎 -看到了 - Do you see that? - Yes.
此外 特氟龍會導致不孕 Moreover, you have infertility at Teflon.
白血病的發生 Occurrences of leukemia.
多種癌症 You have excess of cancers.
包括膀胱 腎 口腔 咽喉部位的癌症 Bladder, kidney, oral, pharynx.
下一段 Next paragraph.
78 Seventy-eight.
你看到標題了 You see that heading?
你看到日期了 你看到了嗎 You see that date? Do you see that?
證據96 證據53 Exhibit 96. Exhibit 53.
我想先談談先天缺陷 I'd like to move on to birth defects.
-已經快七個小時了 -霍利迪先生 - We've gone almost seven hours. - Mr. Holliday,
你知道 在1981年 you're aware that, in 1981,
3M公司向杜邦公司通報他們對老鼠進行了研究 3M notified DuPont that it had conducted studies on rats
這些研究表明持續接觸C-8 and these studies showed that sustained C-8 exposure
會導致面部畸形 can cause facial deformities?
我不知道3M公司的研究 I'm not aware of a study by 3M.
那杜邦公司自己的研究呢 How about DuPont's own studies
那些表示對人類有同樣影響的研究 that showed the same thing in humans?
那是杜邦公司1981年針對懷孕的研究 That's DuPont's pregnancy study from 1981.
-看上去是杜邦公司的文檔嗎 -看起來是的 - Does that look like a DuPont document to you? - It looks to be.
你知道杜邦公司否認 Are you aware that DuPont has denied
曾有過任何類似的研究 that any such study ever even took place?
我並不熟悉 I'm not familiar with specific statements
對此的具體陳述 we've made about that.
七個孕婦 Seven pregnant women,
都是杜邦公司的員工 都在特氟龍生產線上工作 all DuPont employees, all from the Teflon line.
你看到這裡嗎 Do you see this here?
引用 "孩子 四個月大 Quote, "Child, four months,
一個鼻孔 眼睛有缺陷" 結束引用 one nostril, eye defect," End quote.
看到了 Yes.
七箇中的兩個 Two of the seven women,
近乎三分之一孩子 nearly 30%, gave birth to babies
都有一樣的面部畸形 that had the exact facial deformities
-你的公司早就知道 -到此為止 - that your company already knew about. - We're done here.
先生 Sir.
他的父母給他取名為巴奇 His parents named him Bucky.
巴奇·貝利 Bucky Bailey.
這就是你們的受體 This is your receptor.
現在我們結束了 Now we're done.
美國國家環境保護局 The Environmental Protection Agency
對化學巨頭杜邦公司徵收了 has levied the largest fine in agency history
有史以來最大一筆罰款 against the chemical giant DuPont.
環境保護局斷定 The EPA concluded
杜邦公司未能通報用於製造特氟龍的 the company failed to report the health dangers of C-8
C-8的健康危害 used in the manufacture of Teflon.
杜邦公司將向環境保護局支付1650萬美元 DuPont will pay the EPA $16.5 million.
其每年從特氟龍中獲得十億元的利潤 It earns a billion dollars in profits from Teflon each year.
杜邦公司
調解中 請安靜
回顧一下 我們已經同意 To recap, we've agreed that DuPont
杜邦公司將會清理本地供水設施 will clean local water supplies,
在所有六個區域安裝滲透系統 install infiltration systems in all six water districts.
此外 Additionally,
杜邦公司將賠付7000萬美元現金給受影響群體 DuPont will pay $70 million in cash to the class.
這是特氟龍生產線三天的收入 Three days' revenue on the Teflon line.
還剩下 Which leaves
我們最具挑戰的問題 醫療檢測 our most challenging issue: medical monitoring.
我們同意成立一個由三位科學家組成的 We've agreed to establish an independent science panel
獨立科學小組 comprised of three scientists
這些科學家與任何一方都沒有關係 who have no relationship to either side.
這個獨立小組將研究這些群體的成員 This independent panel will study the members of this class
來確定C-8的暴露 to determine whether C-8 exposure
是否會致使該地區的病情加重 has led to increased incidents of disease in this region.
如果小組發現針對一種特定的疾病 If the panel finds that there are probable scientific links
有若干可能的科學聯繫 to a particular disease,
那該群體中每個人的健康狀況都要受到監測 the health of everyone in the class will be monitored
杜邦公司會為該疾病患者們 for that disease in perpetuity
賠付兩億三千五百萬美元 at DuPont's cost up to $235 million.
而且任何的群體成員 只要是患上了那種病 And any class member who develops that disease
都可以找杜邦公司索賠 can sue DuPont for damages.
但是 如果科學小組 However, if the science panel
沒能建立起可能的科學聯繫 fails to establish probable scientific links,
那這就結案了 then this case is over.
沒有監控 沒有訴訟 沒有例外 No monitoring, no lawsuits, no exceptions.
很好 Good.
先生們 現在你們正式 Well, gentlemen, you are now officially
被科學掌握在手中了 in the hands of science.
我當然不覺得你會喜歡喝邁泰酒 Wouldn't have pegged you as a mai tai guy.
那是節日飲料 It's festive.
我也不覺得你會喜歡 Wouldn't have pegged you for that, either.
我們可以來慶祝一下吧 We have something to celebrate.
-是嗎 -慶祝嗎 - Yeah? - Do we?
你看 我們怎麼會知道科學小組將要證明 Look, how do we know that the panel is going to prove
是杜邦公司讓這些人生病了 that DuPont made all these people sick?
我不是科學家 但即便是我也知道 I'm no scientist, but even I know you'd need
你需要大量的醫療數據 huge amounts of medical data,
更別提那成百上千的血液樣本了 not to mention thousands of blood samples and...
那些不信任我們的人 From people who don't trust us.
"大伙們 我們想在你們身上用針扎一下 "Hey, folks, we want to stick you with some needles.
你們不會介意的 對吧" You won't mind, will you?"
我是說 我清楚這些人 I mean, I know these people.
他們只會拿錢走人 They're gonna take the money and run.
不是嗎 Wouldn't you?
我覺得他們 他們不止想要錢 I think they-they want more than just the money.
我覺得他們 I-I-I-I think they...
他們想知道自己會不會生病 they want to know if they're gonna get sick or not.
或是說 如果他們血液裡含有C-8 Or if they have C-8 in their blood
這會對他們和他們的家庭帶來什麼 and what that's gonna do t-to them and their families.
所以 So,
我們就只能相信他們會出現 是吧 we're just gonna trust that they show up, huh?
相信 但還要核實 Trust and... but verify.
那是什麼意思 羅伯 What does that mean, Rob?
就是要檢測 Well, come in for an exam.
給我們一份血液樣本 Give us a blood sample.
然後我們會給你支票 Then we'll give you your check.
轉念一想 給我來一杯邁泰吧 On second thought, make mine a mai tai.
每人一杯 謝謝 All around, please.
-羅伯·畢洛 -是啊 - Rob Bilott. - Yeah.
你哪來的點子 Where'd you pull that out of?
健康的飲用水對我們來說至關重要 Healthy drinking water is vital to all of us.
這也是為什麼科學家們需要弄清楚 That's why scientists need to know
C-8化學物會導致什麼健康問題 if the chemical C-8 causes any health problems.
今日起 你們可以通過 Starting today, you can help by completing
完成一份健康問卷調查來幫助他們 a health questionnaire and having...
不是吧 Ah, come on!
市區醫療車 medical van downtown.
你還好嗎 Well, how about you?
你要去弄血檢嗎 Are you gonna get your blood tested?
不 我討厭針頭 Nah. I-I hate needles.
測一次四百塊呢 兄弟 It's 400 bucks, buddy.
真的嗎 Really?
注意... Got your attention...
C-8血檢處
好 好的 Okay, okay!
好的 好 All right, all right.
是的 會有效的 Yeah, that'll work.
我們把他們帶來這裡 We bring them back here,
抽血然後給他們一張支票 draw the blood and hand them a check.
-400美元 -每個 - $400. - Each.
這兒都是錢啊 Lots of money around here.
今天你帶了多少人來 盧安小姐 How many you brought with you today, Miss LuAnn?
我老公和我的三個孩子還有我 My husband and my three kids and me.
-2000美元 -是啊 - $2,000. - Yeah.
在聖誕之前不會太寒酸 Not too shabby right before Christmas.
是的 Yep.
但你什麼也不會查出來 But you ain't gonna find nothing.
杜邦公司是群好人 DuPont's good people.
等著瞧 You'll see.
琪琪 琪琪 琪琪 Gigi, Gigi, Gigi!
現在該你把這個天使放在上面了 It's your turn to put the angel on the top.
寶貝 你來放吧 You do it, sweetie.
-琪琪已經玩累了 -快看我 - Gigi's too pooped. - Look at me!
-為什麼不讓你本叔叔幫你一把呢 -看 - Why don't you get your Uncle Ben to give you a boost? - Look!
媽 Mom?
-怎麼啦 -你還好嗎 - What's up? - You okay?
-還好 -你能放 你能幫我... - Yeah. - Can you put... Can you help...
說真的 真的很大 Seriously, it's huge.
他們今年打算讓你做合夥人 They're gonna be making you partner this year.
-我知道 -他們最好這麼做 - I know it. - Well, they'd better.
我的意思是 I mean...
媽咪 快來看看 Mommy, come see this!
寶貝兒 你把那個裝飾品掛起來了嗎 Hey, baby, did you hang that ornament?
羅伯 可以去接一下電話嗎 Rob, can you get that?
-讓我看看 -好 我去接 - Let me see. - Okay, I'm-I'm coming.
喂 Hello?
羅伯 你準備好了嗎 Rob, you sitting down for this?
-拉裡 怎麼啦 -69000 - Larry, what's wrong? - 69,000.
什麼69000 69,000 what?
69000個人參加了測試 69000 69,000 people got tested. 69,000!
你知道這是多大一個數據嗎 You realize how much data this is?
這就是我們需要的 羅伯 就這了 This is what we needed, Rob. This is it.
-天哪 -朋友你還好嗎 - Oh, my God. - You were right all along, my friend.
-聖誕節快樂 -多謝 - Merry Christmas. - Thank you.
-那還用說 -謝謝 - You bet. -Thank you!
待會再聊 Talk real soon.
-剛剛那是誰呢 -你不會相信的 - Hey, who was that? - You won't believe.
-爸比 猜猜我剛剛做什麼了 -嗯哼 - Daddy, guess what I just did. - Yeah?
-你做了啥 -我把那個小天使放在最上面了 - What? What'd you just do? - I put the angel on the top.
-是嗎 -本叔叔把我舉起來的 - Yeah? - Uncle Ben lifted me.
就像這樣子噢 He did? Like this?
祝大家聖誕節快樂 Merry Christmas, everyone!
聖誕節快樂 Merry Christmas!
自坦南特案以來 11年
今天我們聚集在此 We are gathered here today
以紀念威爾伯·厄爾·坦南特 in memory of Wilbur Earl Tennant.
主乃吾領路人 我自不缺乏 The Lord is my shepherd; I shall not want.
主令我躺在綠色草地 He makes me lie down in green pastures.
他帶我走過死水 He leads me beside still waters.
他重塑了我的靈魂 He restoreth my soul.
哪怕我經過死亡陰影籠罩的峽谷 Even though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death,
也無懼邪惡 I will fear no evil...
大家快點 要芥末還是番茄醬 Quick, everybody. Mustard or ketchup?
泰迪 我說了多少遍了 這是我的番茄醬 Teddy, for the tenth time, that's my ketchup.
查理 別又開始了 Charlie, don't start.
什麼 這是我的 我拿來的 What? It's mine. I got it.
-他有他自己的番茄醬 -你是那個律師 - He's got his own, okay? - You're that lawyer.
吃完 Finish up.
我哥哥是戴爾·蘭普 My brother's Dale Lamb.
你拿了他的血樣 你說過你會幫他 You took his blood, said you'd help him.
是的 我說過 我們正在 Yeah, I did. We're-we're-we're...
我們正在做這件事 我保證 we're working on that. I promise.
他已經去世了 He's dead.
睪丸癌 Testicular cancer.
留下了三個比你的孩子還小的男孩 Left three little boys younger than yours.
可你卻在和你的家庭歡度時光 But you enjoy your family.
-好吧 都起來 -我還沒吃完呢 - Okay. Everybody up. - I'm not finished.
我說了起來 I said up.
達琳甚至出個門 Well, Darlene can't even leave the house
都要被人騷擾 without being harassed.
我知道 喬 我 I-I know, Joe. I'm...
一開始 他們責怪我們起訴杜邦 First, they-they blame us for suing DuPont,
現在他們恨我們 and now they hate on us
因為他們沒有看到任何進展 'cause they ain't seen nothing from it.
-我很抱歉 喬 -不 這還不夠 - I'm sorry, Joe. - Well, that ain't good enough!
他們想知道到底為什麼他媽的 花了四年時間 And they wonder why in the hell it takes four damn years
來檢測血樣 這我不怪他們 to read a lousy blood sample, and I don't blame 'em.
我們相信你 羅伯 We trusted you, Rob.
我們信任你 We put our faith in you.
-我知道 喬 我十分抱歉 -好麼 - I know, Joe. I'm-I'm so... - All right?
我十分抱歉 I'm so...
難道沒有什麼 Isn't there just... just some kind of a...
進度報告嗎 a progress report, anything that I can...
任何我可以和那些人分享的東西 I can share with these folks?
我的意思是 他們 他們已經等了 I mean, they-they... they have been waiting.
我很抱歉 畢洛先生 I'm sorry, Mr. Bilott.
專家組還在從上千份的 The panel is still in the process
樣本和病歷中 of analyzing complex data and modeling
分析複雜數據和模型 from thousands of samples and medical histories.
我十分抱歉 I'm so sorry.
你可以等一下麼 Could you hold a moment?
查理 別挑食 Charlie, don't pick at your food.
什麼是妓女 What's a hooker?
你從哪學來的這個 Where did you learn that?
他告訴我抹大拉的瑪利亞是個妓女 He told me that Mary Magdalene was a hooker.
什麼 她曾經是的 What? She was.
你應該說"賣淫女" You're supposed to say "Prostitute."
然後她找到了上帝 And then she found God
成為了耶穌最為虔誠的信徒之一 and became one of Jesus's most fervent disciples.
看到了麼 我剛教了他《聖經》 See? I was just teaching him the Bible.
我今天不想發脾氣 I-I can't today.
所有人起立 So, everybody up.
所有人起立 Everybody up.
我們還能付得起嗎 Can we still afford it?
什麼 What?
天主教學校 Catholic school.
我哥哥又進戒毒所了 你知道麼 My brother's back in rehab. Did you know that?
-不知道 我很抱歉 -今天是 - No. I'm sorry. - Today's...
今天是媽媽化療的第一天 Today's Mom's first day at chemo.
我忘了 I forgot.
因為這和你的案子沒有關係 羅伯 'Cause it's not about your case, Rob.
看著車 Car!
-天啊 -天啊 - Gosh. - Okay. Geez.
泰迪偽造了我的簽字 托尼放棄了踢足球 Teddy forged my signature, and Tony's quitting football.
托尼嗎 你怎麼知道這些的 Tony. But how would you know about that, right?
因為你只看到了 你只看到了 Because all you see, all that you-you...
孩子們從來都只看到你沉迷於案件 the boys have ever seen is you obsessing about this...
我抱怨過麼 Have I ever complained?
說句話 求你了 羅伯 Say something, for God's sakes, Rob.
不 No.
-不 -不 - No? - No.
不 No.
因為我知道你需要點什麼 Because I knew that you needed something.
一些連結 一些東西 Uh, some connection, s-something.
所以我接受 And s... so I took it on.
但如果你想要開始計算 But if you want to start accounting,
如果你要以"哦 我們能否承擔"開頭 那麼 if you want to start with-with, "Oh, can we afford," Then...
我不知道 羅伯 I don't know, Rob.
孩子們能否有個稱職的父親 Can the boys afford a father
是誰不能把這兩個詞連在一起 who can't string two words together?
我們的婚姻能否經得住13年 Can our marriage afford 13 years of...
13年這樣的生活 13 years of this?
你覺得呢 羅伯 你想談談嗎 How about it, Rob? You want to talk about it?
談談我們的生活 About our lives?
當然不想 Of course not.
我會跟媽媽說你關心過她的病了 I'll tell Mom you asked about her.
專家組到底在做什麼 What in God's name is that panel doing?
我們為什麼還有賬單要付 And wh-why are we still getting bills?
經費的 呃 當地律師 Overhead, uh... local counsel.
哈利已經給中心打過電話 H-Harry's call center.
一小時收費一千美元 A thousand dollars an hour.
這是 這是個技術專家 That-that was a... that was a technical expert.
我們需要在杜邦開始遊說華盛頓 We needed to do fi-filings
保留C-8之前做好備案 when DuPont started lobbying Washington to keep C-8...
這是華盛頓的問題 不是你的 That's Washington's problem, not ours.
所以你才把他們牽扯進來 你的備忘錄 That's why you got them involved. Your memo.
那只是筆罰款 湯姆 只是筆罰款 It was just a fine, Tom. It's a fine.
1600萬美元 這是 $16 million, it's...
這對於那些人而言微不足道 it's nothing for these people.
-這只是他們的零花錢 -是的 可是如果 - It's pocket change. - Yes, but if they get charged
他們被判處故意隱瞞罪 那他們就完了 with criminal concealment, game over.
你說司法部正在調查 You said DOJ was investigating.
-他們不再調查了 -什麼 - Not anymore. - What?
他們終止了調查 They dropped the investigation.
-他們終止 什麼 -是的 他們終止了 - They dropped... What? - They dropped it.
他們沒有給出理由 No reason given.
湯姆 我們的政府被杜邦控制了 Tom, our-our government is captive to DuPont.
這個案子是我們唯一的希望 This case, it's the only hope we have.
他們也知道是這樣 They know that, and they're trying to make it
所以他們盡可能地抬高價格逼你阻止我 as expensive as they can to force you to make me stop.
-告訴我還要多久 -呃 - Just tell me how much longer. - Uh...
我 我不能 I-I-I ca... I can't.
我 我希望我可以 I-I-I-I wish I could.
-湯姆 我... -你還好嗎 - Tom, I... - Are you okay?
我還好 我只是... Uh, I'm fine. I'm just...
羅伯 我現在已經是執權董事 Rob, I'm a managing partner now.
所以 湯姆 我覺得這也會 And, Tom, I think there could be
帶來一筆賠償 a huge payout here
-如果我們可以... -你覺得我是為了錢嗎 - if we can... - You think I'm in this for money?
-不 我... -你認為我... - No, I... - You think I am...
讓你把我們律所搞得 I'm-I'm letting you drag
名聲俱損 this firm's reputation through a meat grinder
就是為了讓原告得到賠償 for some kind of plaintiff's payoff?
我 我不知道你這麼做是為了什麼 I-I don't know why you're doing... doing it.
羅伯 聽著 我... Rob, listen, I...
我很抱歉 但是你得再降一次薪 I'm sorry, but you're gonna have to take another pay cut.
湯姆 這是我第四次降薪了 Tom, that's-that's my fourth pay cut.
-我現在該幹什麼 -我 我... - What am I supposed to do? - I-I-I...
-你沒有任何 -我只有原來薪水的三分之一了 - You-you don't have any... - I'm-I'm down to a third now.
你沒有任何客戶 你 你... You don't have any clients. You-you...
沒人願意接你的電話 No one will take your calls.
我該怎麼辦 What am I supposed to do here?
現在我站在你這邊 但... Now, I'm on your side, but...
羅伯 艾米 Rob? Emmy!
艾米 Hey! Emmy!
-凱思琳 -叫人來幫忙 - Kathleen! - Get some help!
羅伯 Rob?
看起來我們應該 Looks like we should, uh,
取消四點我和傑瑞的... cancel my 4:00 with Jerry and...
我不知道 我們在等結果 I don't know. We're waiting.
但是 給我們... But, uh, give us, uh...
嗯... Well, uh, uh...
記得告訴傑瑞 Make-make sure that, uh, Jerry knows that, um...
我 我要掛了 I-I have to go.
-畢洛夫人 -我是 - Mrs. Bilott? - Yes.
我們認為你的丈夫可能經歷了TIA We think your husband's most likely experienced a TIA,
短暫性腦缺血發作 a transient ischemic attack.
大腦供血暫時受阻 Blood is briefly cut off to the brain,
症狀和中風類似 mimicking the symptoms of a stroke.
額 不好意思 是TIA嗎 Uh, uh, excuse me. A TIA?
並不是短暫性的 This wasn't short.
是持續性的 It-it kept going on.
有毒物質呢 What about poison?
你說什麼 I'm sorry?
有沒有可能被人給他下毒 Could someone be... be poisoning him?
不 畢洛夫人 這是神經性的 No, Mrs. Bilott. This is neurological.
你剛剛說這不是中風 You just said it wasn't a stroke.
這次真的不是 Not this time.
那說明了什麼 What does that mean?
說明他不能停止藥物治療 Well, it means that he needs to never miss his medication
並且要減少生活中的所有壓力來源 and he needs to reduce all sources of stress in his life.
他在工作中承受的壓力太大了 He's under enormous pressure at work.
好吧 這就需要調節了 Well, that needs to change.
但他還年輕 But he's a young man.
他不該出現這種情況 He shouldn't be having these incidences.
他已經服用過鎮定劑 你們可以進去看看他 He's sedated, but you can see him.
-好 -我明天早上再來看他 - Okay. - I'll check in on him tomorrow.
謝謝 謝謝 Thank you. Thank you.
我 我給你們一些私人空間 Um... I'll, uh, give you some privacy.
有任何需要 給我打電話 anything you need, call me.
我需要你別再讓他感覺自己是一個失敗者 I need you to stop making him feel like a failure.
我知道你們家庭 I appreciate the stress
必須承受的壓力 that your family must be going through.
請... Please...
別以我是一個妻子的口吻跟我講話 don't talk to me like I'm the wife.
羅伯告訴你過 他小時候經常搬家嗎 Did Rob ever tell you about, uh, moving around as a kid?
-我... -高中前搬了十次 - Um, I, uh... - Ten times before senior year.
他沒有朋友 沒有任何聯繫方式 沒有... No friends, no ties, no...
只有他自己 他的姐姐 他的親戚和... Just him, his sister, his folks and...
然後我出現了 你也出現了 Then I came along, and you came along and, uh...
塔夫特 這不僅是一份工作 Taft... it's not just a job.
對於他來說 To him, it's...
是家 it's home.
他願意為了一個需要他幫助的陌生人 And he was willing to risk all that
冒所有的風險 for a stranger who needed his help.
雖然 你和我也許不知道那是什麼 Now, you and I may not know what that is...
但那不是失敗 but it's not failure.
*你帶領著我* *And you lead me*
*駛向永恆* *In ways everlasting*
*主啊 你搜尋者我的內心* *Lord, you have searched my heart*
*你知道我什麼時候坐下 什麼時候站起* *And you know when I sit and when I stand*
*你的掌心籠罩著我* *Your hand is upon me*
*讓我遠離死亡* *Protecting me from death*
*讓我遠離傷害* *Keeping me from harm*
*哦 主啊* *Oh, Lord*
*我知道你就在這兒* *I know you are near*
*永遠站在我的身旁* *Standing always at my side*
*你守護著我...* *You guard me from the foe...*
嘿 你 你知道比分嗎 Hey, do you... do you know the score?
球賽的比分 The game?
抱歉 我的收音機壞了 Sorry, my radio's busted.
-抱歉 不知道 -沒關係 - Sorry. - Don't worry about it.
有可能會有驚喜 It'll be a surprise.
巴奇 快點 我們要晚了 Bucky, come on. We'll be late.
祝你有一個美好的夜晚 Have a good one.
嘿 羅伯 我是比爾·利瑞 Hey, Rob. Bill Leary.
我們之前沒見過 Uh, we haven't met.
我是印第安納波利斯的新審計長 I'm the new comptroller out of Indianapolis.
我們應該談談這些未計費的時間 Listen, we need to talk about your unbilled hours
和未償還的... and these un-reimbursed...
你好 Hello?
畢洛先生 Mr. Bilott?
恩 Yes?
我覺得我應該從道歉開始... I guess I should start by apologizing for taking...
-哦 這用了我七年 -請問你是誰 - well, seven years to call you. - Mm, who is this?
哦 對了 Oh, yes, of course.
我是凱倫·弗蘭科博士 來自 It's Dr. Karen Frank from the...
科學專家組 Science panel?
再次為讓您等待這麼久 Again, I'm so sorry to have
-而深表歉意 畢洛先生 -呃 - kept you waiting this long, Mr. Bilott. - Uh...
-但數據量實在是太大了 -請等一下 - But there was just so much data that... - Please, uh...
醫生 請你 你能 能先告訴我 Doctor, please, can you... would you just please tell me
之前和現在的研究進展 what-what's happened, what's happening,
-以及你 你們有什麼發現嗎 -好 好的 - what-what-what-what you've found out? - Yes, yes.
您幫我們收集到空前多的數據 You gave us an unprecedented amount of data,
在人類流行病學研究史上可謂是絕無僅有 the largest epidemiological study in human history.
這是不容置疑的 It's irrefutable.
我們已經把對C-8的持續接觸 We have linked sustained exposure to C-8
與六類嚴重疾病聯繫到了一起 to six categories of serious illness.
腎癌 Kidney cancer,
睪丸癌 甲狀腺疾病 testicular cancer, thyroid disease,
子癇前期 高膽固醇 preeclampsia, high cholesterol,
潰瘍性腸炎 ulcerative colitis.
樣本中已經有3535人患上這些疾病 3,535 people in the class already have these diseases.
還會有更多的樣本患病 Many more will develop them.
感謝你 樣本中的其他人將受到監測 Thanks to you, the entire class will be monitored,
已患病的人會得到賠償 and those who get sick can seek restitution.
你做了件大好事 畢洛先生 You did a good thing here, Mr. Bilott.
你做的是好事 You did good.
謝謝你 Thank you.
-哦 -謝謝你 - Oh. - Thank you.
多謝你 Thank you.
當心點 小心你的眼睛 Watch out, now. Watch your eyes.
哦 Oh!
拉裡·溫特
羅伯 Rob?
怎麼了 What happened?
羅伯 Rob?
杜邦公司 他們反悔了 DuPont, they're reneging.
哪方面 Which part?
全部 All of it.
他們撕毀了我們的協議 They're tearing up our agreement,
否認了科學專家組的檢測結果 rejecting the science panel.
他們 他們要 他們要 They're-they're gonna... they're gonna...
他們要在法庭上反駁所有的指控 they're gonna fight every claim in court.
幾千條指控 Thousands of claims.
普通民眾 患病的人 他們會放棄的 People, sick people, they'll give up.
他們鬥不過杜邦公司 They can't fight DuPont.
他們怎麼能違約 How can they go back o-on...?
-薩拉 -他們不能全盤違約 - Sarah. - They-they can't go back on everything.
他們可是行業巨頭 Well, they're a Titan of industry.
所以 他們想怎麼做 I mean, they can do
就能怎麼做 根本無關緊要 whatever the hell they want. Nothing else matters.
他們 他們可以隨意地攻擊你 They-they can fight you all they want.
但這總不能抹去你所做過的一切吧 It doesn't take away from what you've done.
當然可以 Of course it does.
實際上這已經發生了 That's exactly what it does.
他們想告訴整個世界 鬥爭是無用的 They want to show the world it's no use fighting.
"看啊 大家 就算是他也打破不了這規則 "Look, everybody, even he can't crack the maze,
甚至還幫著鞏固了它" and he helped build it."
整個體制都被操控著 The system is rigged.
他們想讓我們相信它會保護我們 但這是騙局 They want us to think it'll protect us, but that's a lie.
只有自己才能保護自己 只能我們自己 We protect us. We do.
沒有人能代勞 Nobody else.
企業不能 科學家們不能 Not the companies, not-not the... not the scientists,
政府也不能 只能我們自己 not the government. Us.
一個只受過高中教育的農民曾告訴過我這些 A farmer with a 12th-grade education told me that.
從一開始他就知道 但我還覺得他瘋了 On day one, he knew, and I... and I thought he was crazy.
這是瘋了嗎 Isn't that crazy?
不是 No.
科爾雷恩鎮
俄亥俄州 哥倫布市
全體起立 All rise.
尊敬的迪莫西·伯格 美國俄亥俄州 The Honorable Timothy Burg, United States District Judge
南部地區審判長 for the Southern District of Ohio presiding.
依照休庭申請 本院現在開庭 This court is now in session pursuant to the adjournment.
靜聽 靜聽 靜聽 Hear ye, hear ye, hear ye.
凡與本案有關人員 All persons having business with this honorable court,
近前坐 注意聽 其所說一切將作為呈堂證供 draw near, give their attention, and they shall be heard.
上帝保佑美國及本法庭 God save the United States and this honorable court.
請坐 Please be seated.
今早 我們在此進行陪審團審判 And we're here this morning for a jury trial.
共有3535份訴狀 So... 3,535 claims.
如果以每年四到五份的速度處理 At a rate of four or five cases a year,
幸運的話 we can all expect to be here till...
我們只需要在這裡呆到 well, the year 2890,
2890年就行了 if we're lucky.
我想可以開始了 Guess we'd better get started.
約翰遜先生 你的律師在嗎 Mrs. Johnson, is your attorney present?
早上好 法官大人 Good morning, Your Honor.
羅伯·畢洛代表原告 Rob Bilott for the plaintiff.
啊 你還在這裡 Oh, still here, huh?
堅持到底 Still here.
案件一審結果 羅伯勝訴 贏得賠償160萬美元
二審結果 贏得賠償560萬美元
三審結果 贏得賠償1250萬美元
杜邦公司最終為3535件起訴 賠償共計六億七千零七十萬美元
地球上幾乎所有生物的血液中 都能檢測出PFOA
包括99%的人類在內...
如今由於羅伯的努力 全世界興起越來越多的活動
呼籲抵制PFOA 並對600多種相關"永久性化學品"進行調查
幾乎包含所有無標準化學品...
在威爾伯·坦南特第一次走出家門的20年後
羅伯·畢洛依舊在為案件奮鬥
巴奇·貝利
達琳和喬·基格
吉姆·坦南特(威爾伯之弟)
《I won't back down》——Tom Petty
*我絕不後退* *Well, I won't Back down*
薩拉和羅伯·畢洛
*不 我絕不後退* *No, I won't back down*
*在地獄門前 你可以放我鴿子* *You can stand me up at the gates of hell*
*但我不會後退* *But I won't back down*
*處於我的立場* *Gonna stand my ground*
*就不要調轉方向* *Won't be turned around*
*我會讓這世界 不再拖我後腳* *And I'll keep this world from draggin' me down*
*處於我的立場* *Gonna stand my ground*
*我就不會退縮* *And I won't back down*
*嘿 寶貝* *Hey, baby*
*前方無輕鬆的出路可走* *There ain't no easy way out*
*嘿 我呀* *Hey, I*
*定要堅持我的立場* *Will stand my ground*
*絕對不後退* *And I won't back down*
*我知道孰是孰非* *Well, I know what's right*
*人生就這一場* *I got just one life*
*這世界 總是把我搓來滾去* *In a world that keeps on pushin' me around*
*但我依舊堅守* *But I'll stand my ground*
*不會後退* *And I won't back down*
*嘿 寶貝* *Hey, baby*
*前方無輕鬆的出路可走* *There ain't no easy way out*
*嘿 我呀* *Hey, I*
*還是會堅守立場* *Will stand my ground*
*我不會後退* *And I won't back down*
*不 我絕不後退* *No, I won't back down*